Three-Tier System Essentials: Control States

Lizzy Connolly
March 21, 2022

We’ve previously discussed the importance for producers to get licensed for the three-tier system when beginning to sell and distribute their alcoholic products. However, it’s also critical that when a supplier distributes into a new state, they first recognize if they will be selling into a “control system.”

In the control state model, state agencies become directly involved in the beverage alcohol market and are not just outside observers. The state agency will take over one, or more, of the standard “tiers” of the alcohol industry and act in the place of private business. Generally, state agencies act only as a distributor of beverage alcohol, and typically only for distilled spirits. But there are several states where they also operate retail stores, and they can control sales of wine and beer as well.

The National Alcohol Beverage Control Association (NABCA) provides a helpful guide on which states control which products and how. Beverage alcohol suppliers need to be aware of these cases, as that will have a direct impact on to whom they will sell their products (to the state, not to a private company) and how.

Here are important things to remember about control states.

Are you selling into a control state?

Suppliers first must know if they are selling into a control state, as shown below.

Suppliers must also consider the product type that they are selling into a state. For example, if you are selling spirits then you will almost certainly have to deal with a control agency, whereas if you are selling beer, that will only be relevant in Utah.

Recognize the different rules

In control states, it is critical for suppliers to recognize that the normal rules and processes that work in all-private “license” states will be different as they will be interacting directly with a state agency to sell their products.

For instance, suppliers selling to control boards won’t necessarily need to have a license. They must still register with the state or otherwise be recognized as a potential supplier. But, there often won’t be an application process to get a specific license that provides permission to interact with private businesses. Instead, it’s more about letting the control state know that you are interested in selling into it.

In addition, the actual process of advertising and selling products will be different. Instead of convincing a private distributor to pick up a valuable product, that effort will need to be made directly with the control board, which will establish unique parameters and methods for choosing which products they will accept for sale in the state. For instance, the agencies may set out specific dates when they will accept quotes and will set out the different criteria they are looking for in a valuable product (such as market share and review of sales in other states). Often, a supplier is required to submit and manage their product quotations through a registered in-state representative.

This then leads to other differences in regulatory requirements, such as brand/label registrations and follow-up shipping reports. Because a supplier will list their products directly with the state, they will not also need to file a brand/label registration for those products. Further, the state does not need to have additional documentation on those distributions because sales are already distributed directly by the state agency.

Wherefore control states?

In the immediate aftermath of Prohibition, as officials were building out new regulations for the beverage alcohol market, there was a lot of advocacy for control agencies. (Control systems were the preferred option indicated in the seminal 1933 policy guide, Toward Liquor Control.) Ultimately, less than half of states adopted a control system, while most went to the private market. But there has been remarkably little change over the years, as only Washington has moved from one to the other. However, that hasn’t stopped perennial debates about the value of a state playing a direct role in the beverage alcohol market.

Just this year, the Mississippi House passed a bill that would privatize distribution and warehousing of spirits in the state. Additionally, a Pennsylvania state representative proposed a constitutional amendment in January 2022 that would eliminate the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board. While neither of these bills is yet effective, it does show there are ongoing questions about whether control agencies are still relevant.

The control state model does not have to be one that trips up suppliers. Working with the right partner can ensure that you maintain compliance as your business expands and you enter new markets.

Take Action

Take your three-tier distribution to the next level and see how Sovos ShipCompliant’s Market Ready solution can streamline your compliance processes.

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.

Author

Lizzy Connolly

Share This Post
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

North America ShipCompliant
June 30, 2022
New Rules for RTDs in Vermont – Including DtC Shipping

On July 1, 2022, Vermont Act 177 takes effect, creating new ways to sell Ready-to-Drink (RTD) spirits in the state, including permission for distillers to ship these products direct-to-consumer (DtC). As defined in the act, “RTD Spirits Beverages” are alcoholic beverages obtained from distillation that contain no more than 12% ABV and are packaged in containers […]

North America ShipCompliant
June 30, 2022
Compliance Concerns for Importers

Within the three-tier system that governs how alcohol is sold and distributed within the United States, importers are considered a type of supplier. As such, they are largely regulated like domestic producers, meaning they must distribute through wholesalers, who will sell to the retailers, where customers will finally be able to purchase the importer’s products. […]

North America ShipCompliant
June 29, 2022
What States Do Not Allow Alcohol to be Shipped?

The direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping model is growing in popularity, as the DtC wine channel recently broke the $4 billion per year mark, and 92% of craft beer drinkers are looking to order their favorite brews to the front door. It’s no surprise that producers, retailers and other potential shippers are itching to meet the growing […]

EMEA Tax Compliance VAT & Fiscal Reporting
June 28, 2022
What is Indirect Representation, and How Does it Affect UK Businesses?

According to European Customs Law, non-EU established businesses must appoint a representative for customs purposes when importing goods into the EU. In particular, the Union Customs Code establishes that non-EU resident businesses must appoint an indirect representative. At the end of the Brexit transitionary period, many UK businesses suddenly needed to appoint an indirect representative […]

E-Invoicing Compliance EMEA
June 28, 2022
Romania: Questions Remain as Deadline Looms

Romania has been taking steps toward introducing a continuous transaction controls (CTC) mandate since 2021. Although the Romanian tax authority only established the legal framework for implementing the e-invoicing system less than a year ago, it is set to go live soon. At the same time, the e-transport system, introduced even later, will also be […]