Mexico’s Supreme Court Upholds Amparos, But Stay Is Temporary

Steve Sprague
September 27, 2016

When Mexico announced its eContabilidad (eAccounting) legislation in 2014, several multinational companies filed a lawsuit, stating that the requirements were unconstitutional, technically unsound, and unfeasible. Many were granted amparos – legal stays delaying the electronic filing requirement – and the case recently made its way to the Supreme Court. In its July 2016 verdict, the court continued the amparos for technical reasons, but it ultimately found the fiscal email, eContabilidad and Mexico’s impending electronic audits constitutional. That means required compliance with this legislation is just a matter of time for the companies that are currently exempt.

Because the XML schema required under eContabilidad was written in English and was created by a third-party, the Supreme Court upheld the amparo in question. However, we have every reason to believe that these exemptions will be nullified as soon as the tax authority modifies the schema, meaning that companies leveraging amparo should be prepared to comply with eContabilidad soon.

Despite granting this particular provision, the Supreme Court upheld the right of Mexico’s tax authority (the SAT) to mandate the fiscal email, eContabilidad and employ electronic audits. The court made a point to say that not only do companies have the technical capabilities to comply with the laws, but that these mandates actually facilitate the fiscal compliance of taxpayers by expediting collection and verification processes, ultimately preventing unnecessary audits.

In the wake of this ruling, Mexico’s tax authority revealed more details about its electronic audits, which are scheduled to begin this month. If the SAT detects inconsistencies between declared income and taxes and the electronic documents received, it will trigger an automated notice to the taxpayer. Taxpayers then have 15 days to respond or dispute the charge. Those found in violation will face a fine of 20% of taxes owed. More details on the process can be found here.

In sum, amparos are not a permanent defense from the fiscal email, eContabilidad and electronic audits. Even companies that currently hold these stays must have the documentation required available to validate VAT deductions and in the event of an audit, and submitting these documents electronically is imminent. When your amparo runs out, will you be prepared?

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.


Steve Sprague

Como director comercial, Steve Sprague dirige la estrategia corporativa, las iniciativas de penetración de mercado y de field enablement para el negocio del impuesto sobre el valor añadido global (GVAT) de la empresa. El estilo de liderazgo de Steve se basa en su convicción de que, para que las organizaciones tengan éxito, deben comprometerse e invertir en los tres pilares estratégicos de la empresa: las personas, las prácticas y los productos.
Share This Post

North America Sales & Use Tax
June 5, 2023
Sovos Onboarding: 6 Departments Dedicated to Customer Success

If you are evaluating Sovos, we want you to understand expectations for the customer experience and what teams are there to support you. At Sovos, we have a range of teams ready to support you from the day you sign a contract. Whether it be a customer success representative to review the value you are […]

North America Sales & Use Tax
June 1, 2023
3 Things to Remember if You Get a Sales Tax Notice

Have you ever received a sales tax notice from a state department of revenue? Whether you answered yes or no, there are important things to keep top of mind to help keep your business prepared. Finding out that you have failed to comply with one or more of your sales tax obligations can be startling. […]

North America Unclaimed Property
May 30, 2023
How to Set Up a Successful Unclaimed Property Program

Unclaimed property compliance can be difficult and overwhelming. Clients often ask what they should be doing to ensure they are compliant with the various laws and regulations. It isn’t easy, especially if you have multiple property types such as checks, credits or customer accounts that have the potential to become unclaimed property in multiple states. […]

North America ShipCompliant
May 30, 2023
How Hold At Locations Improve Your Customers’ Wine Delivery Experience

Direct-to-consumer shipping wine lovers enjoy the convenience of having their favorite vinos shipped to their front door. But what happens when, for whatever reason, they aren’t available to accept their wine deliveries? Whether they aren’t available during the day or they don’t have someone 21 or older available to sign for their package, these challenges […]

North America Sales & Use Tax
May 30, 2023
Identifying Sales Tax Liabilities and Why They Matter

By Steve Claflin, CLA It’s incredible that it has now been five years since the landmark Wayfair decision. It seems like just yesterday we were reading the case, alerting clients and tracking the ever-developing state guidance. Unfortunately, many companies still are not familiar with their sales tax filing obligations caused by economic nexus, or they […]