Leading Sales Tax Expert, Charles Maniace, Comments on South Dakota v. Wayfair Supreme Court Decision

Charles Maniace
June 21, 2018

On what was easily the most anticipated day in sales tax history, the Supreme Court did what many experts thought they would, ruling five to four in favor of South Dakota’s right to require businesses to collect and remit sales tax on all sales, including e-commerce, even if they don’t have people or property in the state.

In so doing, the Court ushered in a new era for sales tax, overruling Quill Corporation vs. North Dakota, a decades-old legal precedent. This ruling opens the door for governments to collect more than $8 billion dollars in tax from e-commerce sales that were previously off limits.

(Join us for a Live Expert Q&A Web Event on Wayfair vs South Dakota next week.)

We asked our resident sales tax guru and the head of our regulatory analysis team, Charles Maniace, for his initial reactions. Here’s what Chuck had to say:

“We are officially in a new era of sales tax. What we have considered to be foundational principles that define where businesses must collect and remit sales tax, are now entirely out the window. States now have almost a blank slate on which to write, and businesses will face a wave of new rules for tax compliance.”

There is, however, still a standard for when businesses will have to charge and remit tax: a ‘substantial nexus.’ What does and does not qualify as substantial nexus will be defined over the next few years, but what we do know is that ‘substantial’ no longer means ‘physical,’ and that’s a huge change.”

What do e-commerce sellers need to know?

“Any business that sells through e-commerce should pay close attention to state rules, especially in the 20 states that have introduced the same or similar rules as South Dakota. Businesses that sell through e-commerce channels will need watch each state in to which they sell goods for new laws that are sure to come quickly, and they will have to monitor whether those states’ will be litigated under this revived standard set by Complete Auto Transit, Inc. v. Brady and Pike v. Bruce Church Inc.”

What should we expect from the states now?

“States now have the ability to articulate that they have a reasonable standard to establish whether a business has substantial nexus that would require it to pay sales tax. In order to pass this standard, the rule must be reasonable and tax compliance must be manageable. The Court was clear to point out that South Dakota created a standard that does not burden commerce. They have a fairly simplified and uniform sales tax structure, their nexus law excludes small sellers, and as a Member State of the Streamlined Sales tax Agreement, they provide taxpayers with affordable software solutions.”

What role will software play moving forward?

“In today’s ruling, the Supreme Court discusses software as a means for easing the burdens of sales tax on businesses of all sizes, which seemed to be a key factor in the ruling. It’s clear the court appreciated the nature of the South Dakota rule, which set a clear threshold for substantial presence and simplified its sales tax regime, including years of work as a member of the streamlined sales tax initiative, of which Sovos has been a part of for more than a decade. This ruling makes it clear that software is an important part of making sales tax compliance manageable and affordable, and as the ruling mentions, many reliable and affordable solutions are currently available from vendors like Sovos. This ruling should drive further adoption of software, particularly among smaller businesses that have largely flown under the radar until now.”

What’s next in the regulatory environment?

“We’ll likely see states quickly enacting existing rules and drafting new ones, but congress is the wild card. Everyone is waiting to see if they will step in to create a standard, which they have a right to do, or leave it to the states.”

Stay tuned for more news, analysis and resources from Sovos. And, sign up now for our upcoming webinar that will outline all the impacts and what’s next for e-commerce sales tax

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.

Author

Charles Maniace

Charles Maniace is Vice President – Regulatory Analysis & Design at Sovos. An attorney by trade, Chuck leads a team of attorneys responsible for all the tax and regulatory content that keeps Sovos clients continually compliant. Over his 14 year career in tax and regulatory automation, he has given talks and presentations on a variety of topics including The Taxation of High Tech Transactions, The Taxation of Remote Commerce, The Regulatory Implications of Brexit, The Rise of E-Audits, Form 1042-S Best Practices and Penalty Abatement Practices for Information Returns. Chuck is a member of the Massachusetts Bar and holds a B.S. in Business Economics from Bentley College, a J.D. from Boston University School of Law, and an LL.M in Taxation from Boston University School of Law.
Share This Post

Tax Compliance Tax Information Reporting United States
January 14, 2020
See the Latest IRS FY19 Updates on Crypto and Gig Economy Enforcement

The IRS commissioner Chuck Rettig issued the agency’s FY19 updates last month, which included updates on compliance and education initiatives aimed at the emerging gig and crypto industries.   Publication 5382 was released in December to provide taxpayers with updates on the IRS’  FY19 goals. Of the six goals discussed in the report, goal two promised […]

E-Invoicing Compliance EMEA Italy
January 14, 2020
A New Countdown to NSO – Italy’s Electronic Purchase Orders Platform

On 27 December 2019, the Italian government issued a decree delaying and establishing new dates for when the NSO platform would go live.  The Purchase Orders Routing Node platform (Nodo di Smistamento degli Ordini, NSO) had initially been scheduled to be effective on 1 October 2019. The NSO is the Italian government owned platform through […]

EMEA VAT & Fiscal Reporting
January 14, 2020
Recent Developments: Complex Reporting Requirements in the European Union

Digital tax reporting requirements have arrived and are here to stay.  As the global VAT gap continues to grow (estimated to be as high as half a trillion EUR), countries are increasingly using complex reporting requirements to gain insight into VAT activities.  In this rapidly changing environment, it’s of utmost importance for companies to ensure […]

EMEA IPT Tax Compliance
January 8, 2020
Technology Enhancements in Insurance

The insurance world is often seen as slow and reluctant to fully embrace technology. However, new competition from the growing number of insurtech companies and the digitisation of reporting to local authorities are forcing insurers to wake up to the wave of technology transformation the sector is experiencing. Still, people behind technology remain key. Perhaps […]

Tax Information Reporting United States
January 8, 2020
Your Guide to Posting Unclaimed Property Advertisements in New York

Not all states have the same requirements for completing an unclaimed property state report. The state of New York requires that certain companies publish unclaimed property information in newspapers in the form of advertisements. It is important to note the advertising does not replace the need to send due diligence letters. Both advertising and due […]