New York and Virtual Currency: A Semi-Taxable “Barter” Transaction

Sovos
January 7, 2015

When virtual currency is used to purchase other items or services, a semi-taxable “barter” transaction has arisen in New York.

Bitcoin and other virtual currencies have been a hot topic as of late, and it seems that New York has decided to address this issue with respect to sales tax.  Previously, the IRS had held that bitcoins were a type of property.  New York has gone ahead and held that digital currencies are “intangible personal property” and as a result not subject to tax when purchased or redeemed for actual currency.

However, bitcoin users should be aware that when virtual currency is used to purchase other items or services, a semi-taxable “barter” transaction has arisen in New York.   The New York Department of Taxation and Finance has indicated that receipt of virtual currency does not result in sales or use tax liability.  However, a person who receives taxable services or tangible personal property in return for virtual currency will still be required to pay sales tax on the items received.   The examples New York provides in its technical memorandum, TSB-M-14(5)C,(7)I, (17)S, indicate that when virtual currency is provided as payment, the retailer or service must separately state the sales tax due, and the consumer or user of the tangible personal property or services will have to remit sales tax.  Furthermore businesses which accept virtual currency will have to report and register for sales taxes as well.  In conclusion, when bitcoins are used to actually carry out a sale, only actual tangible personal property’s value will be subject to sales and use tax.

This clarification on bitcoins solidifies the position the IRS took on virtual currency earlier in the year.  New York is now jumping into the arena and virtual currency is destined to become more regulated going forward. Taxware is monitoring this situation, as virtual currency becomes a more accepted form of currency going forward.

Have Questions?

Taxware Systems support content related to beverages and beverage syrups. For more information please contact Taxware or Ask a Tax Expert today.

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.

Author

Sovos

Sovos is a global provider of tax, compliance and trust solutions and services that enable businesses to navigate an increasingly regulated world with true confidence. Purpose-built for always-on compliance capabilities, our scalable IT-driven solutions meet the demands of an evolving and complex global regulatory landscape. Sovos’ cloud-based software platform provides an unparalleled level of integration with business applications and government compliance processes. More than 100,000 customers in 100+ countries – including half the Fortune 500 – trust Sovos for their compliance needs. Sovos annually processes more than three billion transactions across 19,000 global tax jurisdictions. Bolstered by a robust partner program more than 400 strong, Sovos brings to bear an unrivaled global network for companies across industries and geographies. Founded in 1979, Sovos has operations across the Americas and Europe, and is owned by Hg and TA Associates.
Share this post

North America
June 6, 2024
Observations and Predictions: The Future of Tax and Compliance

When I became the CEO of Sovos one year ago, I knew that I was stepping into an innovative company in an industry primed for a seismic transformation. However, even with this knowledge in place, I must admit that the speed and scope of change over the past year has been extraordinary to witness. Here […]

EMEA IPT
July 8, 2024
Hungary Insurance Premium Tax (IPT): An Overview

Regarding calculating Insurance Premium Tax (IPT), Hungary is the only country in the EU where the regime uses the so-called sliding scale rate model.

North America ShipCompliant
July 3, 2024
The Prospects and Perils of AI in Beverage Alcohol

I recently had the privilege of speaking on a panel at the National Conference of State Liquor Administrators (NCSLA) Annual Conference, a regular meeting of regulators, attorneys and other members of the beverage alcohol industry to discuss important issues affecting our trade. Alongside Claire Mitchell, of Stoel Rives, and Erlinda Doherty, of Vinicola Consulting, and […]

North America ShipCompliant
June 27, 2024
Shifting Focus: How to Make Wine Country Interesting to Millennials

Guest blog written by Susan DeMatei, President, WineGlass Marketing WineGlass Marketing recently conducted a study to explore how Millennials and Gen X feel about wine, wine culture and wine country. The goal was to gain insight into how we can make wine, wine club and wine country appealing to these new audiences. We’ll showcase in-depth […]

North America Sales & Use Tax
June 24, 2024
Illinois to Adjust Sales Tax Nexus Rules in Light of PetMeds Threat

Illinois is poised to change their sourcing rules again, trying to find their way in a world where states apply their sales tax compliance requirements equally to both in-state and remote sellers. With this tweak, they will effectively equalize the responsibilities of remote sellers with no in-state presence, to those that have an Illinois location. […]

EMEA VAT & Fiscal Reporting
June 21, 2024
ViDA Rejected Again – Europe Misses Another Chance to Harmonize e-Invoicing

During the latest ECOFIN meeting on 21 June, Member States met to discuss if they could come to an agreement to implement the VAT in the Digital Age (ViDA) proposals. At the ECOFIN meeting in May, Estonia objected to the platform rules being proposed, instead requesting to make the new deemed supplier rules optional (an […]