Federal Trade Commission speech shows support for direct shipping

Sovos
November 15, 2005

In a speech by Commissioner Jon Leibowitz titled Competition in the Information Society Uncorked and Unplugged, Leibowitz provides some great insight into interstate wine laws. I would encourage you to read this speech in its entirety, but here are a few choice passages:

the Internet is crucial to consumers. Barriers to e-commerce – whether erected by the state or around the state; west of the Atlantic, or on the Continent, locally, or across borders – have the potential to undermine the promise of the Internet that we as a global society have worked so hard to nurture, and that many of you here today have made a part of your work.

Commerce in the U.S.– and this includes the wine industry – is most often regulated at the state level, because business traditionally has been transacted on a local basis. States have a compelling interest in ensuring that transactions conducted within their borders are fair, that their consumers are protected from fraud and deception, and that consumers receive the best quality goods at competitive prices.

The advent of the Internet, however, has turned local commerce into a national – and often times international – affair. Consumers now have convenient access to a wide array of goods that are produced outside the borders of their home states – or countries. While this is unquestionably of great benefit to consumers, it has also amplified regulatory concerns – and concerns by local “bricks and mortar” retailers, who often feel “squeezed” by Internet-based competition.

Most wine in the United States is distributed through a complicated distribution network, which was developed after the repeal of Prohibition (a 13 year nationwide ban on consumption of alcohol in the U.S.) in 1933. Under this system, a wine producer must first obtain a permit from the federal government. The wine then must sold to a licensed wholesaler, who delivers the wine to a retailer. The retailer may then sell the wine directly to a consumer. Most states prohibit vertical integration among these three tiers.

This is, according to some, the most expensive distribution system of any U.S. packaged goods industry by far.

The FTC took a close look at this issue and concluded in its Wine Report that bans on direct shipping of wine prevented consumers from saving as much as 21 percent.

He also backs our earlier argument that shipments to minors can be avoided by forcing the common carriers to require an adult signature on delivery.

Many of those supporting the restrictions claimed that they are necessary to prevent underage drinkers (in the U.S., those under 21 years of age) from receiving direct shipments of wine. However, these concerns could be addressed by simply requiring a signature from a qualified adult upon delivery. In fact, the Commission’s study found that of the states that allowed direct shipping, most reported few or no problems with shipments to minors.

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.

Author

Sovos

Sovos is a leading global provider of software that safeguards businesses from the burden and risk of modern transactional taxes. As VAT and sales and use tax go digital, businesses face increased risks, costs and complexity. The Sovos Intelligent Compliance Cloud is the first complete solution for modern tax, giving businesses a global solution for tax determination, e-invoicing compliance and tax reporting. Sovos supports more than 7,000 customers, including half of the Fortune 500, and integrates with a wide variety of business applications. The company has offices throughout North America, Latin America and Europe. Sovos is owned by London-based Hg. For more information visit www.sovos.com and follow us on LinkedIn and Twitter.
Share This Post
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

North America VAT & Fiscal Reporting
September 21, 2021
Looking to Cut Tax Compliance Costs? Consider Tax Solutions Before Migrating to SAP S/4HANA

As the digitization of tax continues, many organizations are looking to reduce the complexity and cost of tax compliance. In our latest spotlight report, created in partnership with Americas’  SAP Users’ Group (ASUG), “Boost Tax Compliance Capabilities and Visibility with SAP S/4HANA”, we discuss the most optimal time in the SAP S/4HANA migration process to […]

EMEA VAT & Fiscal Reporting
September 21, 2021
Fiscal Representation Post-Brexit – Requirements for UK Companies Trading in the EU

Non-EU companies are required to appoint a Fiscal Representative in order to be registered for VAT in many Member States. Following the end of the Brexit transition agreement on 31 December 2021, this was a consideration for UK companies who wanted to remain registered or had to register as a result of changes to supply […]

E-Invoicing Compliance EMEA VAT & Fiscal Reporting
September 16, 2021
French E-invoicing Mandate Update: Government Revises Rollout Schedule

When the French Tax Authority published its report last fall, unveiling the continuous transaction control (CTC) plans for France, we questioned whether it would be possible to finalise all the details of this system in less than a year, to allow sufficient time for businesses to adapt. Although the French Treasury (DGFiP) has made good […]

E-Invoicing Compliance EMEA VAT & Fiscal Reporting
September 16, 2021
Saudi Arabia’s E-Invoicing Mandate is Fast Approaching

The Zakat, Tax and Customs Authority (ZATCA) announced the finalised rules for the Saudi Arabia e-invoicing system earlier this year, announcing plans for two main phases for the new e-invoicing system. The first phase of the Saudi Arabia e-invoicing system is set to go live from 4 December 2021. With the mandate just around the […]

EMEA VAT & Fiscal Reporting
September 15, 2021
EU E-Commerce VAT Package FAQs: Understanding Marketplace Liability

The EU E-Commerce VAT Package is here. The new schemes, One Stop Shop (OSS) and Import One Stop Shop (IOSS) bring significant changes to VAT treatment and reporting mechanisms for sales to private individuals in the EU. Our recent webinar, Back to Basics: The EU E-Commerce VAT Package, discussed the basic principles of the three […]