Federal Trade Commission speech shows support for direct shipping

November 15, 2005

In a speech by Commissioner Jon Leibowitz titled Competition in the Information Society Uncorked and Unplugged, Leibowitz provides some great insight into interstate wine laws. I would encourage you to read this speech in its entirety, but here are a few choice passages:

the Internet is crucial to consumers. Barriers to e-commerce – whether erected by the state or around the state; west of the Atlantic, or on the Continent, locally, or across borders – have the potential to undermine the promise of the Internet that we as a global society have worked so hard to nurture, and that many of you here today have made a part of your work.

Commerce in the U.S.– and this includes the wine industry – is most often regulated at the state level, because business traditionally has been transacted on a local basis. States have a compelling interest in ensuring that transactions conducted within their borders are fair, that their consumers are protected from fraud and deception, and that consumers receive the best quality goods at competitive prices.

The advent of the Internet, however, has turned local commerce into a national – and often times international – affair. Consumers now have convenient access to a wide array of goods that are produced outside the borders of their home states – or countries. While this is unquestionably of great benefit to consumers, it has also amplified regulatory concerns – and concerns by local “bricks and mortar” retailers, who often feel “squeezed” by Internet-based competition.

Most wine in the United States is distributed through a complicated distribution network, which was developed after the repeal of Prohibition (a 13 year nationwide ban on consumption of alcohol in the U.S.) in 1933. Under this system, a wine producer must first obtain a permit from the federal government. The wine then must sold to a licensed wholesaler, who delivers the wine to a retailer. The retailer may then sell the wine directly to a consumer. Most states prohibit vertical integration among these three tiers.

This is, according to some, the most expensive distribution system of any U.S. packaged goods industry by far.

The FTC took a close look at this issue and concluded in its Wine Report that bans on direct shipping of wine prevented consumers from saving as much as 21 percent.

He also backs our earlier argument that shipments to minors can be avoided by forcing the common carriers to require an adult signature on delivery.

Many of those supporting the restrictions claimed that they are necessary to prevent underage drinkers (in the U.S., those under 21 years of age) from receiving direct shipments of wine. However, these concerns could be addressed by simply requiring a signature from a qualified adult upon delivery. In fact, the Commission’s study found that of the states that allowed direct shipping, most reported few or no problems with shipments to minors.

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.



Sovos was built to solve the complexities of the digital transformation of tax, with complete, connected offerings for tax determination, continuous transaction controls, tax reporting and more. Sovos customers include half the Fortune 500, as well as businesses of every size operating in more than 70 countries. The company’s SaaS products and proprietary Sovos S1 Platform integrate with a wide variety of business applications and government compliance processes. Sovos has employees throughout the Americas and Europe, and is owned by Hg and TA Associates.
Share This Post

Latin America Tax Compliance VAT & Fiscal Reporting
March 22, 2023
Argentina: New Perception VAT Regime on Sale of Food and Products for Human Consumption

Argentina has recently expanded its perception VAT (Value Added Tax) collection regime to ensure efficient tax administration. It has included selling food and other products for human consumption, beverages, personal hygiene, and cleaning items under its scope. The Argentinian Federal Administration of Public Revenue (AFIP) established this through Resolution No. 5329/2023 in early February 2023. […]

North America Tax Information Reporting
March 22, 2023
What is the Combined Federal State Filing (CF/SF) Program?

The IRS created the Combined Federal State Filing (CF/SF) program more than 20 years ago to help alleviate the administrative burdens on small businesses reporting 1099 information to states. This program integrates federal and state filings. The IRS uses information filed in federal filings and then forwards relevant information to states on a business’ behalf. […]

Italy VAT & Fiscal Reporting
March 21, 2023
Pre-filled Italian Annual VAT return – an innovative change

On 10 February 2023, the Italian Tax Authority introduced the possibility for 2.4 million professionals and companies to view and download the pre-filled Annual VAT declaration related to transactions carried out in 2022. This return must be submitted by 2 May 2023. Who does this impact? The service is available for taxpayers defined by the […]

North America Unclaimed Property
March 16, 2023
California Begins Voluntary Compliance Program Rollout

The California Voluntary Compliance Program (VCP) is now available, according to an announcement from the California State Controller. For the first time, we are hearing from the State Controller’s Office (SCO) regarding the VCP authorized by the California legislature in September 2022. The announcement on the SCO’s website provides guidance concerning the upcoming program and […]

North America ShipCompliant
March 15, 2023
A Continued ‘Normalization’ in DtC Wine Shipping – What Does That Mean?

Sovos ShipCompliant’s recent 2023 Direct-to-Consumer (DtC) Wine Shipping Report, released with our partner Wines Vines Analytics, showed the first-ever decline in both value (-1.6%) and volume (-10.3%) of shipments. While these numbers are concerning, it’s important to look at the industry in its entirety and keep in mind the overall context of pandemic responses from […]