North America
Book a Call

Direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of wine comes in two general categories: on-site and off-site. Both ultimately involve the use of a third-party common carrier to fulfill an order by a consumer, but they differ in how the consumer places their order.

“On-site” DtC shipments are those where the consumer was physically present at the winery’s premises when they bought the wine; “off-site” shipments are remote orders, ones made through the internet, a phone call or a club.

Generally, the distinction between on-site and off-site orders is not critical. But there are some states that apply different rules on how wine can be DtC shipped within their borders depending on how the order was placed, which a winery engaged in DtC wine shipping would need to recognize.

How are on-site and off-site orders regulated differently?

Both on-site and off-site orders ultimately involve the transportation of alcohol, often across state borders, and so they must abide by the laws of the jurisdiction where the alcohol will be consumed. That is, the state where the consumer will take possession of the wine sets out the legal conditions under which the wine can be shipped to the consumer. These requirements often involve licensing, limits on how much can be shipped and tax obligations for the winery.

It is important to note that no state allows a private individual to ship wine themselves, even when that is a consumer simply trying to ship wine they bought on vacation back to their home. While most states do permit citizens to personally import small amounts of alcohol for their own consumption, they also require this to be done through a personal import. That is, the consumer must maintain physical possession of the alcohol—either carrying it in the trunk of their car or in their checked luggage—throughout the process. Only authorized entities can use common carriers to ship alcohol to consumers’ residences.

This means that when a consumer does make an on-site order—say while touring through Napa or the Williamette Valley or the Finger Lakes—if they want to have that order brought to their home through a common carrier, the winery will have to handle the shipping for the consumer, and must do so in full compliance with the laws of the state where the consumer lives.

In most cases, the rules for shipping an on-site order are the same as those for shipping an off-site order. The licenses will be the same, the volume limits will be the same, the tax obligations on the winery will be the same (this is because when wine is DtC shipped, in almost all cases it is then deemed by law to be a sale in the destination state, meaning the destination state’s taxes apply).

However, there are a few states that distinguish between on-site and off-site DtC shipments of wine.

Rhode Island and Arkansas only permit on-site DtC shipments of wine, so consumers in these states may not place orders online or via other remote sources. Rhode Island’s law extends to all types of alcoholic beverages, giving more options for tourists from the Ocean State. Arkansas, unlike Rhode Island, only permits wine shipping and requires any winery that will fulfill their on-site orders to have received a license first and to remit the state’s excise tax on their shipments.

Delaware is often listed among the few states that don’t allow any DtC shipping, but technically the state does allow consumers to receive shipments of wine through what is called “federal on-site” shipping. This comes from a provision originally found in the Patriot Act, which sets out that states that permit personal importation of wine but do not have rules for DtC shipping of wine must allow residents to have any wine they purchased while out of the state shipped back to their homes, in lieu of being able to carry it onto their flights. However, this rule is overlooked and little used as most other states have simply adopted effective DtC shipping laws.

Georgia, Kansas and North Carolina all permit both on-site and off-site DtC shipping of wine, but only require licenses and taxes for off-site orders. Further, while each state has a limit on how much wine sold off-site a winery can ship to a resident, those limits do not apply to on-site DtC shipments. Georgia and North Carolina set a separate limit for on-site sales, but Kansas has no limit on how much a Kansas resident can have shipped to their home, as long as it was purchased on-site.

Besides these few states, though, the rules for shipping wine sold on-site or off-site do not differ. And then for Georgia, Kansas and North Carolina, the different rules may not be all that helpful for a winery. Unless a winery commits to only fulfilling on-site sales in these states, it would still need to get a DtC license and comply with most of the state’s laws for their off-site sales. While it may be nice to avoid some tax payments or ship “extra” packages of wine, it may end up being more of a hassle to distinguish the different sales and apply the different rules.

Nevertheless, the “on-site” v. “off-site” distinction remains a part of the DtC wine shipping market, and at least at a high level, wineries need to recognize the difference. And as other beverage alcohol categories look to expand their own DtC shipping permission and pull from the established rules for shipping wine, it is possible that these different types of ordering alcohol will gain new relevancy.

Take Action

Ready to get a handle on DtC shipping compliance? Learn more with ShipCompliant Direct.

A wide variety of speakers and presentations addressed some of the major issues affecting the wine industry at the 2023 Sovos ShipCompliant Wine Summit, which took place in Napa on April 19-20. Some of the highlights from the 18th annual event are presented below.

Sovos ShipCompliant updates

Larry Cormier, vice president and general manager, Sovos ShipCompliant and Lexie O’Neill, director of product management, Sovos ShipCompliant, provided a look at developments in ShipCompliant over the last year, including a refreshed user experience and improvements to the software’s reliability and scalability. The audience was particularly appreciative to hear more about the addition of Ohio to the rank of states using the Product Registration Online service in 2022.

Keynote: cannabis and wine

Arun Kurichety, COO and General Counsel for Petalfast, presented on the cannabis industry as compared to wine, including the complex regulatory schemas under which they operate and their respective roles as social lubricants. Arun made sure not to shy away from the areas where there is potential conflict between the growing cannabis industry and wine, such as competition for consumers and fears of agricultural contamination. But the overall message was that both industries can stand to learn from each other, cannabis on how to manage their compliance needs and expand legal sales opportunities, and wine on how to attract a younger audience and adapt to changing consumer desires.

State of the wine industry

Steve Gross, VP of State Relations for Wine Institute, provided his much-anticipated presentation on the state of the direct-to-consumer (DtC) wine shipping industry and updates on recent regulatory changes. Steve recognized the work of Wine Institute and Free the Grapes! over the last year, including minimizing the impact from regulatory burdens placed on fulfillment houses and carriers involved in DtC shipping, and efforts to improve the licensing process in Alabama. Looking forward in 2023, Steve was bullish on a push to remove New Jersey’s production cap on who can ship wine DtC, the last such cap active in the country. He also reminded the audience of Alaska’s recent DtC law changes, which will add licensing and tax requirements effective January 1, 2024, and a plan to establish similar requirements in Minnesota.

Updates from regulators

Mari Kirrane, Wine Trade & Technical Advisor for the Tax & Trade Bureau (TTB), provided an update from the TTB for the wine industry, noting the expansion to the TTB’s Cincinnati office as a center for permitting and taxation processing and the implementation of new rules and online tools for importers to take advantage of the tax relief found in the Craft Beverage Modernization Act (more information on this and other TTB guidance can be found in their library of past industry presentations).

Matt Botting and Ryan Mercurio, General Counsel for the California ABC and Commission Counsel for the Tennessee ABC, respectively, joined us to discuss new and ongoing compliance issues in their states. Of key concern for these states has been managing the rise of new sales and delivery options, such as cocktails-to-go, which present novel regulatory scenarios for enforcement agents. Their overall message to wineries was to take the time to properly understand how a prospective sales model would work and whether it is allowed under the permissions granted by the state under the license(s) owned by the winery.

Legal professionals’ take on wine regulation

Suhani Kamdar, Senior Associate with Rogers Joshep O’Donnell, and Susan Johnson, Partner at Stoel Rives LLP, spoke on developments in wine marketing and distribution and how wineries can better understand what is and is not allowed under state and federal law. Central to their discussion was the message that almost all aspects of the wine industry are subject to regulation and that just because there is a “new” way of doing something doesn’t mean that there is free rein. As wineries engage more and more with social media and working with influencers, they need to recognize that the “old” laws still apply, and that what has traditionally applied in print or other media also applies online. Ultimately, if a winery is concerned, there is never any harm with consulting with a legal expert first.

Subscription models versus traditional wine clubs

Susan DeMatei, President of WineGlass Marketing, shared insights on subscription models and how they represent a sea change from traditional wine clubs. While wine clubs worked well for the Baby Boomer generation, which appreciated the sense of exclusivity and belonging that came from being part of a club, that model may not work as well for young generations, which have bought into the subscription model for items from makeup to household goods to pet supplies. By offering a more bespoke approach that allows regular customers to opt in or out, or adjust an order to suit their tastes, wineries can make themselves more attractive to new consumers.

How your budgeting process supports your sales goals

Maria Pearman, Advisory Principal at GHJ, presented key budget management tools and techniques that wineries can implement to better track their operations and planning. Central to any effective budgeting approach is a unified plan that recognizes the individual talents and expertise of the winery’s team. Maria demonstrated several different budgeting methods that a winery could adopt, but ultimately the one that will work the best is the one that has the buy-in from team members and that enables that team to succeed.

Using data to better understand your customers

MJ Dale, Founder and CEO of Customer Vineyard, discussed the importance of thorough data analysis in developing a winery’s sales strategies. By recognizing key insights from sales data—such as where most consumers live or which group of consumers buy the most wine (as opposed to the most expensive wines)—a winery can more effectively and efficiently set out a course of action that is suited to their sales goals.

As Larry Cormier noted in his opening remarks, we at Sovos ShipCompliant hold a privileged position as a hub for much of the domestic wine market. In supporting the distribution and DtC shipping compliance needs for our users, we gap the arcana of regulatory interpretation with the everyday realities of moving wine around the country. The annual Wine Summit, then, is our opportunity to bring these worlds together in one room and help bring greater understanding to the industry. For helping us do that, we once again thank all of our fantastic speakers and our attendees who honored us with their presence. We hope everyone will join us again next year!

Take Action

Subscribe to the Sovos ShipCompliant blog and never miss an industry update.

Earlier this week, Nebraska lawmakers passed a bill that would update the state’s liquor laws. State Senator John Lowe introduced LB376, which passed with a 41-0 vote.

Under the bill, Nebraska will now create a brand registration for the state’s Liquor Control Commission to accurately identify and track alcoholic products imported into the state. This new brand registration requirement will become effective January 1, 2024 and will apply to all alcohol products imported into the state for either three-tier distribution or direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping. Registration will need to be completed by the Primary American Source or authorized brand dealer (who will need to certify their authorization) of the product, who will need to indicate their Nebraska wholesaler and pay a fee.

As reported by the Nebraska Legislature, provisions for five other bills were also included in the passed legislation:

It’s important to note the new product registration requirement for primary American source suppliers prior to bringing any product into Nebraska. This will apply to all products and any time a product will be shipped into Nebraska, including DtC and three-tier sales. Currently, Nebraska allows for DtC shipping of wine, beer and spirits.

With the new registration part of the law not going into effect until the start of 2024, Nebraska can utilize all of 2023 to further develop its specific process and forms for the legislation’s requirements.

Take Action

Subscribe to the Sovos ShipCompliant blog to stay current on the latest beverage alcohol updates.

For craft beer lovers, expanded direct-to-consumer (DtC) beer shipping is at the top of their wish list, according to the third annual Direct to Consumer Beer Shipping Report. Released last month by Sovos ShipCompliant in partnership with the Brewers Association, the data showed that 88% of regular craft beer drinkers believe there should be greater legal access to DtC beer shipping. However, as of March 2023, just 11 states and Washington, D.C. allow it.

But what can actually be done to help make a change? And could beer really benefit from consumers having products shipped directly to their front doors the same way that wine does?

Even with inflation, the DtC desire is there

The beer world is hardly immune from economic turmoil, including the rising costs of inflation. As reported by Brewbound, the Consumer Price Index (CPI) for beer both at home (+6.1%) and away from home (+5.5%) outpaced overall inflation (+5%) in March 2023 compared to March 2022, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. However, even with increased prices, the desire clearly exists for DtC beer shipping. Nearly three-quarters (72%) of regular craft beer drinkers would spend $50 or more per month if they could for craft beer to be shipped directly to their home, according to the Sovos ShipCompliant Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report. Additionally, 51% would spend $100 or more per month.

Our own Product Registration Online (PRO) new product registrations numbers also showed continued quarter-over-quarter growth for the beer/malt category in February 2023. The beer categories increased 4% year-over-year and had a 39% quarter-over-quarter increase.

Get the word out

The old saying “you get what you pay for” doesn’t need to have a negative connotation when it comes to purchasing beer DtC. In fact, an increasingly popular argument is that producers could rely on the sales of special releases to help ferment consumer spending.

In fact, “brands should also lean in on consumers looking for an opportunity to treat themselves and their loved ones by highlighting craft ingredients, decadent flavors, or limited-edition products,” according to an Insider Intelligence article.

Ecommerce alcohol is also forecast to outpace traditional alcohol retail sales, with 6.1% year-over-year growth, the article said.

Breweries could create beer subscription clubs, with the Sovos ShipCompliant/BA report finding that 71% of regular craft beer drinkers would be likely to sign up for such an option. Additionally, 86% would be likely to think more positively of a brewery that offers a DtC purchasing option.

Social media can also have a positive impact on DtC beer sales. Whether breweries are promoting new beers, subscription programs or weekly in-house entertainment, an increase in highlighting the brand can help get the word out to new potential customers. And in turn, consumers using social media could also help to promote breweries. The Sovos ShipCompliant/BA report found 72% of regular craft beer drinkers would be likely to post on social media about a brewery if it offered DtC shipping.

It’s difficult to predict how DtC beer shipping will continue to evolve, but it’s very clear that states are far from giving up on the fight to expand.

Take Action

Download the 2023 Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report for key takeaways and an analysis of the DtC beer channel.

It’s no secret that non-alcoholic beer is having a moment, and the segment is pointing to continued growth. First Key reports that dollar sales of non-alcohol (NA) beer, wine and spirits brands doubled between 2020 and 2022, with non-alcoholic beer accounting for over 80% of the market share of the category.

What was once a small, niche market has now become mainstream. The Brewers Association has predicted that in the coming years, NA will make up 5+% of the beer market.

There are a variety of reasons a consumer would opt for a NA beer, and brewers are looking to expand their market presence. Customers who once had one or two NA beer choices can now pick between alcohol-free but still hazy IPAs, hearty stouts and citrusy sours. Better quality NA beers are entering the market, with NA beer fans saying that alcohol-free versions are indistinguishable from their full-ABV counterparts.

While NA beers contain little to no alcohol, they still come with a variety of compliance concerns.

How is non-alcoholic beer regulated?

Since it’s “like” beer, the production, distribution and sale of NA beer can, like beer, be restricted by state and federal laws. Initially, this means recognizing whether a NA beer is subject to either of the two federal statutory codes that govern the production and distribution of alcohol: the Internal Revenue Code (Part 25 of CFR) and the Federal Alcohol Administration Act (Part 7 of CFR). Whether a given NA beer is subject to both or either of these statutes, however, depends on how it is made. If a product does not meet one or both statutes’ definitions of regulated beverages (which are different!), that could remove a heavy compliance burden from the producer.

The Internal Revenue Code (IRC) defines “beer” as a fermented beverage “brewed from malt, wholly or in part, or any malt substitute” that, importantly, contains 0.5% ABV or higher. This is opposed to the category of products called “cereal beverage,” which is a beverage that may or may not be fermented, is “derived in whole or in part from malt, or a substitute” and, critically, has an ABV of less than 0.5% when ready for consumption. Under the IRC, most products considered NA beers would be defined as “cereal beverages,” and so be subject to any applicable IRC laws relating to “cereal beverages.” It should be noted that the IRC specifically exempts any product with an ABV less than 0.5% from all federal alcohol excise taxes.

The Federal Alcohol Administration Act (FAAA), however, has slightly different definitions of these products. The FAAA, instead, governs what it calls “malt beverages,” defined as fermented beverages “derived from an infusion or decoction in potable water of both malted barley and hops.” Traditional NA beer would then most likely fall under the class type of malt beverages called “cereal beverages,” which are malt beverages that contain less than 0.5% ABV. Notably, to be subject to the FAAA, an NA beer would first have to be considered a “malt beverage,” so any malt beverage not made with hops would not be subject to the FAAA.

Licensing requirements

Federally, both the IRC and FAAA may require subject producers to receive a license before making their products. Under the FAAA, if an NA beer is considered a “malt beverage,” the producer would need to have a Brewer’s Notice. The IRC does not have any licensing requirement for its class of “cereal beverages,” but does note that those products may be produced at a brewery under any existing Basic Permit.

However, an NA beer producer may also need to receive a Distilled Spirits Basic Permit if they use specific techniques for removing alcohol from their products that are based on distillation techniques, such as reverse osmosis. If an NA beer is not produced using such a method (say, if it is made with non-fermenting yeasts), the distillery permit would not be required.

Labeling requirements

Both the IRC and FAAA set out rules for NA beer labeling. Generally, the standard labeling requirements for full-strength beer apply to NA beer, to include the producer, type and volume. Unlike traditional beers, NA beer labels must prominently include “Nontaxable under section 5051 I.R.C.” COLAs are only required if the product is subject to the FAAA and if it is sold interstate. Additionally, the Government Health Warning is only required on products containing greater than 0.5% ABV.

A common question is when to use “Alcohol Free” versus “Non-alcoholic.” Both identifiers are optional, but if you choose to print one on your label, be sure to be mindful of the requirements. Producers can’t use the phrase “Alcohol Free” if there is any alcoholic content at all in the product, but if label will say “0.0% alc by vol” anywhere, then “Alcohol Free” must also appear. “Non-alcoholic” can be used by any NA beer that contains more than 0.0% ABV, but then the phrase “contains less than 0.5% alc by vol” needs to be included as well.

How alcohol retailers can sell non-alcoholic beer

As with most things in the beverage alcohol industry, there isn’t a consensus among the 50 states on how to define or sell NA beer. When planning to sell NA beer, it’s important to focus on franchise laws and how the product is defined and regulated by states.

Many states are aligned with the federal definitions of NA beer, with a few notable exceptions. Kentucky and Vermont allow NA beers to contain up to 1.00% ABV, while Arizona, Georgia, Idaho, New York and Tennessee don’t have a minimum ABV threshold for malt beverages subject to state laws. For good measure, there are also some states that have laws specifically targeting NA beers.

In most cases, NA beer is not subject to three-tier requirements, which allows producers to consider distributing through direct-to-consumer shipping. Many traditional beer distributors do still make themselves available to support NA beer sales, but as ever when establishing a distributor relationship, make sure to fully review any agreements you may sign with them. Further, Texas and Illinois include NA beer in their franchise laws, which can severely affect your ability to amend or terminate a distributor contract in those states. As such, it is recommended to review all distributor contracts with counsel.

Take Action

Interested in how Sovos ShipCompliant can simplify compliance for your brewery? Talk with our experts.

Taxes are one of the primary compliance concerns for direct-to-consumer (DtC) shippers of wine, and one of the more complex ones. The 47 states, plus D.C., that permit DtC shipping of alcohol want to ensure there is parity between alcohol sold in-state and any coming from out-of-state sources. So, if a bottle of wine is going to be DtC shipped to a consumer in New York, it would be subject to the same taxes as if the wine was purchased in a local retail shop.

Broadly this means that DtC shippers must assume an obligation to collect and remit both excise and sales taxes on the wines they ship. Usually, this obligation is imposed on DtC shippers as a condition for getting the necessary shipping licenses in a state. (For sales taxes, this creates what might be called “DtC shipper nexus,” where the shipper has a tax obligation on even $1 of sales, meaning most of the recently adopted economic nexus laws across the country did not change much for DtC shippers.)

While excise taxes and sales/use taxes are by no means simple to manage, they are at least relatively standard and recognizable. If nothing else, there are plenty of resources out there to help prospective DtC shippers collect and remit these taxes.

But there are several states where DtC shippers face an additional or unique tax scenario that may not look quite normal. The sales tax rate may be greater than for other merchandise or there may be an additional excise tax levied just because the wine was shipped DtC. To help relieve any possible confusion, we outline some of the more notable unique taxes below.

Additional wholesale taxes applied to DtC shipping

Kentucky assesses what it calls the “wholesale sales tax” on alcohol sold within the state. When DtC shipping came into effect in 2021, it was included among DtC shippers’ other tax obligations in the state. As written, the tax is a 10% levy on the wholesale price of wine and beer, or 11% for spirits products. For three-tier sales, the distributor can readily account for and remit the tax, but it presents a unique challenge for DtC shippers who may not have set a wholesale price of their products in Kentucky. As such, Kentucky’s law allows DtC shippers to instead calculate the wholesale price as 70% of the retail cost of their products for the purposes of this tax. Notably, the state also allows DtC shippers to collect this tax from consumers at the time of purchase, just like the state’s sales tax, even if it is remitted alongside any excise tax that is due. The upshot of all this is that Kentucky consumers end up paying a tax of over 13% on their DtC shipments (to further complicate things, Kentucky considers any collection of the wholesale sales tax to itself be subject to the state sales tax), which DtC shippers need to manage .

South Dakota has a similar 2% tax on the price of all alcohol sold in the state. For products sold in the three-tier system, that is assessed against the wholesale price, but for DtC shipments it is instead calculated against the price paid by the consumer. Like in Kentucky, this tax can be collected from the consumer, raising the tax rate a consumer will see on their invoice.

Control state markup equivalence

New Hampshire is a control state for wine and spirits, so when the state began DtC shipping of these products, there were no excise tax rates ready for them to port over to DtC shipments (control states generally assess a “markup” on products they distribute, instead of more standard volume-based excise taxes). Instead, the state requires all DtC shippers to remit an 8% tax on their shipments—including beer, even though beer is not a controlled product in New Hampshire. Again, this tax can be collected from consumers at the time of purchase, like a sales tax. Since the Granite State is famously tax-antagonistic, however, this can lead to some awkward, if not hostile, conversations between DtC shippers and their consumers who might look askance at finding a tax rate listed on their receipts.

Wyoming is also a control state for wine and so similarly lacks a ready excise tax rate. Instead, the state imposes a 12% tax on DtC shipments there. The extra complication in Wyoming is that, while the state does have a sales tax, it does not require all DtC shippers to pay the sales tax as a condition of being a DtC shipper. Instead, only DtC shippers with nexus in the state (either physical or economic) will have a sales tax liability. But Wyoming also considers its 12% DtC markup to be part of the taxable base cost of any DtC shipment, meaning it is subject to the state’s sales tax. So, for a DtC shipper without nexus, they will assess only a 12% tax on their sales, but a DtC shipper with nexus will need to collect over 18% in tax from their Wyoming customers.

Unique sales tax rates

For the most part, DtC shippers are required to collect and remit state and local sales tax on all their shipments, even for $1 worth of sales. There are a handful of states that are exceptions to this rule, however, which can complicate things for DtC shippers as they need to track their annual revenue to see where they might have economic nexus. Generally, besides nexus tracking, managing sales tax is little different for DtC shippers than any other retailer in a state. There are a few states that do tax alcohol differently than other merchandise, which should be pointed out.

It can seem daunting for DtC wine shippers to manage all the various unique tax scenarios they may be subject to. However, correctly meeting their tax obligations is one of the more critical regulatory obligations for a DtC shipper and so it should not be ignored just because it’s complex. Instead, DtC shippers would do well to prepare for their tax burdens and seek out the best support and solutions available to them.

Take Action

Learn more about streamlining the DtC shipping process – including accounting for taxes – with ShipCompliant Direct.

After a few years of DtC spirits shipping in Kentucky, opening doors for wineries, breweries and distilleries to expand their product reach. The change was especially welcomed by the Kentucky Distillers’ Association (KDA), which helped craft and guide the landmark DtC bill in 2020 that established these permissions.

Founded in 1880, the KDA is the first and only non-profit trade association that promotes and protects the Bourbon legacy in Kentucky. The “promote” part centers around The Kentucky Bourbon Trail®, while the “protect” part encompasses the legislative side, as KDA Vice President of State Relations Adam Johnson described to Sovos ShipCompliant.

The Kentucky Bourbon Trail® is a “road-trip style experience for Bourbon lovers to go behind the scenes” at the state’s signature distilleries. On the legislative side, KDA advocates to expand options to help both Bourbon consumers and spirits producers.

“So much of what we have done has been driven by tourism,” Johnson said. “It comes down to making your guests happy.”

It started with distillery visitors wanting to enjoy a cocktail – but they couldn’t. Enter SB 11 in 2016, which raised the daily per-person free sample limit to 1.75 ounces and allowed distilleries to operate restaurants and serve cocktails, among other benefits. During the COVID-19 pandemic, “take-home cocktails” were a boon to restaurants, bars and others in the hospitality industry. With SB 67 in 2021, take-home beverages became a permanent option.

Another part of meeting consumer expectations was DtC shipping, which allows distilleries to responsibly and safely ship orders to consumers in Kentucky and reciprocal states. As well, it gives visitors the option to ship home bottles from the distillery they toured. That’s why a key effort for the KDA is to help other states craft and pass similar legislation.

“There’s more work to be done, to be sure we are expanding the options for states to ship to,” Johnson explained. “We want to make sure it’s done the right way: making sure the taxes are accounted for, not shipping to minors. Everyone is doing this to make sure it’s done the right way.”

Working toward the greater good for DtC spirits shipping in Kentucky

When it comes to Bourbon, it’s hard to think of a state with a richer history than Kentucky. And with the Kentucky Bourbon Trail® and Kentucky Bourbon Trail Craft Tour®, more people can learn about that history. In 2022, the two Kentucky Bourbon Trails surpassed 2.1 million visits combined, a new record according to Johnson. After launching a campaign to book tours in advance, the booking window is now 40 days out, he said, whereas it used to be seven days or fewer.

“Kentucky is a destination for Bourbon lovers,” Johnson said. “It’s a bucket-list item. We’re catering to the crowd and working to offer new experiences and things to do.”

However, there is still more work to be done. One key target for the KDA currently is to phase out the state’s barrel tax. As the only location globally to tax aging spirits, the law is turning away startup distilleries from Kentucky and forcing the business case for the Bluegrass State’s existing distilleries to age millions of barrels tax-free in neighboring states, Johnson explained.

“When you’re eager to get into Bourbon and spirits production, Kentucky is the major league. We offer the key resources and suppliers, from corn and barrels to nation-leading DtC, shipping and distribution systems and an incredible tourism stream. Phasing out the state’s punitive barrel tax only makes sense.”

Helping to expand Kentucky’s DtC spirits shipping is also on KDA’s agenda. At any given time, Johnson is sharing advice and takeaways with guild leaders in a half-dozen states nationwide seeking to responsibly expand their DtC alcohol shipping permissions.

“Part of my job is helping state guilds with what we went through on our own DtC bill; the compromises made and how it can be a model for other states to use,” Johnson said, adding that it’s important to ensure DtC shipping is done responsibly and legally.

“Every state we can help to further that effort is going to make the whole category stronger,” he explained. “That’s our goal: to help as many states as possible. And the consumer will only benefit.”

Kentucky Bourbon – and Bourbon as a whole – may be a massive industry. But it’s also a very small, familiar industry, according to Johnson. And that’s the secret to Kentucky’s success: everyone is helpful.

“Our membership strength is that our people help each other,” Johnson said. For example, when a consumer finishes a tour or visit at one distillery, they will be recommended another – competing – distillery to go to next.

“It goes back to the people really caring about the category. What’s good for the industry is good for the brand.”

Take Action

Want to learn more about the overall state of DtC spirits shipping? Download our inaugural Direct-to-Consumer (DtC) Spirits Shipping Report.

Sovos ShipCompliant’s recent 2023 Direct-to-Consumer (DtC) Wine Shipping Report, released with our partner Wines Vines Analytics, showed the first-ever decline in both value (-1.6%) and volume (-10.3%) of shipments. While these numbers are concerning, it’s important to look at the industry in its entirety and keep in mind the overall context of pandemic responses from both consumers and wineries.

This point was stressed in our recent webinar, “Insights from the 2023 DtC Wine Shipping Report,” hosted by Alex Koral, regulatory general counsel, Sovos ShipCompliant and Andrew Adams, Wine Analytics report editor at Wines Vines Analytics. Specifically, there is an ongoing “normalization” in the DtC wine shipping market, the two explained.

Without underplaying the significance of the decline in value and volume of DtC wine shipments, the drop reflects a return to a growth pattern that may have been seen from 2020-2022 had there not been a global pandemic. There were 8.39 million cases of wine shipped to consumers in 2020, which was a 27% increase over 2019. In 2021, 8.5 million cases of wine were shipped DtC, representing a 1.4% increase in volume shipped.

Koral and Adams added that 2020 was not a normal year, and the DtC results from that time should be taken with a grain of salt.

Expensive wines lead the way, younger consumers buy differently

The highest-priced wines—those priced at $100 or more per bottle—increased their volume shipped by 7.8% in 2022, and those priced at $200 or more per bottle increased by more than 20%. Comparatively, wines priced under $30 per bottle dropped in volume by 17.5%. This was a continued pattern from 2021, following large increases in shipments of lower-priced wines in the unprecedented sales from 2020. Additionally, buyers of higher-priced wines are likely better equipped to withstand the inflationary pressures seen in 2022 and are less likely to change their buying habits because of it.

The average price per bottle shipped grew 9.7% in 2022, reaching $45.16. The average price per bottle shipped has increased 10.9% since 2019. This is likely due to wineries responding to higher costs, including energy, goods, services and borrowing.

However, it’s not necessarily cause for wineries to lower prices. It could be a matter of better communicating the value of the product to consumers, according to bw166.

“For young consumers, pricing is a limitation which is a problem for the Wine industry – in 2022 the average price of a serving of Wine at retail was $2.29, $1.38 for Beer, and $1.12 for Spirits,” the article said.

It will also be important for wineries to find strategic new opportunities in the DtC market, including more targeted marketing for consumers of all ages. Wine is more expensive to make, market and ship, meaning wineries cannot rely on the same incentives in the DtC space like they did during the pandemic, Adams explained to The Drinks Business.

“It’s not getting any easier for small and medium wineries to sell their products in retail, so DtC remains an invaluable sales channel as well as the most effective way to engage your best customers and attract new ones,” he said.

Take Action

Download your free copy of the 2023 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report to learn more details about the state of the industry.

While the first annual Direct-to-Consumer (DtC) Spirits Shipping Report, presented by Sovos ShipCompliant and the American Craft Spirits Association (ACSA), found that 80% of regular craft spirits drinkers would purchase spirits for DtC shipping monthly if permitted in their state, it’s not necessarily as apparent to producers how they can legally ship spirits DtC.

We’ve outlined key things to keep in mind around shipping spirits directly to consumers, ensuring your business stays compliant through the entire process.

Which states allow DtC spirits shipping?

As of March 2023, eight states and Washington, D.C. allow interstate DtC spirits shipping. The states that allow shipments to a consumer’s home are:

Rules vary from one state to the next

Remember that state regulations can differ – just because a state allows DtC wine or beer shipping does not automatically mean that it allows DtC spirits shipping. Furthermore, a state may allow DtC spirits shipping, but with certain caveats. For example, Arizona only permits spirits to be shipped DtC by distilleries producing less than 20,000 gallons of spirits per year. Ensure that you adhere to the rules of the state where the consumer will receive the product shipment.

Age verification is necessary

Regardless of the state in which you are shipping spirits, some level of age verification will be required. This could include ID checks at the point of delivery, collecting recipient signatures or both. There are also some states that require point-of-sale (POS) age checks – verify the state requirements before you start shipping products directly to consumers.

Shortcuts are not the answer

While third-party services are necessary to complete the DtC spirits shipping process, don’t assume that those organizations will iron out the details. If your company is found to be shipping products improperly, your company – not the third-party service – is the one that is going to be held responsible. Especially when a third-party says it has a “work around,” make sure you understand how the service works and what you will remain responsible for.

Take Action

Still unsure about how to legally ship spirits DtC? Learn how ShipCompliant Direct can help.

Craft beer drinkers want expanded direct-to-consumer (DtC) beer shipping options, and if recent pieces of legislation are any indication, they may soon start to get that wish. Currently, several states have introduced bills that could expand the DtC alcohol shipping landscape for breweries and wineries alike.

Expanded DtC beer, wine & spirits shipping – by state

We’ve highlighted the details below:

Hawaii

Is Hawaii ready to say “aloha” to beer and spirits being shipped right to consumers’ doors? Companion Senate and House bills support the expansion of direct-to-consumer beer shipping and DtC spirits shipping. SB 1571 and HB 1259 would allow “direct shipment of beer and distilled spirits by” producers under rules similar to what already control how wine is shipped within the state.

The two bills also note that the COVID-19 pandemic disproportionately impacted certain beverage alcohol manufacturers in Hawaii. The closure of bars and clubs, as well as prohibiting in-person dining “has caused these manufacturers to struggle to find alternative methods of serving their customers, resulting in drastic revenue losses.”

“Direct business-to consumer shipping will allow these manufacturers to serve existing customers while also pursuing additional markets and new customer bases,” according to the bills. “Direct business-to-consumer shipping will also assist smaller manufacturers that are struggling to find wholesalers willing to sell and represent the manufacturer’s small brands by giving those manufacturers direct access to customers.”

Minnesota

A Minnesota bill (HF 417) would expand the amount of wine that a winery could ship directly to a consumer to 12 cases per person per calendar year. This would replace the current limit of two cases per person per year, while also establishing new licensing and tax requirements on wineries shipping into the state. This would bring Minnesota into alignment with other states that permit DtC shipping, rather than the more informal arrangement that currently governs DtC shipping in the state. In addition, common carriers servicing DtC shipments will be required to file a regular report on their activity in the state.

New Jersey

A New Jersey bill (NJ S549) would remove the production cap on what wineries are permitted to DtC ship in the state.

“Wineries that produce more than the 250,000 gallon capacity cap are currently prohibited from directly shipping wine,” according to the NJ S549 summary. “This bill establishes a license to allow the holder of a New Jersey winery license or an out-of-State winery that exceeds the 250,000 gallon capacity cap to directly ship up to 12 cases of wine annually to any person over the age of 21.”

Currently, only New Jersey still has a production cap after Ohio removed its restrictions on wineries producing more than 250,000 gallons last year.

Washington

Two Washington state bills (H 1016 and SB 5007) would allow in-state and out-of-state retailers to ship wine directly to consumers. Retailers would need to be licensed to sell wine in Washington or “obtain a wine retailer shipper’s permit under procedures prescribed by the board by rule and pay an annual fee of $100 to the board,” according to the bills. While almost every state permits domestic producers to ship DtC, only about 14 grant access to that market to out-of-state retailers, severely limiting consumer access to imports and other wines that are only distributed in one or two major markets.

Stay tuned to Sovos ShipCompliant for the latest on how these pieces of legislation—and others—are decided.

Take Action

Never miss a DtC beer shipping or DtC spirits shipping update and subscribe to the Sovos ShipCompliant blog.

Read the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report.

Craft beer drinkers want their beer shipped DtC—legally—and they are willing to pay for it. Those are among the conclusions of the third annual Direct-to-Consumer (DtC) Beer Shipping Report, released this March by Sovos ShipCompliant in partnership with the Brewers Association. The report includes a regulatory review of the DtC beer shipping channel, the latest data on consumer demand and purchase intent, and perspective from the national trade association that represents America’s craft breweries.

Report finds consumer demand has grown

While legal access to direct-to-consumer shipping of beer remains severely curtailed, this year’s survey of regular craft beer drinkers finds that interest in DtC beer shipping is higher than ever. Among the report’s insights:

The report has implications for states—most of which are missing out on the tax revenues associated with DtC wine shipping—and breweries alike.

Consumer survey methodology

This survey was conducted online within the United States by The Harris Poll on behalf of Sovos ShipCompliant from January 3-5, 2023 among 756 adults ages 21+, among whom 568 drink craft beer at least once per month.

Take Action

For additional takeaways and analysis into the DtC beer channel, download the 2023 Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report.

andrew adams wine vine analytics headshotBy Andrew Adams, Editor, Wine Analytics Report

The winery market has entered the next era of DtC wine shipping, where we saw total shipments for the past year declined 1.6% by value and 10.3% by volume. While the declines are unprecedented in the more than 12 years Wines Vines Analytics and Sovos ShipCompliant have tracked the channel, they are not that surprising given the equally unprecedented 27% increase in total volume seen in 2020.

Released just prior to the global outbreak of COVID-19 and the ensuing lockdowns of March 2020, the annual report on shipment activity in 2019 described a “mature” market in which growth could be expected to be much more modest than in previous years. At the time, the dominant trend had been strong year-to-year growth thanks to the opening of new states to DtC wine shipping. Yet after Pennsylvania fully opened to shipments in 2018, there were no longer any major markets left to open and a period of robust year-to-year growth via legislation came to an end.

But like everything else, the pandemic changed the landscape for wineries. DtC shipments served as a vital lifeline for wineries through 2020 and into 2021 when total shipments enjoyed a 1.4% increase in volume on top of the record high set during the worst of the pandemic.

While the declines seen in the past year don’t suggest a general pullback from direct shipments by both wineries and consumers, the steep drop in December shipment volume, coupled with a 10% decline in value, indicate that inflationary pressures and economic worries crimped the key sales period. In 2021, wineries enjoyed a boon in DtC business from holiday gift-giving from individuals and companies, some of which organized virtual tastings as COVID-safe holiday parties, leading to a value increase of more than 14% in October and 17% in November that year. This past year, wineries reported holiday gifting appeared down and many wine club members paused some club shipments because they accumulated so much wine in 2020 and 2021.

Meanwhile, many wineries in Napa and Sonoma counties will need to be strategic in 2023 with how they allocate wine into the various sales channels because the past three harvests have been lighter than normal. Back in 2020, many had excess inventory because of the bumper crop of 2018.

Those factors will all remain in play during the coming year as the DtC channel begins to reflect the wider U.S. wine market. Sales growth will be a challenge and wineries will need to be even more aggressive in a market that is poised to have fewer consumers than in 2020 or 2021 because of a revived on-premise sector, less demand for lower-priced wines to be shipped direct and layoffs among white collar workers. Shipping and material costs aren’t likely to decline even if price increases moderate through 2023, further reducing margins on direct shipments.

Back to the new normal

As the DtC channel continues to normalize from the dramatic increases of 2020 and 2021, and the next era of DtC wine shipping begins, it is being driven by many of the trends that defined it long before the COVID-19 pandemic. Cabernet Sauvignon reasserted its dominant position in the channel as the only key varietal to enjoy a significant increase in shipment value and a comparatively small decrease in volume.

The varietal accounted for 30% of total channel value in 2022 after increasing 6% to $1.26 billion for the year. By volume, Cabernet accounted for 17% of the total channel with 1.27 million cases, followed by Pinot Noir and Red Blends that both had a share of 14% after volume declines of 10% and 12%, respectively. Red blends saw a 2% increase in total value to $675 million.

While the popular varietals and wine types lead in DtC shipping just as in retail, the significant share of the “other” category in value and volume demonstrates the potential for consumers to acquire the alternative wines that may not be so easy to find in other channels. In 2022 the “other” category accounted for 15% of total channel value at $619 million (down 9% from 2021) while nearly a quarter of volume at 1.75 million cases (down 13% from 2021).

Just as seen in the total U.S. wine market, growth in DtC shipments has been bifurcated by price and the overall decline in volume is even more dramatic when segmenting by price. By value, total shipments of wines priced less than $50 fell 13% to $1.55 billion while the total value of wines priced more than $50 rose 7% to $2.59 billion.

The most expensive price tier of more than $200 grew by 32% to $664 million. By volume, wines priced more than $50 increased 1% to 2.11 million cases, while those priced less than $50 fell 14% to 5.37 million. Lower priced wines do account for a significantly higher share of volume with wines priced less than $50 accounting for 74% of all cases shipped and 70% in 2022. By dollars, wines priced more than $50 accounted for 58% of total channel volume in 2021 and that share grew to 63% in 2022. While the 166,927 cases of wines priced more than $200 accounted for just 2.2% of channel volume, they claimed 16% of total value.

While the past three years have brought both ups and downs in winery DtC shipments, 2023 is likely to see a return to market conditions that could be viewed as “normal” prior to the pandemic, ushering in the next era of DtC wine shipping. Wineries need to be even more vigilant and strategic in finding new opportunities in the DtC market while also retaining the invaluable consumer relationships that generate consistent, high-margin direct sales.

—-

Andrew Adams is the editor of the Wine Analytics Report, which is published by Wines Vines Analytics. Adams grew up in the city of Sonoma, Calif., before graduating from the University of Oregon with a degree in journalism. In addition to working at daily newspapers for more than a decade, Adams worked in the cellar and lab at the former Starmont winery in Napa Valley and has been a regular contributor to Wine Business Monthly magazine since 2019.  

In the month following the release of the 2023 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report, several other data snapshots of the wine industry were also published. In response to the various reports, there has been a swell of commentary on what each one signals for the health of and outlook for the U.S. wine industry.

It can be difficult to make sense of the varying takes because the data represented in each of the different reports are nuanced and often speak about different sectors of the larger industry.  While we might all be talking about “the wine industry,” on careful examination we see that these different sources, and the interpretations of each, are examining different slices of the larger pie.

The wine industry is composed of many channels—local delivery of three-tier distribution sales and direct-to-consumer shipping, other on- and off-premise models, consumers in different age brackets with different buying habits and needs. While it’s tempting to extrapolate from one segment to the rest, there’s much to be gained from looking at each slice of the pie in its own right.

Wine sales data: slices of the pie

Gus Clemens makes a savvy observation in his January 31 column: “Wine sales data is a confusing mix of proprietary data, estimates, modeling, and retail sales numbers that do not include key statistics. Each of the most respected data sources report different and incomplete numbers. It all depends on what beans are counted.”

For example, the Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) annual state of the wine industry report combines proprietary research with analysis of dozens of sources to enable Rob McMillan to provide his assessment of current market conditions and offer SVB’s trends forecast.

A recent bw166 post leans heavily on the Sovos ShipCompliant/Wines Vines Analytics Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report, along with numbers from the U.S. Census Bureau and some of the firm’s own data, in reaching the conclusion that the wine industry glass is half full.

Nielsen IQ offers data on on-premise sales and trends from point-of-sale data and other sources, and with the acquisition of CGA, aims to integrate off-premise data from casual and fine dining, bar and nightclub to this data view.

Meanwhile, WSWA SipSource uses aggregated and trended wine and spirits distributor depletions, built from unique items sold to individual stores, to predict what consumer trends will bring for both the on- and off-premise in 2023.

As for our own Sovos ShipCompliant data, it is the most comprehensive look at one key channel in the wine industry—direct-to-consumer shipped sales (including tasting room sales that are ordered for shipment, though not those that are picked up or carried out) based on millions of transactions that are extrapolated through the rigorous Wines Vines Analytics model to the entire U.S. DtC shipping channel. The data discussed in the report does not cover on-premise sales or non-DtC-shipped off-premise retail sales.

Different ages mean different buying habits

Wines’ relationship to younger (legal drinking age) consumers has been a topic of ample discussion. Using Sovos ShipCompliant/Customer Vineyard data, the SVB report shows that the proportion of wine sold directly to consumers over age 60 has continued to grow in total share over all other age bands, as consumers younger than 60 are less interested in buying wine today.

Conversely, the bw166 post we mentioned above uses ShipCompliant data to illustrate that when it comes to DtC spending, the per capita spending of 21- to 30-year-olds has been increasing at a faster rate than the 61 to 70 age band. As this data is specific to DtC shipping, other sources covering, for example, the on-premise might find different demographic trends.

W. Blake Gray of Wine Searcher says the wine industry is failing to engage younger consumers, but also notes this outcome could be cyclical. “Whiskey was down and out as an industry 30 years ago, and look at it now. Maybe whoever comes along after Gen-Z will decide to take up wine just because their parents did not. But can the wine industry afford to wait to find out?”

Where we’ve been & where we’re going

Looking specifically at DtC wine shipping in the U.S., from 2011 to 2021, the average change in the volume of winery shipments and the value of the shipping channel is +11.2% and +12.3%, respectively. This trend was disrupted in 2020 and 2021. However, the volatility continued in 2022 when the volume of DtC winery shipments decreased by 10.3% (876,848 cases) from 2021, while the value of winery shipments decreased by 1.6% ($66 million).

Although overall off-premise sales fell by half a billion dollars in 2022, DtC shipments of wine kept pace with 2021 shipments by capturing 12.0% of the off-premise sales of domestic wines, essentially matching the largest ever percentage of domestic off-premise sales recorded by the DtC shipping channel (12.1% in 2021).

While it appears now that inflation in the economy is easing somewhat, it remains far higher than historical averages. Additionally, interest rates continue to rise and are forecast to rise going into 2023, though perhaps at a lower clip than throughout 2022. If these economic conditions maintain their trajectory, the wine industry and its DtC wine shipping channel will continue to be impacted by slower consumer spending and the high costs of goods, services and debt.

None of that is good news for wineries that rely on DtC sales and shipments, but it doesn’t necessarily point to a failing by the industry to produce wines that fit the budgets of younger consumers, or neglecting to reach out to them with targeted marketing campaigns.

Wine isn’t finished, but there is definitely work to be done to ensure that consumers of all ages and in varying tax brackets can find their ideal vintage. Perhaps it’s just a matter of making sure to take in the entire pie as well, not simply one piece at a time.

Take Action

Download your complimentary copy of the 2023 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report to take a deep dive into the latest DtC data.

Sovos ShipCompliant attended the recent American Craft Spirits Association (ACSA) Convention. Celebrating its 10th year, ACSA once again brought together “distillers and suppliers to harness the energy of the industry.” Direct-to-consumer (DtC) spirits shipping was a recurring theme at the convention, with multiple panels discussing what changes must take place to increase DtC spirits shipping across the country.

That theme was no surprise, as the first annual Direct-to-Consumer Spirits Shipping Report, published by Sovos ShipCompliant and the American Craft Spirits Association in December 2022, found that the interest is decidedly there for DtC spirits shipping. Specifically, 46% of regular craft spirits drinkers want craft spirits shipped directly to them via a third-party carrier.

The report also showed that 80% of regular craft spirits drinkers would purchase spirits DtC monthly if permitted in their state. However, only eight states and Washington, D.C. allow for spirits DtC interstate shipping.

Given all of that, it’s welcome news to see recently proposed bills that would expand spirits DtC. New York senators introduced a bill in early 2023 that would amend the state’s current DtC shipping law, expanding it to allow for liquor to be shipped directly to consumers’ homes. Specifically, the bill would allow licensed liquor, cider and mead manufacturers to obtain an out-of-state direct shipper’s license and sell up to 36 cases of their product to New York state residents who are of legal age.

Additionally, a recent Texas bill would allow for DtC spirits and DtC beer shipping. Texas-based licensed beer and spirits producers could conduct in-state DtC shipping using licensed third-party carriers and consumer delivery services.

Legislation for DtC Spirits Shipping

DtC spirits shipping is also a legislative priority for the Distilled Spirits Council of the United States (DISCUS), alongside other marketplace modernization efforts, as highlighted by DISCUS President and CEO Chris Swonger during his 2023 economic briefing.

This focus comes amid the context of spirits’ increasing market share. DISCUS reported that spirits supplier sales in the U.S. were up 5.1% in 2022, reaching $37.6 billion. Additionally, volumes increased 4.8% to 305 million 9-liter cases. This is the first time spirits supplier revenues surpassed beer, which has a 41.9% market share. DISCUS found that spirits gained market share by value of the total U.S. beverage alcohol market for the 13th straight year, as supplier sales hit 42.1%.

These findings align with Sovos ShipCompliant Product Registration Online (PRO) data, which recently found that from 2021 to 2022, tequila new product registrations were up 39%. Whiskey accounted for 34% of the total new product registrations in 2022 and had a 104% spike in Q4 year-over-year growth. Overall, spirits new product registrations increased 90% over Q4 2022.

So, what’s ahead for spirits? “Direct-to-consumer shipping is poised to be a major imperative step in the evolution of the spirits marketplace, especially for craft distilleries,” Margie A.S. Lehrman, CEO of the American Craft Spirits Association, said in a statement. “The current DtC market is small but is expected to grow and mature, particularly for smaller premium brands that consumers are demanding in different markets across the country.”

Take Action

Download your complimentary copy of the Direct-to-Consumer Spirits Shipping Report for a deep dive into the consumer and regulatory sides of this growing market.

If you ask a beverage alcohol regulator what their biggest concern is, nine times out of ten, you’ll hear about efforts to prevent sales to minors. The health risks associated with alcohol, particularly for developing brains, validate those concerns, but there is something of a reflexive response around underage consumption—a response grounded more in fear than in the facts—that affects how regulators react to changes in the beverage alcohol industry.

New ways to sell alcohol are automatically suspect and seen as potential gateways to rampant drinking by teens and tweens, despite evidence of market innovations that have not increased underage access and contrary to the fact that underage drinking has decreased dramatically since the 1990s. These responses have been especially visible with the rise of direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping options for alcohol sellers.

To be 100% clear, no one is advocating selling or making alcohol available to people under the age of 21. But the kneejerk reaction that innovation will necessarily erode protection for minors is almost always overblown, as we’ll see below, and leads to diminished options for those who can legally purchase alcohol.

Two recent stories in the news highlight the prevailing perceptions regarding online sales of alcohol and access by minors. By moving past the headlines and digging into what the stories are reporting, we can lessen confusion and gain a more nuanced understanding of how we can both enjoy innovation in the alcohol industry and protect minors.

First the ‘bad’ news

In October 2022, the Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission (OLCC) released a report, “Eyes on Oregon,” which detailed systemic failures within third-party delivery services handling alcohol orders. According to the headlines, the report found that over a third of deliveries of alcohol made in Oregon committed compliance failures, putting the state at serious risk of a wave of underage drinking and overconsumption.

Stories like this put fear into the hearts of anyone advocating for expanding online sales options, as they seem to imply that any such enterprise is doomed to failure. However, when you look more closely at the report, it becomes clear that nothing in it points to any actual illegal sales or any systemic problems within the online alcohol market.

As the report says, the results were based on 106 online orders fulfilled by different third-party delivery services in the state from May to September 2022. Notably, all the volunteers who made the purchases were between 21 and 26 years old, and all able to avail themselves of the Oregon alcohol market. So, when the headlines state that the report demonstrates rampant illegality in the delivery of alcohol, that is dead wrong—none of these orders appear to have been illegal in and of themselves.

Instead, where the report indicates “compliance failures,” it actually means that the third-party delivery service did not check (or more so, did not “appear” to properly check) IDs. Certainly, this is problematic—checking IDs and getting the signature of someone of age at the time of delivery is not only best practice, it is almost always required by law. But it hardly means that there is any entrenched flaw in the delivery of alcohol.

Indeed, per the report’s own data, fully two-thirds of the orders were perfectly compliant. And in the one-third of deliveries that were “non-compliant,” the failure was most often (29 times out of 39) that the recipient’s ID was “insufficiently checked,” not that the delivery person didn’t check the ID but that, per the volunteer purchaser, the check “did not appear to be carefully” done or only involved the use of an ID scanner (the problem there presumably being that the recipient is using someone else’s ID). Still not the best but also not anything like irreparable failure.

That leaves 10 orders out of 106 that could be characterized as problematic, with either no attempt to check the recipient’s age or only a very superficial one. Notably, the alcohol package was left with no contact with the recipient on only two occasions. While even one such delivery is troubling, it is hard to see this as a scourge of society.

Really, this report needs to be seen in the broader context of how much the alcohol market has changed in the last few years. These kinds of online sales involving the use of third-party delivery services are still very new, and as with any new system, there will be kinks that need to be worked out. A few compliance failures are not cause to throw the whole process of innovation out the window. Instead, they should be seen as teachable moments, showing where improvement is needed while allowing for refinement and change.

There’s also good news

In comparison to the OLCC’s report, the online wine marketplace Vinoshipper recently released an internal study of DtC orders through its system that found 100% effectiveness at stopping sales of alcohol to minors. The study, examining two years of sales, comprising over 1 million shipments to more than 600,000 buyers, concluded that they had no sales to minors. They describe having managed this through a process of validating consumer information through an online database (IDology) and conducting follow-up reviews wherever there appeared to be a problem. The study asserts that 75.3% of consumers passed on the first review, with 24.6% able to confirm their age on the second review; just 0.15% of the orders had to be canceled because the consumer’s age could not be verified.

There are some notable differences between the Vinoshipper and OLCC reports, most critically in that they address slightly different types of delivery methods, one using common carriers like UPS and FedEx, and the other using local third-party services like DoorDash or Uber Eats. The markets are also different, the one being licensed DtC wine shippers (an established market), the other delivery from local retailers (a developing one).

Indeed, that the DtC wine shipping market can be so effective should be a sign of hope for local delivery services. By educating that segment of the industry to follow best practices—namely, that signatures must be collected at the time of delivery and that IDs must be looked at carefully—the OLCC could help strengthen their alcohol market for the retailers and consumers it seeks to serve.

Rather than handwringing about how any failures supposedly signal inherent problems in the market, we can recognize that compliance systems, like all systems, need time to develop. However, unlike a fine wine that may need years to mature, the growing third-party services can benefit from the experience of DtC alcohol shippers and apply those lessons today to ensure a safer and healthier alcohol market.

Take Action

Subscribe to our blog and never miss an update on the latest DtC shipping regulations.

A recently introduced Texas senate bill (TX SB752) would extend direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping permissions in the Lone Star state for both spirits and beer. These permissions would work largely in the same manner as DtC wine shipping in the state.

Specifically, TX SB752 would enable licensed Texas-based producers of beer and spirits to conduct in-state DtC shipping using licensed third-party carriers and consumer delivery services. Such shipments by producers will be subject to the same personal sales volume limits that Texas beer and spirits producers are already subject to.

The bill would also create new beer and distiller shipping licenses for out-of-state producers, granting them access to the Texas market, just as out-of-state wineries have enjoyed for years. These producers would need to get their respective DtC shipping license (either DtC beer shipping or DtC spirits shipping), which would only be available to domestic producers with valid production licenses issued by their home states. However, if the producer has an existing interest in a Texas retailer or wholesaler, they would be unable to get a DtC shipping license as Texas sees that as a violation of its strict tied-house laws. If passed, the new law would also require the following:

TX SB752 also allows that all DtC shipments may be made to dry counties, just like with wine. All products that are currently and properly meeting federal label registration requirements (COLAs) would not need to do any additional Texas registrations to be shipped.

Illinois DtC beer shipping bill introduced

Illinois also introduced a new bill (IL SB 2193) that would extend beer-only DtC shipping permission in the state, largely along the same lines as what currently exists for wine. For example, all beer producers, both in-state and out-of-state, would be required to get the new DtC license if they want to ship into/within Illinois. Producers would also be required to register to collect Illinois use tax on their shipments, pay Illinois excise tax on their shipments and furnish the state with any shipping records upon request.

The bill would limit DtC beer shippers to shipping no more than 12 cases of beer per consumer per year. Notably, applicants for a DtC beer shipping license will need to list all third-party logistical services they would use to facilitate their shipments (i.e., fulfillment houses, but not carriers). Those third-party services would need to file a regular report on their shipments. These third-party logistic service rules are already in effect under Illinois’ DtC wine shipping rules.

In both the Texas and Illinois pieces of legislation, all packages must be clearly and legibly stamped to indicate that they contain alcohol. Furthermore, carriers must check IDs at the time of delivery and get a real signature from the recipient.

While it’s positive to see these types of DtC shipping bills introduced, history reminds us that there will not be a seamless path for either to become enacted into law. Both California and Maine curtailed bills for DtC spirits shipping in 2022. However, a Vermont bill went into effect last year that created new ways to sell Ready-to-Drink (RTD) spirits in the state, including permission for distillers to ship these products DtC.

It’s more important than ever for Texas and Illinois consumers and producers to contact their local representatives to show support for their state’s respective bill. Additionally, working with state guilds can help usher the legislation along and help avoid the interference that has doomed other bills. So far, 2023 seems to be building up to an important one for DtC beer shipping and DtC spirits shipping bills.

Take Action

Don’t want to miss the latest DtC shipping news? Subscribe to the Sovos ShipCompliant blog to always stay in the loop.

Across all categories, the number of 2022 registrations showed a 2.3% increase compared to 2021 

Winter brings cooler temperatures across the U.S., but beverage alcohol new product registrations are hardly cooling off. Spirits new product registrations led the way (+9.8%), followed by wine (+0.5). The beer/malt category for Product Registration Online (PRO) new product registrations* continued to show a gradual decline with a 2.5% year-over-year dip, but is showing continued quarter-over-quarter growth.

The following is a breakdown of new product registration data via PRO from the fourth quarter of 2022 (October, November, December) for spirits, wine and beer.

Spirits

Overall, spirits new product registrations increased 9.8% from this time last year and 90% over Q4 2022. Cocktails led the overall spirits category with 55% growth from 2021 to 2022, with tequila up 39% in that same time. Whiskey accounted for 34% of the total new product registrations in 2022, and had a 104% spike in Q4 year-over-year growth. Among other liquor new product registrations:

Wine

The number of wine brand registrations has steadily been increasing since 2019. The yearly growth is just 0.5% but the overall category had a 1.3% increase over Q3 2022 and saw a 53.3% leap from Q4 2021. The sparkling category lead the way in year-over-year growth at 15%. White wine and red and rosé registrations each had moderate yearly increases, at 9% and 6%, respectively. However, fruit and dessert wine (-13%) and saké (-9%) each saw declines compared to 2021.

Beer/Malt

Overall, beer/malt new product registrations are up 27% from Q3 2022. While the category saw a 2.5% drop year-over-year, there is continued quarter-over-quarter growth. For example, Q3 year-over-year growth (+4.8%) and Q4 year-over-year growth (+25.4%) were both positive. Specifically, the beer categories are up 4% year-over-year and saw a 39% increase quarter-over-quarter. While other malt new product registrations saw an 8% drop year-over-year, the category still increased 17% quarter-over-quarter and showed a 22% jump in Q4 2022 compared to Q4 2021.

*Product Registration Online (PRO) data encompasses nationwide label/brand registrations by PRO users. Product Registration Online processes some 100,000 state registrations annually. 

Take Action

 Learn how PRO enables fast, easy electronic brand filings for wine, spirits and beer brands in participating states.

Updated February 3, 2023

There’s a chance New York may soon allow direct-to-consumer spirits and cider shipping. Last Wednesday, New York Senators James Skoufis (D- 42nd District) and Rachel May (D-48th District) introduced Bill 2852, an act to “amend the alcoholic beverage control law, in relation to authorizing the direct intrastate and interstate shipment of liquor, cider, mead, and braggot and relates to direct shipments of wine.” In short, the proposed bill would add New York to the list of eight states (and D.C.) that allow interstate direct-to-consumer spirits shipping.

The Empire State’s laws allow for direct-to-consumer wine shipping, but past attempts at legalizing the direct shipping of beer, cider and spirits have failed. If passed, the amended bill would shape the state’s liquor shipping laws after the current wine shipping laws, even down to the number of cases allowed per consumer.

What is included in Bill 2852?

If signed into law, Bill S02852 would allow licensed liquor, cider and mead manufacturers to obtain an out-of-state direct shipper’s license and sell up to 36 cases of their product to any of-age New York state resident. Currently, New York permits the DtC shipping of apple- or pear-based fermented beverage alcohol with an ABV of 8.5% or less only when the products are labeled and sold as a fruit “wine.” If made into law, ciders of all kinds can be shipped into the state. Notably, beer is not included and remains non-DtC shippable in New York.

The bill states that New York-based licensed manufacturers must be provided reciprocal shipping privileges, much like current rules in place for direct-to-consumer wine shipping. Like many other states, there is also strict guidance regarding packaging label requirements, age and signature checks at the time of delivery and tax filing.

New York isn’t the only state proposing the expansion of direct-to-consumer shipping. Hawaii Senator Jarrett Keohokalole (D- 24th District) introduced Senate Bill 1571, which aims to amend the existing wine shipping laws to apply it to all alcoholic products, including beer and spirits.

If you are a New York or Hawaii resident who wants to have their favorite spirits shipped directly to your home, reach out to your local representatives through Ship My Spirits. This grassroots coalition makes it easy to send a customized, personal email to your state legislators.

Take Action

Download our inaugural Direct-to-Consumer Spirits Shipping Report for an in-depth look at the consumer and producer sides of this emerging market.