Find Sovos ShipCompliant at the 2024 Unified Wine & Grape Symposium in Sacramento, California. We’ll be showcasing our cloud-based direct-to-consumer and three-tier compliance solutions that reduce risk and lessen the burden of compliance. We look forward to meeting friends both new and old at our booth.
As 2023 comes to a close, now is a great time to review the regulatory changes that impacted the beverage alcohol industry this year. From California’s bottle bill to the direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping legal battles that occurred around the country, a lot has happened this year. These updates were covered in a webinar hosted by Sovos ShipCompliant; some of the highlights are presented below.
The annual sales threshold for businesses subject to Colorado’s retail delivery fee was raised to $500,000 from $100,000. The fee was adopted by the state in 2022 to generate revenue on retail deliveries made in the state, including everything from pizza deliveries, Amazon deliveries to, of course, alcohol deliveries. However, only businesses that have annual earnings in the state greater than the threshold amount are required to collect and remit the fee. The change in the retail delivery fee threshold does not affect any other Colorado state tax or fee, so DtC shippers with sales exceeding $100,000 in the state are still subject to Colorado sales tax liability.
After Alabama opened up for DtC shipping in 2022, many would-be shippers opted out of selling there because the state adopted rather complex application requirements. Earlier this year, however, the state passed a bill removing many of those requirements, including the need to register with the secretary of state, a bond requirement and a need to have liability insurance on their shipments to the state. Additionally, ownership information is now only required for those with more than a 10% stake in the company. If you’ve previously skipped DtC shipping in Alabama based on the requirements, now may be a good time to reassess if these changes lower the barrier to entry.
Oregon was central to a key legal battle in the beverage alcohol industry this year around DtC beer shipping and self-distribution. Oregon law enabled self-distribution from in-state breweries and reciprocal DtC beer shipping rules but prohibited most out-of-state brewers from engaging in these sales. After a group of Washington breweries sued the state, Oregon agreed to compromise, allowing national self-distribution and DtC shipping.
Soon after that case, an Oregon winery sued the state of Iowa on similar grounds, as Iowa only allowed local wineries to self-distribute in the state. This could be the beginning of a trend for broadening self-distribution rights, and we’ll be keeping an eye on these and other cases in the new year.
Related, there was some positive movement in retailer DtC shipping litigation. In the last few years, most courts have held up discriminatory rules that allowed only in-state retailers to ship DtC. However, in a couple notable cases this year, appellate courts have indicated an unwillingness to accept state claims on their face and have required a full hearing of the arguments before the court, signaling a possible shift in how courts will assess facially discriminatory retailer DtC shipping laws.
State enforcement officials had a close eye on DtC shipping this year. Age checks and sales to minors were the main focus, with a report issued by Massachusetts claiming widespread compliance failures. While there is much to criticize about the Massachusetts report, this is a good reminder that DtC shippers must do everything they can to prevent sales to minors. Even if a state doesn’t require point of sale age checks, we always recommend doing it anyway to ensure that your products are not being sold illegally to anyone underage.
In the last few years states have been increasing their enforcement activities against businesses shipping alcohol without a proper license. Ohio and Michigan have been actively prosecuting those who sell and ship products without licenses for a few years, and Tennessee joined them this year by issuing cease and desist letters. Virginia also sued a company that was over-extending the terms of their license by shipping from locations not covered by their license.
Of course, the introduction of California’s bottle bill is a top headline, which will extend to wine and spirits products starting on January 1, 2024. The bill is a recycling encouragement program, with a fee charged on all manufacturers selling in the state along with the California Redemption Value (CRV), a 5- to 10-cent deposit collected from retail beverage sales in the state.
Under the new law, for alcoholic beverages, a “manufacturer” is the party that is licensed by the California ABC to produce or sell products in the state, including California-based producers and importers and DtC wine shippers. Manufacturers must register with CalRecycle, file a monthly report and pay the Manufacturer Processing Fee.
There is a separate requirement for “distributors,” which the state has defined as anyone who sells directly to California retailers or consumers. Distributors also must register with CalRecycle, collect the CRV from consumers and remit it to CalReycle with a monthly report. This applies to all DtC shipments going to California residents along with most distributions to California retailers. There is a limited exception to the CRV for sales of wine that will be consumed in wineries’ tasting rooms.
The California bottle bill also includes a labeling requirement to alert consumers of the California Redemption Value (CRV). There is a labelling grace period through July 1, 2025, with a total exemption for any wines or spirits bottled before January 1, 2024.
The sheer number of regulatory changes that we saw this year is a great reminder that wineries need to stay updated on what’s going on in the industry. While Sovos ShipCompliant regulatory experts share their findings on our blog, we also recommend keeping tabs on what your local guild and groups like Free the Grapes! are up to. By keeping up with the latest regulatory happenings, you can ensure that your company enjoys a compliant 2024.
Subscribe to the Sovos ShipCompliant blog to get the latest insights on beverage alcohol compliance and government reporting sent to your inbox.
With 2024 just around the corner, it’s necessary to review upcoming regulations that are set to impact wineries and other producers in the direct-to-consumer (DtC) wine shipping market in the coming year. Everything from California’s new bottle bill to Alaska DtC shipping updates were discussed in a recent webinar featuring Jeff Carroll, VP of partners and compliance, WineDirect, and Sovos ShipCompliant’s Alex Koral, regulatory general counsel. The duo presented, “How to Prepare for Changing Regulations in 2024.” Some of the event highlights are presented below.
Effective January 1, 2024, wines and spirits sold in California will become subject to the state’s Container Recycling and Litter Reduction Act. This bottle bill program is meant to encourage recycling and applies to a number of beverages being sold in the state. California is hardly alone in having this type of program, but in most other states, wine and spirits products are excluded.
There are two aspects to the California bottle bill: one for manufacturers and one for distributors.
Manufacturers are defined under the bottle bill as any party that produces or bottles subject beverages. For the alcohol beverage industry, manufacturers are specifically defined as the party holding a license issued by the California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, including a producer license, an importer license or a certificate for out-of-state producers. Under the bottle bill, manufacturers will need to register with CalRecycle and file a monthly return paying the Manufacturer Processing Fee for all beverages they sell in the state.
Distributors are defined under the bottle bill as any party that sells subject beverages to California consumers or retail establishments—which includes many parties that would not typically be considered a “distributor” in the alcohol industry, such as California producers that self-distribute and all wineries selling direct-to-consumer in the state. Distributors must register with CalRecycle, collect the California Redemption Value (CRV) from consumers at the point of sale and file a monthly report remitting the CRV collected. Notably, sales by wineries for on-premises consumption in tasting rooms are explicitly excluded from CRV requirements.
The rates for the Manufacturer Processing Fee and the CRV vary depending on the size and type of the container.
There are also key labeling requirements to keep in mind about the program. All applicable beverages sold in the state must:
Wine and spirits bottles are exempted from the labelling requirement until July 1, 2025, and any products bottled before January 1, 2024, will never need to show CRV. However, best practice will be to start the CRV labeling process in 2024.
There are also changes coming into effect for Alaska DtC rules, starting on January 1, 2024. A new license will be required for direct-to-consumer shippers, but as of the webinar, it is not currently available to apply for yet. The license will cost $200 and will need to be renewed annually.
Point-of-sale (POS) age verifications are also being instituted, and the state will continue to mandate its ban of selling to certain local option communities. There will also be a customer volume limit of two cases per month or a 10 case per year limit.
Finally, excise tax will need to be remitted to the state. Notably, Alaska does not have state sales tax, though the state does permit individual communities to assess their own sales tax and adopt economic nexus rules, extending liability for those local sales taxes to remote sellers that make over $100,000 in sales in the state.
NOTE: Regulators are still working to finalize select rules for DtC shipping, including how to better identify local option communities, and how shippers can verify that the purchaser and recipient are not on a list of persons prohibited by the state from purchasing alcohol. It is recommended that shippers wait to apply for an Alaska DtC license until how these rules should be managed have been sorted out by the state.
Overall, there are key compliance behaviors that states are cracking down on, working to increase their enforcement of certain rules. Organizations operating in the DtC shipping market must ensure they are keeping tabs on the latest changes and how they may be impacted.
One of the top issues continues to be preventing alcohol sales to minors. It’s important to always conduct age checks, even in states that don’t necessarily require it. Businesses can utilize tools such as IDology or LexisNexis to help ensure that all alcohol sales are in fact being done legally. (Note to ShipCompliant users: you can enable these checks via third-party tools in your account.)
Customer aggregate volume limits (CAVL) also present continued concerns, with more states using electronic reports, which are easier to search through to find questionable sales. States are keeping closer watch on names being switched around or pseudonyms being utilized. Remember that if a consumer breaks the law with regard to CAVL, it is your license potentially in jeopardy.
There is also heightened awareness around license details and who can sell what, specifically, on sales happening outside the scope of a license. For example, many states limit the brands that a DtC shipper can sell. These are called “not of own production” (NOOP) rules and can vary between states, making it all the more critical for businesses to understand the intricacies.
Evolving compliance requirements for fulfillment houses are also a top DtC issue. States are being told of questionable practices taking place with fulfillment houses and are subsequently updating licensing requirements and reporting rules.
Essentially, it’s necessary more than ever to stay vigilant in your DtC compliance practices, ensuring there is open communication with consumers. They also must understand and be mindful of compliance requirements – as they themselves are also an important part of the DtC shipping market. Encourage consumers to contact their state legislatures to continuously move the industry forward, allowing DtC shipping to expand in a safe and regulated way that benefits all parties involved.
See how ShipCompliant Direct can help you get a handle on your DtC shipping compliance.
Diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) initiatives have quickly become staples for numerous businesses across industries. The beverage alcohol industry is also demonstrating that these efforts are as core to their company successes as lobbying and member education.
We’ve gathered a handful of examples of DEI programs that our partners have implemented, showcasing how ensuring a diverse and inclusive workplace can benefit both the organization and its customers.
The American Cider Association (ACA) has its Cider is for Everyone equity pledge, which is part of its larger initiative work from its Antiracism, Equity and Inclusion Committee.
“We are committed to creating an industry that promotes zero tolerance for discrimination and harassment; creates space for and amplifies voices from underrepresented and marginalized groups; and allows for individual and company growth around equity and justice,” the ACA states on its website.
Along with committing “to fostering a diverse craft brewing community by providing resources, educational opportunities, and a powerful community of advocates,” the Brewers Association (BA) offers DEI Mini Grants and a mentorship program.
“The BA is proud to fund grants in support of local and regional events, media production projects, and educational and training initiatives that thoughtfully and intentionally promote and foster a more diverse, equitable, and inclusive craft beer community,” states the BA website.
The mentorship program aims to provide guidance and work to further promote diversity within the workforce, leadership and ownership of small and independent breweries. Mentors can be knowledgeable in numerous parts of the brewing industry, including but not limited to technical brewing, guest experience, brewery operations and sales and distribution.
Increasing diversity is a top priority listed on the American Craft Spirits Association (ACSA) website, with the ACSA acknowledging that diversity in distiller leadership and other positions within the industry can still be improved upon.
“We are committed to creating and fostering an environment that is welcoming and accepting of all individuals, and ensuring that all members of our community are treated with dignity and respect,” the ACSCA explains on its website. “We believe that a person’s background, identity, or beliefs, should not be a hindrance to their being in a position to contribute.”
The Distilled Spirits Council of the United States (DISCUS) formed its DEI Committee in 2021 and held its inaugural DEI Summit in partnership with Pronghorn in June 2023.
“This is the first time we are leveraging our collective power as an industry to come together and drive a broader impact for all our people and consumers,” Victoria Russell, Beam Suntory Chief Diversity & Inclusion Officer and Chair of the DISCUS DEI Committee, said in a statement. “Historically, we’ve worked in the silos of our respective organizations with marginal impact on the diversity of our industry. We are better together, and this inaugural DEI Summit has the potential to positively impact the industry as a whole.”
Remember: this roundup is hardly comprehensive. There are numerous other DEI initiatives in place throughout bev alc – and more to be created! Is your company or association engaged in DEI-focused work? Let us know if you have positive examples of the industry working to become more inclusive.
Learn more about how ShipCompliant Direct can help your business update its approach to DtC shipping in the beverage alcohol industry.
In late October, the District Court of Eastern Washington rejected an effort by the state to dismiss a lawsuit challenging its prohibition on direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of spirits by out-of-state producers. While the case remains open before the court, the full-throated denial of the motion to dismiss was notable for what it signals about how the case may resolve and for what it could mean for future DtC litigation.
Shady Knoll Orchards & Distillery v. Postman challenges a provision in Washington’s law that permits in-state distilleries to ship their spirits DtC to Washington consumers but prohibits out-of-state distilleries from doing the same. Washington law allows local distillers to act as a distributor or retailer within Washington, selling spirits produced by them or other Washington distillers to consumers. As long as they maintain a physical retail location in the state, the distiller can also engage in online sales that are fulfilled through a DtC shipment.
Shady Knoll, a New York distillery, along with three Washington consumers, sued the state, claiming that the law was unconstitutional as it improperly restricted interstate commerce and violated the precedent established in Granholm v. Heald. In Granholm, the Supreme Court rejected laws in New York and Michigan that permitted DtC shipping by only in-state wineries as a violation of the Constitution’s Commerce Clause.
Washington attempted to dismiss the case, arguing that, even if the law was discriminatory (which it did not concede), the 21st Amendment gave it free rein to set up its internal alcohol market, including the right to establish laws that discriminate against out-of-state interests. The state likely felt confident about making this argument, as in the last few years many other district courts have rejected DtC shipping lawsuits for similar reasons.
However, the Washington district court roundly rejected this argument, noting that while the state has a legitimate interest in the health and safety of its citizens, enabling it to regulate its internal alcohol market, the state law itself contradicted the state’s claims. That is, if the state was concerned about the risks of DtC shipping of spirits, it failed to demonstrate why that risk was only applicable to out-of-state distillers. Instead, Washington must provide clear and convincing evidence as to why shipping by out-of-state distillers threatens the health and safety of Washington consumers in a way that in-state shipping doesn’t.
While it remains to be seen how the court ultimately rules in the case, it’s a positive sign for the plaintiffs here and for proponents of DtC shipping broadly that it is applying the proper standards of review for beverage alcohol litigation as set out in Granholm and the 2018 Tennessee Wine & Spirits case.
Indeed, Washington is hardly alone in having DtC shipping laws that apply only to in-state parties.
For instance, North Carolina law permits DtC shipping of beer by in-state brewers, but not out-of-state brewers. And California recently passed a bill that extends until 2025 a “temporary” spirits DtC shipping law that is only available to craft distillers licensed by the state. (Efforts have been made in the past few years to make this law permanent and extend it to distillers across the country, but they have been stymied by in-state industry infighting.)
Even though it has been seemingly obvious since the Granholm ruling in 2005 that if states want to establish DtC shipping laws for in-state producers, they must also grant that permission to out-of-state producers, these discriminatory laws remain in place. If Shady Knoll prevails and overturns Washington’s law, that should spark efforts by producers to remove similar laws in other states.
Notably, distillers and brewers are not the only parties affected by discriminatory DtC shipping laws. Indeed, retailers have been very active in challenging such laws in recent years. These efforts have been largely unsuccessful, though, as many courts have so far uncritically accepted the states’ positions that preventing out-of-state retailers from shipping DtC, but allowing in-state retailers to do so, is part of their 21st Amendment authority.
As such, the rejection by the Eastern District of Washington of that assertion, and that states must actually prove their case with evidence, gives hope for retailers going forward. (Notably, Washington’s DtC spirits shipping law is primarily written for retailers, even though the challenger in this case is a distiller.) While whatever ruling the court ends up making will apply only to this specific Washington law, it can provide direction and guidance for other courts reviewing similar laws.
Ultimately, states would do well to avoid these legal challenges by simply adopting non-discriminatory DtC shipping laws in the first place. Indeed, with clear and widespread interest among consumers for expanded access to DtC shipping of alcohol, we can hope that many more states will act to amend their laws in the coming years and establish a proper, regulated national DtC shipping market for beverage alcohol.
Learn how ShipCompliant Direct can help you stay compliant with all of your DtC shipping needs.
Direct-to-consumer (DtC) beer shipping has remained out of reach for beer enthusiasts who crave the convenience of having their favorite brews delivered right to their doorstep. The demand for DtC beer shipping is palpable, but the supply is disappointingly scarce, with only 10 states and D.C. allowing beer to be shipped to its residents.
A substantial majority of beer enthusiasts express a strong desire to, at the very least, have the legal option to have beer shipped to their homes. Who are these consumers, and what motivates them to seek DtC beer?
These potential DtC beer customers are already passionate about their brews. They regularly purchase beer from stores and embark on pilgrimages to craft breweries in search of unique flavors and limited-edition batches. These consumers know that the types of beer they want are out there but may be difficult to find on the shelves of their local retailers.
Those aged 34-44 and those with children under the age of 18 living in their household are particularly interested in purchasing beer DtC. These consumers are looking for convenience, as their responsibilities and commitments make it challenging to visit a brewery or specialty beer store. This insight disproves claims that mothers and families are universally opposed to the idea of shipping alcohol and instead, suggests that convenience is a compelling factor in their beer choices.
The benefits of offering DtC shipping extend beyond the immediate revenue impacts. If a brewery offered DtC shipping, 82% of regular craft beer drinkers would likely buy from that brewery more often, and 85% of them would recommend their friends and family do the same. If consumers know that their friends and family, regardless of their location, can enjoy the brewery’s beer, they become more likely to recommend it to their loved ones. DtC beer shipping, in this context, becomes a powerful tool for building brand loyalty and word-of-mouth marketing.
It’s abundantly clear that consumers want DtC beer shipping, however, legal barriers have held back the industry’s full potential. Craft breweries are poised to benefit greatly from expanded DtC shipping permissions, as long as they approach this opportunity with realistic expectations and set prices that ensure a good return on investment without overextending themselves.
It’s time for the beer industry to collaborate and extend the map of available legal beer shipping options. All that consumers are asking for is a chance to meet the clearly evident demand for DtC beer. It’s a win-win situation, and it’s time for the beer industry to raise a glass to a more accessible and consumer-friendly future.
Learn how Sovos ShipCompliant helps breweries keep up with compliance.
It’s hard to avoid headlines discussing artificial intelligence (AI) these days, whether it’s how ChatGPT is being used in court cases or how teachers must learn to spot computer-generated essays. But how could this technology impact the beverage alcohol industry? Is AI already being used, and if so, how?
Let’s see how AI is currently being served in bev alc, and what it could – possibly – mean for the future of drinks.
A common way that AI can benefit bev alc is through consumer research and analysis. Companies can take a deeper dive into customer purchasing patterns and work to create actionable information from massive data sets.
For example, AI has been found to increase engagement, purchase intent and actual product orders. DRINKS, a company that enables alcohol e-commerce for retailers, online marketplaces and alcohol companies, conducted a study to see how more relevant customer recommendations generated by AI can impact wine purchases.
Based on bottle and label attributes and inferred customer behavior, the study showed increases in engagement (113%), click through rates (117%), addition of products to cart (118%) and product favoring (133%).
The rise of ChatGPT – a chatbot capable of generating text by utilizing user-entered prompts and pulling from its large language model and data – has led to amusing scenarios where people have it rewrite favorite TV shows, but it could also be utilized in marketing. Organizations might use AI for assistance in writing emails, crafting social media posts or compiling basic blog posts (this particular post was 100% written by a human, I promise).
Chatbots have long been utilized for customer support, answering basic questions and responding to customers to help determine where that customer should be routed to or what type of help they may need from a company.
But how close to Skynet are we actually getting? Hopefully not very, but some companies have started to use AI when it comes to creating alcoholic drinks. Several years ago, Japanese-based Sapporo announced that it would be using AI to help develop new products for its ready-to-drink (RTD) cocktails. Marketers would input a general concept into the AI, choose flavor descriptors (e.g., sharp, sour) and even use past Sapporo products as a reference.
Similarly, AB InBev launched Beck’s Autonomous earlier this year – a beer and marketing campaign created with AI.
“AI created a recipe that uses local German produce and 100% natural ingredients. The concept that AI created a pure recipe we found super exciting. It certainly knows it’s beer and what makes Beck’s so delicious,” Beck’s marketing director, Laura Salway, told the drinks business.
AI designed the beer name, container and custom logo, and even was used to prepare all advertising campaign assets. A trial run of 450 cans was set to be available in the United Kingdom, Germany and Italy in April.
As with most things though, there can be too much of a good thing. ChatGPT is far from perfect, and there have been documented cases of plagiarism – specifically within the wine industry – and of the chatbot taking liberties with its definition of “real” scenarios. When utilizing AI, it’s important to check that you have not gotten fully plagiarized work or that something is untrue.
Organizations should still work to anticipate new and updated regulations in bev alc that encompass outputs from AI and humans alike. Remember: bad behavior, whether human or AI driven, will be frowned upon by regulators.
While we can’t predict the future, we do know that technology and the bev alc industry as a whole are continuously evolving. Big data and analytics have evolved into AI that can design new types of alcoholic beverages, but the overarching goal remains the same: give the customers what they want.
Learn more about how ShipCompliant Direct can help your organization stay current with DtC shipping in the ever-evolving beverage alcohol industry.
Sovos ShipCompliant recently released its second annual Direct-to-Consumer Spirits Shipping Report, in partnership with the American Craft Spirits Association (ACSA). In just its second year, the report shows consumer demand for DtC spirits shipping is on the rise, with 87% of regular craft spirits drinkers saying they want to be able to legally purchase craft spirits via DtC shipping — up from 80% in 2022. The report also features in-depth analysis of the craft spirits direct-to-consumer (DtC) channel through a consumer poll, as well as ACSA’s perspective on how the market can continue to make strides.
Here are five key takeaways from the report that show the current – and potential future – state of the DtC craft spirits shipping channel.
For the second year in a row, the Direct-to-Consumer Spirits Shipping Report shows that consumers are interested in DtC spirits shipping. Specifically, 86% said they would be likely to try a new spirit from a distillery or purchase from a distillery more frequently (82%) if DtC shipping were offered. Furthermore, 75% said they would be likely to sign up for a distillery’s subscription club if DtC shipping of products was an option. However, there have been no official regulation changes. While several states made moves to push DtC shipping laws forward, there are still only eight states – and Washington, D.C. – that allow for spirits to arrive on your doorstep.
It’s time for the industry to take the next step in expanding DtC spirits shipping permissions. With multiple states working to meet consumer demand, it’s time for law makers and others to make efforts toward the same goal. Currently there are more than 122,000 spirits brands in the U.S., while between 13,000 and 16,000 new spirits brand registrations have been approved by the TTB over the past few years. The product is there, the demand is there – it’s time to implement safe and regulated options to bring the two together.
These surveys were conducted online within the United States by The Harris Poll on behalf of Sovos ShipCompliant from August 21-23, 2023 among 2,017 adults ages 21+, among whom 598 drink craft spirits/liquor at least once per month.
Download the 2023 Direct-to-Consumer Spirits Shipping Report for more information and key insights into the DtC spirits channel.
On January 1, 2024, wines and spirits sold in California will become subject to the state’s Container Recycling and Litter Reduction Act, or bottle bill. As the effective date draws near, wineries and distilleries selling in California need to prepare themselves for the new requirements. (Beer and low-ABV mixed drinks were already part of the Act.)
The bottle bill is designed to encourage recycling by providing a rebate to consumers who bring their used containers to a certified recycling center, and California is just one of several states with such a program.
While most of the provisions of the bottle bill, including collection and remittance of the California Redemption Value (or CRV, the 5, 10 or 25 cent deposit), cannot be acted on until after the start of the new year, there is one essential step that suppliers selling in the state should do sooner than later: registration with CalRecycle, the state’s department managing recycling.
All California-based manufacturers, Certificate of Compliance holders and Direct Shipper Permittees will need to register with CalRecycle as a “manufacturer.” Manufacturers, as defined by the bottle bill, do not collect the CRV from consumers but must still report the amount of subject containers they sell in the state and pay a small fee ($0.00452) per container.
Direct Shipper Permittees will also need to register as a “distributor,” as they make direct sales to consumers and so will need to collect and remit the CRV.
Registration as either a manufacturer or a distributor is available online or on a paper form available on CalRecycle’s website, along with links to lots of other useful information for suppliers subject to the bottle bill.
A word of caution on the registration form: when asked to provide the date when they began sales or transfers into California, wineries and distilleries should list January 1, 2024, as that is the date when they will be subject to the bottle bill, and not whatever date in the past that they actually opened to business in the state.
Getting ahead of registration is highly recommended as CalRecycle expects to be very busy this fall and winter processing all of the new applications. So, save yourself some stress over the holidays and don’t scramble to become compliant with the new bottle bill provisions at the last minute.
Learn more about how Sovos ShipCompliant Direct can help you wrangle the latest DtC compliance requirements.
The two-day 2023 Sovos ShipCompliant Beverage Alcohol Summit virtual event included a wide variety of speakers covering topics that affect every level of the industry. Some of the highlights from the event are presented below.
Dr. J Jackson-Beckham, of Brewers Association, shared five strategies to build diversity, equity, inclusion and justice into the culture of your organization. Diversity drives innovation, and as Jackson-Beckham pointed out, innovation and nimbleness are necessary in the current bev alc space. Diversity, equity, inclusion and justice are not just a program or initiative, they must be a holistic part of your organization to produce the benefits all wish to see.
Nathan Westfall of Vine Valley Analytics & Strategy and Erlina Doherty from Vinicola discussed the use case for AI in your day-to-day business. Tools like ChatGPT can be helpful in drafting emails, blogs and social posts (though we promise this one was written by a human). Other AI tools can write code for your website, act as a chatbot to offer customer support and for pricing optimization. Many may feel hesitant about losing the human touch with tools like these, but Westfall reiterated that this isn’t meant to take jobs, but rather make the more mundane parts of your day easier, freeing up your time for the more complex and nuanced tasks facing your business. Generative AI tools “learn” from data supplied by users, so you may find that its outputs contain biases. Because of this, Doherty cautioned that it’s the responsibility of the users to consider intellectual property and product liability rules before using content created by tools like ChatGPT.
Sovos ShipCompliant’s Alex Koral moderated a discussion between Chas Runco of Runco & Proffitt and Bethany K Hatef of Davis Wright Tremaine focusing on suppliers who wish to add direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping to their strategy alongside three-tier distribution to better meet consumer demand.
The trio shared the options available for producers, importers and suppliers to ship beer, wine and spirits. The rules vary depending on who you are and the product you sell, and guilds across the country are engaged in grassroots efforts to further open up the DtC beer and spirits markets to achieve parity with the DtC wine market.
Self-distribution also came up as another interstate sales option that has drawn recent interest from bev alc producers. In the few states that allow it, Runco says it’s an incredibly valuable tool for breweries, distilleries and wineries to get their products to retailers or consumers. So-called three-tier direct-to-consumer services that offer established suppliers to market, advertise and sell onto their websites were also discussed, with all three speakers warning of the legal concerns associated with this business model.
Kater Bernot and Bryan Roth of Good Beer Hunting shared how category-agnostic drinkers are shaping the wine, spirits, beer and other beverage alcohol categories, and how producers can use data to better understand and react to today’s market. By conducting interviews with Millennial and Gen Z drinkers, they found that switching between categories isn’t motivated by taste preferences per se, but rather by mood and who they are drinking with. Alcohol companies are adapting to the mind shift of consumers by marketing to the flavor experience, focusing on seasonality, occasion and emotion rather than calories or ABV.
Each year we aim to have the regulators themselves speak at the Beverage Alcohol Summit, and this year was no different. Janelle Christian and Chris Thiemann, representatives of the TTB, offered news, updates and general advice about interacting with the bureau for your regulatory needs. They offered updates on an executive order regarding competition in the wine, beer and spirits industries and new labeling rules regarding alcohol facts, allergen and ingredient information. The bureau’s top priorities are updating and modernizing the customer experience of the TTB website, simplifying the list of materials needed for permits and tax forms and keeping processing times down.
Legal experts Shauna Barnes, Elke Hoffmann, Arielle Albert and Alex Koral wrapped up the two-day summit by discussing the major issues and concerns in the industry. They offered the legal perspective around developing products like ready-to-drink spirits, hard seltzers and non-alcoholic beverages. They stressed the importance of realizing the limits of each license. For instance, a producer can only go-to-market with an RTD cocktail if the base alcohol is the same as what they are already licensed to produce—a brewer cannot just go ahead and make a spirits-based RTD, nor a distiller a malt-based one. Additionally, the laws around non-alcohol beverages, another newly popular product category, can get complicated and require careful review. In one state your product may be considered juice, while another views and regulates the same product as beer.
For more information on the topics covered in the Sovos ShipCompliant Beverage Alcohol Summit, check out our blog. There, you’ll find the latest updates, trends, news and insights affecting the beverage alcohol industry.
Learn more about managing your DtC alcohol shipping compliance.
The beverage alcohol industry might no longer be strictly viewed as a “boys’ club,” but there are a minority of women leading organizations in the space. However, the number of women-led wineries, breweries and distilleries is on the rise, which – as we’ll explain – is likely a very positive thing for the industry.
A 2020 Santa Clara University study found that just 14% of California wineries reported a woman as their lead winemaker. However, that is an increase from the 10% reporting the same in 2011. For beer, a 2021 Brewers Association study found that 23% of brewery owners were women and just 2% of all breweries were fully-woman owned.
High Proof Creative, a woman-owned marketing agency that caters to beverage companies, launched Women in Distilling to highlight women and marginalized people in distilling. According to their numbers, there are currently 183 woman-owned, -operated and -led distilleries on their Distilling Women map. Around 160 of those are located in the U.S., making up about 8% of the 2,063 active distilleries in the country.
Women make great leaders – specifically, women-led S&P 500 companies significantly outperform businesses run by men. While 94% of the S&P 500 companies have a male CEO, research found that there is a 384% difference in returns from female-led companies over the past 10 years, compared to 261% from male led companies.
For the beverage alcohol industry, the average consumer is also changing. According to Rabobank, 2019 was the first time in the U.S. that the majority of alcohol consumers under 25 were women. Additionally, people of color represent 40% of the individuals under 25 who regularly use alcohol.
“Inviting people of different backgrounds, race, and gender to the table won’t just help companies speak to women and communities of color,” the Rabobank report states. “It can help refresh how they market to all audiences.”
There are numerous organizations working to lift up women in beverage alcohol for the benefit of all. Pink Boots Society® focuses on helping women and non-binary individuals in the fermented/alcoholic beverage industry. In addition to teaching seminar programs, the organization also raises money for educational scholarships for front-of-house and back-of-house industry careers.
“We are the women and non-binary individuals that own the companies, package the product, design the labels, serve the drinks, write about our industry – and just about everything in between,” according to the Pink Boots Society website.
Women of the Vine & Spirits (WOTVS) is a global organization hoping to help foster “a more diverse, equitable and inclusive era” in the beverage alcohol sector. With a focus on Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (DE&I) and Business Development & Innovation (BD&I) initiatives, WOTVS aims to create workplaces that are more diverse, equitable and safer for everyone.
A WOTVS study found that there is still lots of room for improvement in that regard, with just one in 10 women working in the beverage alcohol industry saying a significant positive change toward women overall in the last five years has occurred. The majority of respondents also said their company’s leadership team has an underrepresentation of women and people with diverse backgrounds.
As we’ve discussed here, greater equity and gender parity can be strong tools for creating businesses that are poised to succeed on every level. Customers are diverse, with ever-evolving tastes. A diverse leadership team is better poised to focus on how to best reach those consumers – whoever they may be. Beverage alcohol companies don’t have to necessarily change leadership overnight just for the sake of doing so, but they can perhaps take a closer look in how they market their products and what sort of offerings they have to get products to consumers.
Learn more about how ShipCompliant Direct can help your business update its approach to DtC shipping in the beverage alcohol industry.
Unless Congress is able to pass an appropriations bill in the next few days, the U.S. government is set to shut down all nonessential services effective October 1, 2023. This will include (among many other agencies) the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB), which will impact the beverage alcohol industry.
If the shutdown occurs, the TTB will have to suspend most of its activities including:
Alcohol excise taxes may (and should) still be filed during a shutdown as per usual, either by paper or through pay.gov.
Formula, COLA and permit applications may also continue to be submitted to the TTB during a shutdown, however the TTB will be unable to review or approve anything submitted until after an appropriations bill has been passed. Once the shutdown has passed, the TTB will begin working through the backlog of applications it has received, which could take several weeks or more depending on how long the shutdown lasts.
If it happens, this will be the fourth government shutdown in the last 10 years, each of which has at least temporarily affected the TTB’s functions. It is impossible to predict how long a shutdown may last, however it is hoped that the House of Representatives will be able to come together and resolve on a funding plan quickly.
Subscribe to the Sovos ShipCompliant blog for the latest beverage alcohol compliance updates and insights.
A trend of the last few years has been the surge in new products entering the beverage alcohol market, from hard seltzers to RTD cocktails, along with the entry of well-established, traditionally non-alcoholic brands, like Hard Mountain Dew and Simply Spiked. While the growth of hard soft drinks is great for consumers, who benefit from the expanded selection and additional styles to try, some of these products bring with them the serious risk of consumer confusion.
Consumer confusion is a key issue underpinning beverage alcohol regulation in the U.S. For perfectly understandable reasons, it is critical that consumers both are informed as to what they are buying and that they can trust the accuracy of that information.
It’s annoying if a consumer buys what’s labeled a Riesling only to find out it’s actually a Sauvignon Blanc. But when there is a product on a shelf that would normally be available for kids to drink, but now has an ABV, then the potential risks become extreme. That many of these alcoholic versions of established brands are sold in the same stores—or even in adjoining aisles—to their non-alcoholic counterparts, heightens the concern.
Alcohol producers (particularly new entrants that may not be as familiar with the industry’s standards) must do their part by recognizing the risks associated with any such potential confusion—and by abiding by the state and federal laws designed to eliminate such confusion.
Proper and accurate labeling is one of the mainstays of alcohol regulations. Ensuring that consumers know what they’re buying—and can trust that those statements are accurate—has been central to beverage alcohol law going back to the very earliest days following the repeal of Prohibition.
All alcoholic beverages sold in the U.S. are subject to federal regulations and laws that require clear and direct disclosure of their contents and nature. Beers, wines and spirits must be labeled as such, and all products that have an ABV greater than 0.5% must include the standard Government Warning label.
The Trade and Tax Bureau (TTB) governs these federal laws and issues Certificates of Label Approval (COLA) for beverage alcohol products reviewed for compliance with federal labeling standards. Through the COLA process the TTB lends an imprimatur to brands that, at least officially, are clearly and accurately labeled in a way that an average consumer should know what they are buying.
This is not to say that the COLA process is foolproof, however. Indeed, many alcoholic products are exempt (or excluded) from getting a COLA due to how federal law is written. Malt beverages that do not contain hops and wines with an ABV under 7% (which would include most juice-based beverages) cannot receive a COLA and so will not be reviewed by the TTB prior to sale. That many of the developing products like malt-based hard seltzers or spiked juices would fall into these exclusory categories is potentially problematic. (These products are still subject to federal laws around clear and accurate labeling and must still include the Government Warning; they just would not be reviewed by the TTB for a COLA prior to sale.)
Even if a brand label strictly adheres to the letter of the law, there is still the potential for consumer confusion, which means that suppliers should take additional measures to ensure that consumers are fully aware of what they are buying when they pick up a product from the shelf.
Above all, this means not being coy or cute about labeling. Especially for established brands that typically do not contain alcohol (spiked juices and sodas), they should loudly and very visibly announce that they are an alcoholic version. Don’t rely on consumers to read the small print on the side or back of the label; don’t slip a small “spiked” or “hard” in quotes, barely visible near the brand name; don’t make your alcoholic labels nearly indistinguishable from your non-alcoholic labels. Be direct, even proud, of the new format available of your beloved brand, and call out that it is alcoholic.
There are also many other industry principles and standards that new market entrants need to be aware of beyond clear and visible labeling. These include limiting where alcoholic beverages can be advertised and marketed. Avoid markets that are even moderately populated by minors—like many social media platforms—and make sure your ads are not even possibly seen as targeting kids.
Ultimately, these rules and standards are designed to prevent any alcoholic product from seemingly being attractive to kids, which is a principled goal that everyone in the beverage alcohol industry should work towards. These principles, however, can be taken to an extreme, where regulators and lawmakers act to prevent all apparently “kid-friendly” versions of adult products from being sold.
At times this can feel onerous—after all, many adults like sweet things and the brands they grew up with. But remember that it comes from seeking the safety of minors above all else. And if it seems like the beverage alcohol industry is being cavalier about that safety, then there certainly could be additional regulations down the road that could prohibit the sale of products that are attractive to minors, however that is defined.
No one wants minors to get their hands on these spiked products, even accidentally—and no one wants this burgeoning market to collapse because regulators think their concerns are being ignored. As an industry, it serves us all to recognize both that this is an issue that we have been working with and managing for decades, if not centuries (after all “hard cider” v. “apple juice” has been an issue since people first started fermenting apples). And we need to recognize what we all can do to prevent that confusion, from better and more visible labeling of beverages to where spiked or hard versions of established brands are placed in retail stores.
Learn how Sovos ShipCompliant’s Market Ready platform can help streamline and automate the brand label process.
There may only be two certainties in life, but consumer preferences are still undoubtedly going to evolve over time. This is definitely true in the direct-to-consumer (DtC) wine industry. Whether consumers are pushing for greater sustainability, increased transparency through a brand’s marketing or want something else entirely, wineries must work to incorporate that into their approach to DtC channel building.
We’ll break down some of the top ways that changing consumer demand is pushing the DtC wine industry to look at new and more innovative ways of getting products to wine drinkers.
Younger generations, specifically Millennials and Gen Z, are getting older and continue to have more purchasing power. But they have not typically led the way when it comes to DtC wine purchasing. We’ve previously discussed how younger generations have different wants when it comes to DtC wine. Silicon Valley Bank’s 2023 State of the Wine Industry report, working with Sovos ShipCompliant/Customer Vineyard data, found that consumers under the age of 60 have lower wine consumption. Over one-third (35%) of consumers aged 21 to 29 years old said that they drink alcohol, but not wine.
However, this doesn’t necessarily mean that younger generations will never want to partake in vino. It might just be a matter of meeting your consumers halfway. A recent Wine Enthusiast article interviewed those in the wine industry who were under the age of 40, with the experts saying anything from creative tasting experiences to improved social media presence to being more relatable and inclusive could all make a difference to younger consumers.
The latest vintage’s price point can also be an issue for Millennials and Gen Z. Our own 2023 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report found that wines priced at $100 or more per bottle increased their volume shipped by 7.8% in 2022, while wines priced under $30 per bottle dropped in volume by 17.5%. This could be an issue of wineries not clearly communicating the product’s value, according to bw166. Overall, wineries cannot afford to ignore younger generations, and certainly not to completely discount them simply because they haven’t previously led the way in wine purchases.
Eco-friendly options for the wine industry, specifically with regard to packaging, are becoming more common. For example, the North Bay Business Journal highlighted how one Sonoma County winery uses bottles that are 100% made from recycled materials and are slightly lighter than the standard 750 mL wine bottle – requiring less fuel to transport the product.
Companies focused on creating tasty, boxed wines are also looking to make a splash in the DtC wine market. One boxed wine startup told Modern Retailer that its packaging creates 84% less waste than glass bottles and wine can stay fresh up to six weeks after being opened.
On the regulatory side of things, while states do not necessarily ban specific container types when it comes to wine (i.e., glass v. cans v. boxes), there could be different tax scenarios that shippers would need to consider, as taxes on alcohol are ultimately size based. Additionally, states will have volume per shipment limits, but that is more to ensure that consumers are not purchasing too much of a product from a supplier at one time.
As wineries look into potentially adjusting their packaging, it will be important to stay mindful of all rules in the states in which they operate.
With a sustainability approach in hand, wineries can then focus on marketing that to its consumers – of all ages. Jason Haas, partner and general manager of Tablas Creek Vineyard explained to Wine Industry Advisor that engaging with customers on social media was key to finding out whether or not they’d find success using a lighter bottle. Overwhelmingly, they were fine with it, he said. Having something that would fit in their wine racks was their main concern, Haas said.
Tuscany winery Cantina Salcheto posts on its website the greenhouse gas emissions it’s saved, its water footprint, waste management and employee welfare.
“In the last four or five years, the [sustainable] message that we’ve been giving is much more impactful in our business,” Michele Manelli, Cantina Salcheto CEO and winemaker, told Wine Industry Advisor. “It’s more easily attracting clients, distributors, agents and brokers.”
A Commerce7 and Sovos ShipCompliant webinar earlier this year discussed the importance of how improved ecommerce approaches can also aid in the overall marketing approach for wineries. Building shipping costs into a bottle’s overall price can help to avoid sticker shock and cart abandonment, according to Commerce7. Offering a one-click checkout experience with a mobile wallet and ensuring that marketing emails target abandoned carts can also be beneficial.
Adjusting selling tactics to meet the evolving needs of consumers, whether that means innovative packaging or a refreshed marketing strategy, is not easy. But it’s becoming clear that wineries will need to account for it all.
Subscribe to the Sovos ShipCompliant blog and never miss an update on how the DtC wine industry continues to evolve.
While the wave of litigation to remove legal barriers to retailer direct-to-consumer (DtC) keeps crashing against the breakwaters of district courts, a recent ripple in the courts may signal a potential shift in rules around self-distribution, which could have deep effects on the industry in the years to come.
First, the Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission (OLCC) settled a suit brought by a Washington brewery that asserted that the state’s beer self-distribution and DtC shipping laws were improperly discriminatory against out-of-state brewers. Rather than argue the case in front of a judge, the OLCC decided to extend the ability to self-distribute beer to Oregon retailers and to DtC ship beer to Oregon residents to all beer producers across the country. Breweries will need to get licensed and approved by the OLCC before they can affect these sales, but the prior restrictions on who could receive those licenses are now gone.
In a neat follow up, an Oregon winery filed suit against Iowa in July alleging that Iowa’s wine self-distribution laws are also unconstitutionally discriminatory. Iowa currently allows holders of a Class A wine manufacturer license to self-distribute their wines to Iowa retail shops. However, Class A licenses may only be issued to applicants of “good moral character,” which, as defined by Iowa law, is a condition that may only be achieved by being an Iowa resident (Iowa Code, Chapter 123.3(40)). The Oregon winery objects to this limitation (as might many of us), though it remains to be seen if the court will agree.
While it is quite early to predict how the Iowa case will progress, these two cases present an enticing rise of interest in self-distribution and expanding its availability to more out-of-state suppliers.
Self-distribution is an important but rather underdiscussed method of selling alcoholic beverages that could provide meaningful benefit for small and growing producers and their consumers alike.
In the three-tier system, which is how most beverage alcohol is distributed and sold across the country, there is a strict hierarchy of how products get to market: suppliers (producers and importers) may sell only to distributors, who then sell to retailers, which is where consumers can make their purchases. Distributors thus hold a privileged position in the industry as they are effectively a legally mandated intermediary, without which alcohol could not be sold in most situations.
Often enough, this is no trouble as alcohol distributors’ value can go beyond fulfilling a statutory requirement. They handle logistics and transportation and provide local contacts to help sell products. They understand the rules in their state and can help guide their suppliers to avoid legal trouble. Indeed, many industries utilize wholesale services, and it stands to reason that even without the benefit of the law, most alcohol would still be sold through distributors. But that legal mandate, along with other legal protections they have acquired over the years, can lead to poor outcomes.
Smaller producers, in particular, can struggle under the three-tier system, as many distributors lack the time or capacity to fully support new or limited production brands. (Part of this is likely a consequence of the extreme consolidation in the distributor tier over the last few decades, as today’s massive distributors chase the higher profits that established brands bring.) It can be difficult to even attract the attention of a distributor, let alone ensure that they will give your brands their due attention and care. The result is that many craft manufacturers are either unable to get into retail shops or are stuck in unprofitable distribution relationships.
To help their craft producers, many states have adopted exceptions to their strict three-tier systems, granting suppliers some permission to sell directly to consumers (such as through tasting rooms or DtC shipping), and enabling them to sell directly to retailers—self-distribution. With few exceptions, however, self-distribution rights are granted only to local, in-state manufacturers.
The Oregon and Iowa cases directly attack this in-state only permission, identifying it as a policy that unfairly discriminates against out-of-state interests. If a state allows for self-distribution, it clearly must find it to be compatible with its three-tier system and not so inherently risky or deleterious to public safety that the state can’t establish rules and procedures to control it. As such, where in-state wineries, breweries and distilleries may self-distribute, the main reason to not extend that permission to similarly situated out-of-state suppliers is protectionism.
Oregon apparently agrees and it now grants all U.S. breweries access to its self-distribution market (those breweries of course will still need to abide by Oregon’s laws when self-distributing in the state, including any licensing or tax requirements the state imposes).
Since Oregon settled the case, rather than hash it out in court, there was no discussion of the legal merits or creation of any definitive precedence that courts in other states can look to, but it is hard to see why Iowa’s wine self-distribution law would not be discriminatory when the OLCC itself thought Oregon’s self-distribution law was. And if Iowa also opens up to wider self-distribution, then a wave could quickly expand self-distribution rights across the country.
Looking to streamline your distribution compliance and management? Learn how Sovos ShipCompliant can help.
Online wine marketplaces are a way for consumers to purchase many of their favorite brands with a few clicks, and often enjoy discounted or included shipping to boot. But state regulators are starting to take note of their shipping practices. States like Ohio are arguing that these web shops are not only depriving the state of sales tax revenue, but breaking shipping laws as well. With tactics that raise question marks and states in turn raising an eyebrow, how do online wine marketplaces do it?
Many of the big online wine marketplaces do actually hold wine production licenses, including federal Basic Permits, through which they can receive the proper licenses to ship direct-to-consumer (DtC) across the country. However, there is still the legal question of how they are shipping wines brand that they do not produce or own themselves, as many states have what are called “not of own production” laws that restrict the brands that licensed DtC shippers can sell.
What qualifies as not “not of own production” varies from state to state. In the strictest scenarios, the state will say that only products produced specifically at the premises address listed on a DtC license can be shipped. If a winery owns several production facilities, each location may need its own DtC license.
If the online wine marketplace does not hold any wine production licenses, then it can only receive DtC shipping licenses if it is licensed as a retailer by its home state. It would then be very limited in its ability to DtC ship, though, as licensed wineries enjoy more expansive DtC shipping privileges than licensed retailers. Each has their own set of responsibilities and would-be shippers must tread carefully through the complex web of state regulations to ensure compliance.
Out-of-state retailers can only ship to 13 states and the District of Columbia. Eleven of these states, plus D.C, will allow shipping by retailers located in any other state, if they comply with the destination state’s rules. But California and New Mexico operate under a reciprocal process, meaning they will allow out-of-state retailers to sell directly to their residents only from retailers located in those two states.
Online wine marketplaces are not illegal, and when following each state’s shipping laws, are a healthy addition to the DtC wine industry. Wineries and retailers may elect to operate under other interpretations of state regulations, but we highly recommend they consult with their own legal counsel before acting on those interpretations.
Learn more about managing your DtC alcohol shipping compliance, whether you’re a winery or retailer.
The District Court for Arizona recently ruled against a Florida retail shop in the latest in an ongoing series of lawsuits that seek to address the right of alcohol retailers to engage in interstate direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping.
The Florida retailer in this case, which was joined by two Arizona wine collectors, argued against an Arizona rule that permits shipping of alcohol by instate retailers but denies access to that market to out-of-state retailers. While Arizona does allow DtC shipping of wine and spirits by out-of-state producers, out-of-state retailers are unable to receive any of the licenses that provide permission for DtC shipping in the state. As such, the relief the plaintiffs sought was access to the Arizona DtC market, which is only denied to them because they do not have physical presence in the state.
That the court ruled against the Florida retailer is in itself not all that surprising. Many courts in recent years have rejected similar claims by out-of-state retailers seeking equal treatment when it comes to DtC shipping rights, often with only a cursory look at the arguments being made. Generally, these cases come down to the conclusion that a state’s three-tier system is sacrosanct and because an out-of-state retailer is not a part of this state’s three-tier system, then they cannot ship in the state.
However, the Arizona case does bring up an important but thoroughly unaddressed question: why don’t states trust each other’s three-tier systems?
The court makes short work of the current standard of review for alcohol laws, quickly finding that Arizona’s law is 1) not discriminatory, and 2) even if it was, that the state has legitimate interests in preventing out-of-state interests from entering its market.
The court seems to scoff at the idea that Arizona’s laws are discriminatory, finding that both Florida and Arizona retailers are treated equally in the state in that they must abide by the same physical presence requirement in order to DtC ship in the state. That is, if a Florida retailer wants to ship DtC to Arizona residents, all it needs to do is follow the lead of an Arizona retailer and open a brick-and-mortar location in the state. Blithely, the court notes that if an Arizona company similarly didn’t have a physical premises, it also could not get the licenses necessary to DtC ship alcohol (ignoring the fact that without that license the company would also not be an alcohol retailer of any kind).
Such a ruling is almost proforma these days, as few courts have acknowledged the difficulty in opening retail stores in multiple states (apparently, these courts think that only major, national chains should have wide access to retailer shipping rights).
Regardless, the court’s real focus is not on whether the law is discriminatory or not, but on the sanctity of the Arizona three-tier system and the state’s interest in making sure that no unscrupulous retailer ever sells to one of its residents. But this begs the question, what makes Arizona’s three-tier system any better than Florida’s three-tier system?
The District Court notes Arizona’s interests in prohibiting DtC shipping by out-of-state retailers, namely in ensuring the quality of the product sold, preventing sales to minors and getting tax revenue. Of course, then, the court also finds that these interests can only be upheld through the strict application of the state’s three-tier system. That is, Arizona residents can only be assured of the quality and legitimacy of the alcohol they consume if it was sold by a licensed Arizona retailer who in turn purchased it from a licensed Arizona wholesaler.
Arizona law itself shows that the three-tier system is not the only means of upholding these interests, in that the state permits DtC shipping by out-of-state wineries and distillers. To DtC ship, the states requires those out-of-state parties to get licensed, take affirmative action to prevent shipments going to minors even accidentally (steps that are not required under the law that allows in-state retailers to DtC ship), restrict the amount of wine or spirits they ship to individual consumers, and remit all sales and excise taxes to the state. Why similar requirements could not be imposed on out-of-state retailers is not addressed. Similarly, that many other states have non-discriminatory retailer DtC shipping laws is dismissed because the court appears to be more concerned with upholding the sanctity of Arizona’s three-tier system.
This focus solely on Arizona’s three-tier system hits on an unspoken issue. For whatever reason, seemingly no court that has reviewed an out-of-state retailer shipping case has acknowledged a simple fact: the retailer plaintiffs seeking redress for these discriminatory laws are part of a three-tier system. It may not be the Arizona or Michigan three-tier system, but almost every state employs some form of the three-tier system for sales made by their retailers. (The main exceptions being control systems, which are usually more stringent than private markets). And by and large, states’ three-tier systems are functionally similar.
The District Court fails to address why Florida’s three-tier system is any less capable of upholding Arizona’s stated interests than Arizona’s three-tier system. Just as in Arizona, Florida retailers must get their product from licensed wholesalers who are tasked with ensuring the quality of the product. And Arizona is fully capable of requiring out-of-state shippers to pay the state’s taxes and/or another fee associated with their shipping volume (notably, Florida’s alcohol taxes are much higher than Arizona’s, undercutting any claim that Florida retailers are at a price advantage). The other key interest, preventing sales to minors, applies to essentially every sale across the country and the steps that a Florida or Arizona retailer would take in that arena are identical.
Where there are differences between states’ three-tier systems largely comes down to details, like whether price lists must be submitted to the state or if products must come to rest at a wholesaler’s warehouse prior to being sent to retailers. While a state might think these are important rules to uphold, they have little to do with the key state interests of maintaining public health and safety.
No one is asking for unregulated shipping permissions; open access to an existing market, denied simply because of the retailer’s geographic location, does not equate to an everything goes market. Arizona has indicated that it does not consider DtC shipping by retailers inherently illegitimate, only that it doesn’t trust out-of-state retailers to be good actors, despite those retailers being licensed by and in good standing with their home state’s alcohol regulators.
So, it all comes down to the simple, unaddressed question: why don’t states trust each other’s three-tier system?
Subscribe to the Sovos ShipCompliant blog and never miss an update about the three-tier system.
This virtual event turns the spotlight on challenges and opportunities across both the three-tier and DtC distribution channels for beverage alcohol companies of all types. Stay tuned for agenda and registration information.