North America
Book a Call

Often, the first thing you notice about a beverage alcohol product is the label. The typeface, imagery and colors used were all meticulously chosen to say something about the product and brand. But it takes more than an eye for graphic design to create a beverage alcohol label. There are several regulatory concerns at play that beverage alcohol producers need to be aware of. 

Each alcoholic category has its own requirements for labels, as do some states, so attention to detail is necessary to successfully manage labels and COLAS.

3 Things You Need to Know About Alcohol Labels

Alcohol labels need government approval

A Federal Certificate of Label Approval (COLA) is a federal registration of the label applied to beverage alcohol packaging. With some exceptions for low-ABV wines and select malt beverages, alcohol suppliers and producers must obtain these from the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB) before they distribute their products.  

As a federal label registration, an active COLA signifies that the label has been authorized for sale by the TTB and that it contains the required important consumer safety information without any prohibited verbiage or images.  

Applications take time

When planning your go-to-market strategy, consider COLA processing times. While the TTB allows for select label revisions that do not require getting a new COLA, often enough any change to a label will entail a new application. Always keep the associated wait times in mind when planning to update a label or product, not just when registering a new product. 

The same can be said for labels that are returned from the TTB without approval. Untrue health claims, government iconography and disparaging remarks that demean a competitor are a few reasons that your label may be sent back for corrections. After reviewing your label, take another look at the TTB’s guidelines, make the necessary changes and resubmit your application, but know that your re-submission will go to the back of the line. 

Multiple state registrations are needed for alcohol labels

If you have a footprint in 20 states and a new label comes out, odds are you’ll need to submit the label for approval in each state. If you have a footprint in one state and are introducing six new products, each of the products coming to market will need to be registered separately.  

Choosing a compliance partner that streamlines the registration process will save hours of your time by pre-populating all required fields and supporting documents for each new locale and product registration. That way, all you need to do is print, file electronically or submit automatically.   

Sovos ShipCompliant’s Market Ready empowers businesses to navigate the complexities of COLA management with confidence. In an era defined by regulatory scrutiny and evolving customer preferences, Market Ready offers efficiency to enable businesses to thrive in a competitive market. 

Take Action

Ready to simplify alcohol labels? Sovos ShipCompliant Market Ready is integrated with the TTB, making managing COLAs and label registrations easier than ever. Watch our video series for a deep dive into the features and benefits of Market Ready. 

Why is it that direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of wine is available nearly nationwide, but is only available in a dozen or so states for beer and even fewer for spirits? This is the question that underscored a recent panel I participated in alongside Steve Gross, VP of state relations for Wine Institute, and Sam DeWitt, director of state government relations for Brewers Association. 

Speaking at the recent Craft Brewers Conference in Las Vegas, we delved into the history of wine DtC shipping, how it became the $4 billion market it is today and what it will take for the beer market to achieve similar success.  

The idea for the panel developed at a time when interest in DtC beer shipping opportunities has never been greater among both brewers and consumers. Despite this interest, though, the availability of legal DtC beer shipping lags behind wine, much to the chagrin of the beer industry. 

How wine DtC shipping grew

One of the central messages of our panel was that DtC wine shipping wasn’t built in a day. As Steve Gross, arguably the person most responsible for the current state of DtC wine shipping, noted, it took decades of work and millions of dollars to put together the state-by-state lobbying efforts that created the broadly open map wine enjoys today.  

At one time, DtC wine shipping was severely limited, with only a handful of states allowing it. By the mid-2000s, proponents had managed to establish DtC wine shipping options in roughly half of the country, though there was a hodgepodge of rules and restrictions, including reciprocity laws, that made the system terribly difficult to navigate. Additionally, several states had in-state-only DtC shipping laws, which threatened to further divide the industry by instilling the idea that states could discriminate against out-of-state interests simply because they were regulating the sale of alcohol. 

This all came to a head in 2005 with the now celebrated Granholm v. Heald ruling, wherein the Supreme Court ruled that if a state were to allow any DtC shipping of wine, it would have to enable all wineries across the country to have access to that market. 

With the Granholm ruling in effect, Wine Institute and consumer interest groups like Free the Grapes! began the effort to extend national DtC shipping rights in each and every state. This was not a fast or simple campaign, however, as each state had to be lobbied individually. Some states even decided to remove all DtC shipping permissions, rather than open up to the national market (though they all later reversed that stance). 

And indeed, the drive to fully open up the U.S. to DtC shipping is ongoing, with three states that are still closed entirely and a half-dozen more with restrictions in place that severely hamper would-be DtC wine shippers. Nevertheless, the story that Steve detailed was one of broad success and achievement for wine makers and wine consumers alike. 

How can beer DtC shipping grow as well

What lessons can the beer industry learn from what wine went through? 

First, brewers can recognize that DtC beer shipping is an extremely popular idea among consumers. As detailed in the latest Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report, produced by Sovos ShipCompliant in conjunction with Brewers Association, nearly 90% of regular craft beer consumers (and 68% of all respondents) believe that the laws that restrict their access to DtC shipments must be updated, with 80% noting that they had tried beers that were not distributed in their local markets but which they would buy if shipping was available. 

I pointed out at the panel how the responses from the report were not merely about individual sales, but also documented how greater DtC shipping availability would spur interest in craft breweries if consumers knew they could have a chance to try their beers without traveling across the country. That interest would similarly translate to more purchases at retail establishments, meaning that DtC shipping is not about taking anything away from the three-tier system but is simply another way for consumers to engage with the brands they love and explore new brands. 

This message was underscored by Sam DeWitt, who provided the Brewers Association’s position on DtC beer shipping as a tremendous opportunity for the craft beer industry, if it can grow and expand. At a time when the craft beer market is missing the boom days of the last decade, DtC shipping could be a boon. While it is not a panacea for all brewers—it is expensive to ship beer after all, and many craft breweries justifiably see serving their local communities as sufficient—getting even half of what the wine industry has been able to build is, in a word, not small beer. 

And while it will take effort to change the laws among the many states where beer DtC shipping is currently illegal, the beer industry will benefit by following what the wine industry has accomplished. For one, there should be no need to go back to the Supreme Court—in terms of the Granholm ruling, breweries are virtually indistinguishable from wineries and the principle of non-discriminatory treatment when it comes to DtC shipping rules should equally apply. 

Further, there is the readymade playbook that the wine industry developed for how to successfully lobby for reformative legislation: work with local guilds and producers to create a unified front; engage consumers and channel their frustration at the lack of availability of DtC shipping into grassroots lobbying; and above all recognize and comply with the laws as they exist—any sign that this market is not manageable currently will be used to argue that it can never be made legitimate.  

Two things came through clearly from the panel: DtC shipping of beer is popular and there is an established method for legalizing that market similar to how DtC wine shipping works. If we can come together as an industry and as consumers, we can bring about the positive opportunities that regulated DtC beer shipping promises.

Take Action

For more insights into the DtC beer market, download the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report.

While only 11 states and D.C. allow direct-to-consumer (DtC) beer shipping, more than half of Americans ages 21+ (51%) would purchase more craft beer if they were able to have it shipped directly to their home. In this blog, we discuss the top three reasons why craft beer drinkers want beer sent directly to them via third-party shipping.

One of the key findings of the recently released 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report is the strong desire among Americans to have the option of purchasing craft beer directly from breweries and having it shipped to their homes. This is particularly true among regular craft beer drinkers, with nearly 4 in 5 expressing interest in DtC beer shipping. Craft beer drinkers’ enthusiasm for DtC shipping isn’t surprising given the convenience and access it offers to a wider range of brews, including those from out-of-state breweries.

Delivery is now a way of life

The growing interest in DtC beer shipping reflects a broader trend in consumer preferences towards online shopping and direct-to-consumer channels. From clothing and self-care products to food and beer, consumers are looking to have various everyday items delivered directly to their front doors. When focusing specifically on regular craft beer drinkers, the desire to purchase and have items delivered directly to their homes via a third-party carrier remains strong. While clothing tops the list with 69% expressing interest, beer follows closely behind at 61%.

Craft beer drinkers value variety

Craft beer enthusiasts are always on the lookout for new and exciting brews. Where allowed, DtC shipping offers a gateway to explore a vast array of craft beers from breweries across the nation, including unique and hard-to-find beers that may not be available locally.

With the ability to have beer shipped directly to their doorstep, consumers can access brews that may not be available in their local area. According to our report, 85% of regular craft beer drinkers say the ability to purchase beer for DtC shipping would increase their likelihood of trying out-of-state beers. This opens up a world of possibilities for beer aficionados to discover hidden gems, limited releases and unique flavors, ultimately enriching their craft beer experience.

DtC shipping is convenient

With DtC shipping, craft beer lovers can have their favorite brews, and ones new to them, delivered directly to their doorstep. Whether it’s a busy workweek, inclement weather or a lack of local retailers, DtC beer shipping offers convenience to craft beer drinkers. By streamlining the purchasing process, DtC shipping allows consumers to spend less time shopping and more time enjoying their favorite and new to them beverages.

Take Action

Discover more insights into the DtC beer market in the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report.

2024 is shaping up to be a banner year for legislative efforts related to the direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of beverage alcohol. While these proposed laws span a range of legal issues, the primary driver of the bills is expanding access to the DtC market for beer and spirits producers.

Currently, 47 states and D.C. permit DtC shipping by domestic wine producers—but only eleven and eight states do so for beer and spirits, respectively. As the DtC wine shipping market has blossomed over the years into a $4 billion annual market, it is no wonder that the beer and spirits industries would be vigorous in their efforts to achieve legal parity and grow their own available markets.

DtC Spirits & Beer Shipping Legislation

As of this writing, over a dozen states have active legislation that would establish new access for DtC shippers. (These bills are not only for beer and spirits, as they include Delaware HB 262, which would open that state to wine shipping for the first time.) The states that are looking at this issue range widely, both geographically and in terms of market share, from Hawaii to New Jersey, from South Dakota to California. The list includes two control states (Maine and Iowa), which is notable as debates around DtC shipping of spirits often raise questions of how it would affect a state’s control system.

These bills vary in the types of sales they would cover, with many of them applying only to either beer or spirits (or in the case of New York, cider only—though that state does have a separate bill for all alcoholic beverages).

Broadly, the bills are structured nearly identically to the existing rules that govern DtC shipping of wine and so would establish standard licensing and tax obligations, along with requiring the DtC shipper to accept the jurisdictional authority of the states they ship to. Many would also prohibit the shippers from shipping too much product at a time, and a few establish production caps, limiting DtC shipping to only smaller, craft producers. These rules have largely worked for the wine industry and provide the means for states to enforce their rules against out-of-state shippers, and there is no reason to not believe they also wouldn’t work for beer and spirits.

The spread of proposed legislation around DtC shipping of beer and spirits reflects both a commercial interest within those industries and growing desire among consumers to be able to have beer and spirits shipped to their homes. Consumers are increasingly aware of craft and unique products that do not get wide distribution and are therefore completely inaccessible through a strict three-tier system.

Unsurprisingly then, recent studies commissioned by Sovos ShipCompliant in conjunction with the Brewers Association and the American Craft Spirits Association have shown clear public support for changing laws related to DtC shipping of beer and spirits. Notably, this support is not limited to just regular alcohol consumers but is spread across the public at large.

However, it is far too early in the game to be too optimistic about any of these bills. The legislative process is a fickle one, with numerous pitfalls along the way, and most proposed legislation dies before its state’s session ends. Unfortunately, there are also many interests out there that are opposed to expanded DtC shipping, because they fear increased competition, or they dislike any threat to their market share, or because they are against any alcohol sales. These interests have worked concertedly in recent years to foment industry infighting and otherwise split the pro-DtC efforts, and they will certainly be out in force against this year’s tranche of DtC bills.

However, if consumers and industry members can align and pressure their elected officials to meet their wants, then we can hope to be sharing some positive news related to DtC shipping of beer and spirits in the near future.

Take Action

Find the newest insights into the DtC spirits and beer markets with our latest reports.

Direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping has become one of the leading sales models for businesses of all sizes and in all markets. The idea of connecting directly with consumers is notably attractive, as it helps brands develop a personal relationship and avoid costly distribution chains.

Yet, for all its popularity, DtC is often a hard concept to define, especially within the beverage alcohol industry. For producers and suppliers of beverage alcohol products, the lack of clarity around what DtC means and where and how it can be done can lead to real problems if they try to do something that even approaches a regulatory red line.

Legal compliance in the sale of beverage alcohol can vary widely depending on who is selling, who is buying, what is being sold, where the sales take place and how the consumer ultimately gains possession of the products they purchase. To help clarify things, at least at a very high level, we will look at the primary ways that beverage alcohol suppliers can engage in DtC sales across the country.

Tasting room sales

One of the key ways for producers to build out their DtC sales is by hosting consumers on their premises. Indeed, consumers are increasingly seeking out new ways to connect directly with their favorite brands or find new favorites. Providing a memorable experience, whether that is through a beer garden hangout, tours of the stills or a luxurious afternoon in wine country is one of the best ways a producer can connect with their consumers.

However, producers need to know the rules and restrictions that govern tasting room sales, which can vary depending on the state they are in and the products they sell. For instance, some states still require consumers to go on a tour of a distillery before they can sample spirits, and not every state allows distilleries to sell their products for off-premises consumption. Many states also limit the volume that a producer can sell to consumers per day or restrict sales to producers of a certain size or require the producer to apply for an additional license.

It is therefore critical to thoroughly understand what you are allowed—and not allowed—to do depending on the state you operate in and the licenses you hold. But producers that can figure out how to bring consumers into their tasting rooms are best set to establish real and meaningful relationships with their customers that can encourage years of future sales.

DtC shipping

Not all consumers are able to make it to tasting rooms, though, and even those who can have become increasingly invested in online sales as a means of purchasing anything and everything. As such, the direct-to-consumer shipping model has become one of the most active and developing means of selling alcohol.

Where allowed, DtC shipping offers producers, especially craft producers, the ability to sell to consumers nationwide and avoid the complications that can make working in the three-tier system impossible. Few wholesalers are able or willing to give much attention to smaller brands, often meaning those brands will be entirely cut off from expanding into new markets despite consumer demand. And even for producers that do make robust three-tier sales, offering rare and select products to club members is a great way to remain connected to customers and goose retail sales.

But DtC shipping is also heavily regulated and largely restricted to the wine industry. Currently, 47 states and D.C. allow out-of-state wineries to become licensed to ship to consumers, whereas only 11 states plus D.C. allow shipping of beer and only 8 plus D.C. allow shipping of spirits.

Even with their more expansive map of available states, wineries face a slew of regulatory challenges when shipping, from getting the appropriate license to staying within allowable volume limits to collecting and remitting the proper tax for all of their sales. Nevertheless, DtC shipping of wine has provided a lifeline to hundreds of small wineries and access to millions of wine lovers.

However, for brewers and distillers and their consumers, DtC shipping remains very limited. This has led some to look for alternative options for selling DtC online.

Services like the late Drizly, which enable consumers to buy online from a selection of local retailers, are one way for producers to meet the demand, but they are ultimately three-tier sales and require producers to be actively distributing their products into the partner stores.

Other services have popped up in recent years to attempt to fill the gap between what the law allows and what consumers want, but many of them operate in at best a legal grey zone—and some seem wholly unconcerned with legality.

Still, consumer interest in being able to receive DtC shipments of all types of alcoholic beverages is growing. State lawmakers would do well to recognize the demand and establish clear, regulated markets for the shipping of alcohol under the laws and regulations like those that have worked for wine shipping for nearly two decades.

Take Action

Ready to take on DtC shipping but need some support? Check out A Buyer’s Guide to DtC Alcohol Shipping Compliance Software to learn more about choosing the right solution for your business.

This March, Sovos ShipCompliant released the fourth annual Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report in partnership with the Brewers Association. The DtC beer shipping report features exclusive insights on the regulatory state of the direct-to-consumer (DtC) channel, Brewers Association’s perspective and key data from a consumer preferences survey.

Let’s take a deeper dive into some of the findings from the report.

The regulatory state of 2024 DtC beer shipping

Despite several states introducing bills to expand DtC beer shipping in 2023, none of them were adopted.

As of the report’s publication, brewers may DtC ship beer across state lines to the 11 states plus D.C. that permit it. As with most things compliance, each state maintains their own rules governing the practice. Currently, Alaska, Kentucky, Nebraska, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Ohio, Oregon, Vermont, Virginia and the District of Columbia provide clear, statutory authority for brewers to legally solicit and fulfill sales remotely and across state borders. Pennsylvania and Rhode Island permit some form of DtC shipping, but their laws vary.

Strong consumer interest in 2024 DtC beer shipping

The 2024 consumer survey in the report highlights a persistent enthusiasm for purchasing craft beer through DtC shipping, showcasing continued support for the convenience and expanded choice the market brings. Additionally, future purchasing intent for beer via DtC shipping remains high.

We found a high level of support and interest in DtC beer shipping by both regular craft beer consumers and Americans 21 and older. The collective interest demonstrated by both regular craft beer consumers and all Americans of legal drinking age suggests that existing restrictive DtC beer shipping regulations hinder potential purchasers seeking access to brands unavailable locally. In fact, 78% of regular craft beer drinkers are likely to purchase via DtC shipping in the future, with 33% saying they are very likely.

Consumers rely on DtC shipping for a variety of consumer goods, and 61% of regular craft beer drinkers would like to add their favorites brews to the list of products shipped to their home via a third-party carrier. This segment favors beer delivery over food (60%) and cleaning products (58%).

Benefits for breweries

Expanded DtC beer shipping wouldn’t just positively impact consumers, but breweries too. A strong majority of regular craft beer drinkers say, if a brewery had the option for customers to purchase beer via DtC shipping, they would be likely to recommend that brewery to family and friends, think more positively of that brewery or try a new beer from a brewery (86% each). More than 4 in 5 (83%) would be likely to purchase more frequently from a brewery that had the option for customers to purchase beer via DtC shipping. About 7 in 10 regular craft beer drinkers say they would be likely to share/post about that brewery on social media (70%) or sign up for a beer subscription club (68%).

Consumer Survey Methodology

This survey was conducted online within the United States by The Harris Poll on behalf of Sovos ShipCompliant between January 2-4, 2024, among 1,970 U.S. adults ages 21+, among whom 615 drink craft beer at least once per month. The sampling precision of Harris online polls is measured by using a Bayesian credible interval. For this study, the sample data is accurate to within +/- 2.6 percentage points using a 95% confidence level.

Take Action

For additional takeaways and analysis into the DtC beer channel, download the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report.

This bill was signed into law on March 28, 2024 and takes effect July 1, 2024.

Florida wine lovers could soon enjoy a bigger selection of bottles based on a recent bill passed by the state’s legislature (HR 583) that would remove the existing cap on wine bottle sizes.

What is Florida’s HR 583 bill?

Currently, Florida law prohibits the sale of wine in bottles larger than one gallon (a little over three liters), unless it is sold in a 5.16 gallon (20 liter) reusable container. As such, Florida consumers looking to enjoy a larger format wine or spice up a party by bringing along a Nebuchadnezzar have been out of luck. This restriction applies to both wines sold in Florida stores and direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipments of wine.

Under HR 583, wine could be sold in Florida in 4.5-, 6-, 9-, 12- and 15-liter glass bottles—the standard sizes for larger format bottles.

The bill has passed both chambers of the Florida legislature and has been sent to Governor Ron DeSantis’s desk for a signature. While it is possible he could still veto the bill, it was approved nearly unanimously in the legislature (there was only one “nay” vote) so it seems to have overwhelming support in the state.

Unless it is vetoed, effective July 1, 2024, Florida consumers, wine sellers and DtC shippers alike will be free to pop open a Rehoboam or two in celebration.

Regulation of wine bottle sizes

By enacting HR 583, Florida will align itself with the rest of the country in terms of what sizes wine may be sold in. This is not to say that other states do not have their own rules around bottle sizes, but Florida is unique in the extent of its restrictions. For instance, New York and Texas also have a maximum container size for wine, but they set it at 15.5 gallons or a half-barrel, quite a bit more than the largest of standard wine bottles. Indeed, size limits are more often at play on the other end, with many states restricting the sale of wine (or more commonly spirits) in containers smaller than 100 or 50 mL.

Historically, size restrictions have been more about ensuring proper collection of taxes rather than any moralistic reason. If all products are sold in uniform sizes, then the amount of tax due can be neatly calculated from the total number of bottles sold rather than having to individually assess the bottles sold by each producer.

There was also interest coming out of Prohibition in assuring consumers as to the contents of their purchases—not merely so that they could trust in the quality of what they were drinking, but also know generally how much they were consuming if they didn’t measure out each pour.

These concerns are less salient in the modern alcohol market, which has led some to advocate eliminating standardized sizes for wine bottles entirely. However, in 2019 the Trade and Tax Bureau (TTB) decided against removing the federal standard fill sizes, opting instead to add three new available sizes for wine bottles. While many of the public comments for that rulemaking did argue in favor of increased freedom for producers, ultimately arguments around consumer confusion and the value of market conformity prevailed (after all, it’s much easier to pack and shelve bottles when they’re all the same size or set of sizes).

Nevertheless, standardization of wine bottles remains an open and developing issue for the beverage alcohol industry. Currently, the TTB is conducting yet another rulemaking around a proposal to add an additional 10 possible sizes that wine could be sold in.
Depending on how the TTB rules, possibly in the coming weeks, Florida residents wouldn’t be the only ones to enjoy greater diversity in their options for buying wine.

Take Action

Discover Florida and every other state’s specific rules for DtC wine shipping in our state-by-state guide.

andrew adams wine vine analytics headshotBy Andrew Adams, Editor, Wine Analytics Report

With another year of winery direct-to-consumer shipments tallied and analyzed, the state of Washington was the only major region tracked by Sovos ShipCompliant and WineBusiness Analytics to enjoy growth over the previous year.

Compared to 2022, shipment value by Washington’s wineries grew 11% to $187 million while volume was up by nearly 6% to 390,010 cases. Average bottle prices of all Washington shipments rose by more than 5% to $39.90, which is the most affordable of all the major West Coast regions tracked in the annual report aside from the “rest of California” at $27.27.

It was some good news for the state’s wine industry that has been going through a transition as the largest Washington winery, Chateau Ste. Michelle, has reduced the number of grapes it is buying as part of a revised business strategy in response to the changed U.S. wine market.

While that strategic change has been challenging for many of Washington’s largest grape growers, it ultimately may benefit the state’s smaller wineries by freeing up quality grapes. The growth of DtC shipments in the past year may also indicate that the state’s smaller wineries are already stepping out from beneath the Ste. Michelle banner in forging a new Washington wine brand defined by smaller production, premium wines sold at higher prices that have long defined the DtC channel. According to the WineBusiness Analytics winery database, Washington is home to 872 wineries and 85% of those, or 739, produce fewer than 5,000 cases a year.

Just like every other major wine-producing region in the U.S., Washington is a top destination for DtC shipments as well. In 2023, shipments within the state surpassed out-of-state shipments by both value and volume. Total shipments by Washington wineries within the state came to $105 million, which is $24 million more than shipments out of the state. By volume, in-state shipments totaled 247,691 versus 142,311 that were shipped out of state.

Neighboring Oregon ships considerably more wine out of the state than within it, with out-of-state volume coming to more 289,858 cases, which is nearly 118,000 more than in-state shipments. By value, Oregon’s out-of-state shipments of more than $179 million were $89 million more than in-state shipments. Oregon has enjoyed a stellar decade of growth in the DtC channel, but continuing at that pace may prove a challenge as total shipments in 2023 declined 9% by volume and 2.6% by value compared to the previous year.

With out-of-state shipments already nearly double what’s shipped in state and an average bottle price approaching $50, Oregon may have hit a plateau. Washington, however, appears to have room to grow. In the past year, Oregon shipments accounted for 6.5% of all shipment volume, while Washington claimed 5.5%.

The most popular wines in the DtC market, Cabernet Sauvignon and red blends, account for 59% of Washington shipment value and 47% of shipment volume. The average price for Cabernet Sauvignon shipments from Washington in the 12 months through January 2024 was $59.82 compared to $85.96 for the entire channel in 2023, and the average for red blends from Washington was $40.67 compared to $60.82 for all shipments. More than half of all wineries in Washington produce a Cabernet Sauvignon and 34% produce a red blend, according to the WineBusiness Analytics winery database.

While total shipment volume in the channel has declined from the post-pandemic highpoint of 2021, the DtC market remains significantly larger than it was in 2019 and still accounts for more than 8% of total off-premise sales. With little growth expected for the U.S. wine market through the coming year, wineries need to be more strategic than ever in finding opportunities for growth.

For Washington wineries that already enjoyed exceptional growth in the DtC market over the past year, building on what worked last year appears to be a sound strategy for this year.

Take Action

Download the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report for the comprehensive analysis of the channel.

—-

Andrew Adams is the editor of the Wine Analytics Report, which is published by Wines Vines Analytics. Adams grew up in the city of Sonoma, Calif., before graduating from the University of Oregon with a degree in journalism. In addition to working at daily newspapers for more than a decade, Adams worked in the cellar and lab at the former Starmont winery in Napa Valley and has been a regular contributor to Wine Business Monthly magazine since 2019.

A number of recent lawsuits filed by beverage alcohol producers have raised new interest in self-distribution rights, an often-overlooked area of the industry. Self-distribution is when a supplier of alcohol, such as an importer or domestic manufacturer, is authorized to sell directly to retailers without having to work with a wholesaler to get their products to market

As an exception to the standard three-tier sales process, self-distribution is not widely available, but over the last few decades several states have relaxed their laws to allow for it. In most cases, self-distribution is only available for in-state suppliers—and then often only for smaller, craft producers. Self-distribution permissions also vary widely depending on whether it is beer, wine or spirits product that is being sold.

The goal of these lawsuits is to remove the apparent discriminatory results of existing self-distribution laws by requiring states to extend the same permissions to out-of-state suppliers.

Self-distribution has clearly been a huge boon for small, craft producers, who often struggle to earn the attention and due care from wholesalers that tend to prefer moving established brands that sell in large volumes. If these lawsuits are successful, then, they could mark a significant shift in the alcohol market in the U.S. on par—or perhaps even greater—than the evolution of the direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping market. 

The benefits of beverage alcohol self-distribution

In the dying days of Prohibition, policymakers convened on how to establish a market in the U.S. that didn’t reintroduce the perceived evils that plagued 19th century sales of beverage alcohol. Above all, they feared a return of “tied houses,” where producers would entwine themselves so closely with retail establishments through contracts and ownership arrangements that (it was argued) they could force overconsumption on hapless Americans.

The solution, as described in the seminal study Toward Liquor Control, was for there to be a legally mandated separation between producers and retailers. Going forward, state laws would require that wholesalers act as intermediaries in the sale of alcohol, establishing the three-tier system that continues to govern the beverage alcohol market in the U.S.

Over the many decades since Prohibition, the wholesaler tier consolidated dramatically resulting in a limited number of very large distributors that favored brands that required less effort to market and sold both at good margins and in high volumes. This may not have been a problem for the authors of Toward Liquor Control, but for many in the beverage alcohol industry, the limitations of the three-tier system were becoming increasingly apparent, primarily in how inefficient it was for small producers to gain any real foothold in the market. Consumers suffered as well, especially those looking for more variety in their alcohol selections

To help relieve such barriers to new market entrants, states began around the 1970s to empower craft producers by amending their laws, including adopting self-distribution rights alongside permission for tasting room sales. The modern craft alcohol market we enjoy today owes a great deal to these law changes. It’s no wonder that craft alcohol hot spots like —like California, Oregon and Colorado—were early adopters.

This is not to say that distributors are inherently a barrier to craft producers. Distributors can provide invaluable logistical and sales support—if they want to. The issue is that, especially as it became increasingly consolidated through the 20th century, the distributor tier became more focused on large brands that don’t require as much initial care when selling to retailers. By providing a path to markets that doesn’t rely on third parties agreeing to carry their products, states with self-distribution laws gave craft producers a foot in the door, allowing them to get established and grow.

Why are producers suing states?

Perhaps unsurprisingly, when states adopted self-distribution permissions, they did so with a focus on supporting their own local craft producers. As such, self-distribution is largely available only to in-state producers, and at that, often only for small beer manufacturers. Many states restrict self-distribution to select licensees that become unobtainable if they produce over a certain annual gallonage and only a handful make those licenses available to out-of-state producers.

Producers have begun to challenge those laws, arguing that they are unconstitutionally discriminatory. This argument follows from the Supreme Court’s 2005 Granholm v. Heald ruling, which found that, if a state allowed direct-to-consumer shipping of wine, it had to enable out-of-state wineries to access that market. While Granholm focused on DtC shipping, the ruling can (and arguably should) be read broadly as saying that whenever a state establishes a means for selling alcohol, it cannot restrict out-of-state entities from that market without clear and convincing evidence that it is necessary to further the state’s public health and safety interests.

Under this interpretation, if a state allows their local producers to self-distribute, it must enable out-of-state producers to also self-distribute in that state under equitable terms. And so, challenges have been brought against Iowa, Idaho, Maryland and New York, arguing that these states must open up their self-distribution laws to out-of-state producers.

This argument won a big victory last year, when Oregon acceded to a lawsuit by a Washington brewery and moved to begin issuing self-distribution licenses to out-of-state breweries. However, since that case never went to trial, there is not a clear record for future courts to follow—but hopefully those courts will note Oregon’s apparent view that its laws would not stand up to the challenge and so perhaps neither should the other states’ laws.

There is still much uncertainty about how these lawsuits will play out. Indeed, there is the potential risk that states, faced with the demand to open self-distribution up to out-of-state producers, will simply retrench and allow no beverage alcohol self-distribution. But the prospect of expanded interstate self-distribution rights—even if still only for craft producers—is tremendous and one that demands all due attention in the coming years.

Take Action

Search for self-distribution rules in our State-by-State Guide to Wine Distribution.

Last month, Sovos ShipCompliant and WineBusiness Analytics released the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report, marking the fourteenth consecutive collaboration between the two companies. Alex Koral and Andrew Adams presented an overview of the data and analysis from the report, highlighting key trends and statistics. Here, we summarize some of the noteworthy findings starting with the top wine varietals for the year. 

Top wine varietals in 2023 

The most-shipped direct-to-consumer (DtC) wine varietals have exhibited consistency over recent years, with Cabernet Sauvignon leading the pack in both volume (16.5%) and average bottle price ($85.96) last year. Pinot Noir, Red Blends, Chardonnay and Other Reds rounded out the Top 5 List. Notably, standout varietals like Chardonnay, Sparkling wines, Rose and Sauvignon Blanc, which dominated in previous years, experienced more significant declines than the overall channel. 

Wineries by size 

The largest winery size segment remains limited production, comprising wineries producing fewer than 1,000 cases annually, a large pool of truly small producers. These wineries constitute over half of the country’s total, and despite a slight 1% decrease mentioned by Adams at Unified, the numbers remain robust. The current count of U.S. wineries stands at 11,654. 

Volume and value of shipments 

2023 marked the second consecutive year of decline in volume shipped, with a 10.3% decrease in 2022 and a 6.5% decrease in 2023. Contextualizing these numbers, there was a substantial (27% and 1.4%, respectively) increase in shipments in 2020 and 2021 due to the pandemic, forcing wineries to shift significantly to DtC shipping amid tasting room closures. However, a decade-long perspective reveals an upward trend in the volume of shipments. 

While 2020 and 2021 were anomalies in the value growth of the DtC wine shipping market, the market retained a $4.1 billion valuation in 2023—$1 billion more than in 2019. 

Average price per bottle shipped 

In 2023, there was a noteworthy 7.1% increase in the average price of bottle shipped. This surge is propelled by Napa County wines, averaging $86.43 a bottle, while Sonoma wines hover at $33.04.  

Since 2012, the average price has consistently grown, despite a notable 9.5% dip in 2020, driven by pandemic buying habits. The market witnessed a decline in sales of bottles priced below $60, while ultra-premium wines priced over $200 contributed to the overall value growth. 

What’s next for Wine Varietals? 

Wineries planning for the next few years can use this information to their advantage. Whether commanding high prices or focusing on lower-priced wines (under $30), there are opportunities in the diverse DtC consumer landscape. Despite concerns about consumer sentiment and appetite, the DtC channel remains robust. 

From a regulatory standpoint, Alaska made significant changes to DtC shipping in the state. There remains optimism that Delaware may open to DtC shipments, and New Jersey may remove its production cap. Age verification and volume checks have been on the rise in the last few years, and we don’t see that stopping. While there’s no telling what may happen in 2024, Sovos ShipCompliant is ready to keep you informed of changes as they unfold. 

Take Action

Download the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report for the latest information and data on the state of the market. 

Sovos ShipCompliant recently released the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer (DtC) Wine Shipping Report with our partner, WineBusiness Analytics. This look-back at 2023 is the most comprehensive, complete and exclusive collection of data and insights on the state of the DtC channel. While DtC wine shipments saw a decline in volume for the second year in a row, the value of the channel showed resilience, remaining steady at $4.1B.

About the data in the 2024 DtC Wine Shipping Report

The 2024 DtC Wine Shipping Report takes shipment data from more than 1,250 U.S. wineries’ shipments to consumers each month, totaling more than 37 million shipments over the course of 2023. In compiling this information, each shipment is edited for submission for governmental tax and reporting requirements, and all elements are validated by standardized tables. The verified data is submitted to a proprietary model built on a database of 11,500+ wineries that is updated monthly by WineBusiness Analytics.

2024 DtC Wine Shipping Report highlights

Taking a deep dive into findings from 2023 value, volume, shipments by month, average bottle price, winery region, production tiers and varietal, the 2024 DtC Wine Shipping Report shows some noteworthy shifts to the channel. Here are some notable takeaways:

What’s on the horizon?

Tune in for our free webinar on February 7, where we will dig deeper into data and takeaways from the DtC Wine Shipping Report. Register here for the live discussion hosted by Sovos ShipCompliant and WineBusiness Analytics experts.

Take Action

Download your complimentary copy of the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report for additional insights and analysis of DtC channel trends.

I had the pleasure and privilege of attending the 2024 Direct to Consumer (DTC) Wine Symposium (DTCWS) to speak on the past and future of the direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping market. As an annual event, DTCWS provides our industry with a regular opportunity to reflect on market conditions and connect on ways we can all help build the DtC channel, which has become vital for so many wineries. 

Perhaps unsurprisingly, there was an undercurrent at DTCWS of what might be best called cautious pessimism. Reflecting the larger challenges that face the entire beverage alcohol industry, there were many questions and concerns raised by the audience about the strength of the market going forward.  

Indeed, as recent industry reports have indicated, in 2023 the beverage alcohol industry faced its worst year since 1991, with declining sales for all product types. Coupled with fears around the rise of neo-prohibitionism and developing technologies that promise major disruption for all businesses, there seems to be a real sense within the beverage alcohol industry—and especially in wine—that we are in for an extended period of headwinds. 

And yet, I couldn’t help feeling that while we certainly face no shortage of challenges affecting our market, there is still more than enough reason for optimism. If we recognize where our strengths are, where opportunities await and where the threats to our market lie, then we can push through this time of uncertainty and turn those headwinds into tailwinds. 

Challenges discovered at DTCWS

The biggest concern currently facing the wine industry (and alcohol more broadly) is the apparent decline in sales in 2023. According to market data, wine distribution was down by nearly 9% in 2023.  

There are many different causes associated with this decline, from competition from other products to lack of market penetration among younger consumers to the increasingly vocal campaign that says that any alcohol consumption is unsafe. 

Certainly, the effect of each of these challenges is real and deleterious to wine sales. Consumers do seem very responsive to “new” products crowding shelves, like ready-to-drink (RTD) cocktails, hard seltzers and no/low-ABV beverages—RTDs were essentially the only alcoholic beverage type that saw growth in 2023. And between the scaremongering studies coming out of various international and governmental bodies and reports indicating all-time low alcohol use among younger people, the cause of neo-prohibitionism has never been as charged. 

Within the DtC wine shipping market, there is an extra challenge coming from within the industry itself, as rent-seeking businesses continue to trot out all manner of alleged and unproven horrors related to DtC shipping to convince lawmakers and regulators to snuff out DtC shipping.  

On their own, each of these concerns might be enough to depress the wine market, but together they work as some kind of perfect storm. 

Still, we should not—cannot—let pessimism for the future overwhelm us. Instead, we can recognize that these challenges are hardly new and that by confronting them face on, we can even turn them to our advantage and strengthen the wine industry for years to come. 

How we remain strong

We must realize the resilience of the wine industry. Wine has been consumed and been a central part of society for thousands of years and even a 9% decline in distribution does not signal imminent collapse. Indeed, while neo-Prohibitionism is on the rise, it is still a pale comparison to actual Prohibition and could still readily turn out to be little more than a fad.  

Similarly, the kvetching about Gen Z and how they don’t drink (and don’t drink wine) is overblown. For one, most of the Gen Z cohort are still under 21 years old, so it would be alarming if their rates of alcohol consumption were on equal level with older generations. And second, wine sales have always been lower among younger drinkers. As was noted at the DTCWS, the gradual increase in wine consumption as one ages is nearly as constant as the sun rising in the east.  

That Gen Z does not drink wine as much as older generations is not a cause for panic—in fact, it could be a moment of opportunity if the wine industry can get ahead of the trends and tailor its messaging to the current consumer climate. This does mean confronting the health claims around alcohol. Not by trotting out old claims that wine is actually healthy but by pointing out the reasonable differences between overconsumption and how humanity has consumed wine since time immemorial. Saying that red wine may be beneficial to your heart is not going to change minds today but noting that a glass with dinner and friends is demonstrably unproblematic could. 

Further, wineries can take advantage of the drive for alternative beverages and offer their own takes on low- or non-alcoholic beverages. Especially for the wineries that thrive on visits to their tasting rooms, being more open to wine skeptics can be a way to bring in more tourists (and perhaps give them the chance to come around to trying some wine). While there should be some caution against simply jumping on the bandwagon of the latest trend, wineries that only offer the one thing are at risk of siloing themselves as consumers become more category agnostic. 

And of course, we should note the particular opportunity that comes with DtC shipping. As our upcoming Sovos ShipCompliant/WineBusiness Analytics 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Report will show, the DtC shipping market remained resilient as the rest of the industry faced decline. For the smaller wineries that make up the bulk of the industry, DtC shipping enables ready access to consumers across the country, which would be impossible if the only option was working through the various states’ three-tier systems.  

The major threat to DtC shipping comes from retrenchment among the states and efforts to introduce new and impossible to manage regulations. But if we can continue to work as an industry to push back against the DtC naysayers, then there is every reason to believe that DtC shipping will continue to be an area where wineries can thrive in the face of other market challenges. 

Optimism is often a tough sell, even in rosier times. When the news says the world is falling apart around us, despair can be its own kind of comfort. But it would be wrong for the wine industry to give into pessimism. Wine is strong and our industry has weathered many storms throughout its history. By keeping our cool and recognizing where the current challenges are coming from and how we have overcome them in the past, we can change our tack and make today’s headwinds tomorrows tailwinds. 

Take Action

Interested in learning more about the DTCWS, the latest information on growth trends, changes in price per bottle shipped, regional demand and varietal trends in the DtC wine world? On January 30, download the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report.

2024 has not yet begun but there are some potential upcoming regulatory changes affecting the direct-to-consumer (DtC) wine shipping market that we’re already tracking.

The first is Wisconsin SB 268, a major overhaul of the state’s beverage alcohol laws. Since the bill was signed by the governor earlier this month, the question is not so much around will it happen or not as opposed to how impactful it will end up being.

Perhaps the biggest change within SB 268 is the creation of a new division within the Wisconsin Department of Revenue dedicated to the beverage alcohol industry. The new division is intended to administer Wisconsin’s alcohol laws, including providing a source of regulatory interpretation and guidance for the industry. However, SB 268 also charges the new division to strictly police those laws, meaning that Wisconsin may step up its enforcement actions in coming years—particularly when it comes to DtC wine shippers.

Indeed, SB 268 includes several new provisions directly related to DtC wine shipping, including new licensing and reporting requirements for carriers and fulfillment houses that support the DtC industry. While Wisconsin will be hardly alone in regulating these third-party support systems, there are reasons to be concerned with the specific laws the state has adopted.

Under SB 268, both carriers and fulfillment houses will need to be licensed in order to carry or package containers for wine shippers. A fulfillment house license will cost $100 per year, but each facility the fulfillment house ships from will need to be separately licensed; carriers will need to pay $1,000 a year for their license. But more impactful than the cost, SB 268 sets up strict penalties for compliance issues by carriers or fulfillment houses—picking up a package of wine from an unlicensed shipper once brings a $2,000 fine, doing so twice results in a loss of their shipping license, meaning if FedEx or UPS make two mistakes in a year, they won’t be able to carry any more wine to Wisconsin consumers.

SB 268 also imposes new requirements for carriers to report the DtC shipments they delivered in the state. While many states have carrier reports, Wisconsin’s could end up being impossible for carriers to file, at least as it is currently established in SB 268. As drafted, carriers will need to report (among other things), the name and address of the person who manufactured the alcohol along with the type and quantity of alcoholic beverages in a package—neither of which are data points that carriers have any ability to collect or report on.

However, Wisconsin’s new carrier and fulfillment house laws won’t come into effect until January 1, 2025, so there is time for the DtC industry to work with the state and find workable solutions. Indeed, there is good reason to believe that once it is made clear to Wisconsin regulators and legislators that SB 268 as enacted could lead to the shutdown of the DtC wine market in the state, they will moderate the worst of the new regulations. Whenever other states have tried to establish similarly onerous reporting requirements or harsh penalties on carriers, they have invariably been tempered. But concerned industry members should make sure to do their part in outreach to Wisconsin policymakers and consumers to help avoid the worst potential impacts.

DtC shipping in Delaware, at long last?

The other big potential change we are tracking already for 2024 is whether or not Delaware will open up to DtC shipping. Delaware is one of the few states that prohibits all DtC shipping of alcohol (the others being Utah and Mississippi), but that is not for a lack of trying. For the past several years, concerted efforts have been made to pass a model DtC shipping bill in the state, which have not yet succeeded despite there being widespread interest by Delaware consumers for access to the DtC shipping market.

Part of the issue is that competing DtC shipping bills were introduced, splitting the support either may have received on its own. Already in 2024, there are two DtC shipping bills that have earned attention—HB 262 and HB 259. While they both would establish DtC shipping permissions, they vary in their range, with one only allowing shipping of wine, with a three case per year per person limit, and the other also permitting shipping of beer and spirits with a much higher shipping volume limit.

There is real risk that neither will pass, if proponents of DtC shipping cannot settle on a single version to support. But it is likely both bills will be amended (and possibly consolidated) as the Delaware General Assembly reconvenes in January and begins hearings on the new legislative session.

It is unlikely that Wisconsin and Delaware will be the only states with potential changes to the DtC shipping market in 2024, even if they are already on our radar for the new year. As the regulatory calendar does develop, we at Sovos ShipCompliant will make sure to keep you informed.

Take Action

Learn more about how ShipCompliant Direct can help with your DtC shipping compliance needs.

Find Sovos ShipCompliant at CBC in Vegas! We’ll be showcasing our cloud-based wholesale distribution and direct-to-consumer compliance solutions that reduce risk and lessen the burden of compliance. We look forward to meeting friends both new and old.

Sovos ShipCompliant is proud to once again sponsor the DISCUS Annual Conference in 2024. Look for us in seminars and at nightly events!

Will we see you at the ACSA Convention in Denver? Stop by our booth to say hello and find out how Sovos ShipCompliant helps distilleries of all sizes get a handle on their three-tier distribution management and direct-to-consumer shipping compliance.

Find Sovos ShipCompliant at the 2024 Oregon Wine Symposium, February 13-14. We would love to see you there over Valentine’s Day!

Sovos ShipCompliant will once again exhibit at and sponsor the Direct To Consumer Wine Symposium. Please visit our booth to learn more about our cloud-based, real-time compliance solutions for wineries of all sizes. And keep an eye out for our conference session previewing the findings of the 2024 Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report.