North America
Book a Call

The direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping model continues to represent a major opportunity for the beverage alcohol industry, as the DtC wine channel generated $3.9 billion in 2024, and 83% of craft beer drinkers are looking to order their favorite brews to the front door. It’s no surprise that producers, retailers, and other potential shippers are itching to meet the growing demand. However, DtC rules vary from one state to the next, and not every state has the same alcohol delivery restrictions when it comes to products being shipped. What are the current limitations facing the DtC alcohol shipping industry?

Overview of Federal Rules

At the federal level, the 21st Amendment grants states authority to regulate alcohol within their borders. While the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB) sets overarching standards, such as requiring adult signature and proper labeling, state laws ultimately dictate whether DtC shipping is allowed. Keeping track of the various state-specific alcohol delivery restrictions is what makes compliance so complex for businesses.

States That Do Not Allow Direct-to-Consumer Shipping

Wine

Most states allow DtC wine shipping, but Utah prohibits all DtC wine shipments. Rhode Island only allows on-site purchases for shipping, and Delaware enacted a law that will take effect in 2026 that contains numerous provisions that make it inadvisable to pursue, such as very high licensing cost, low allowable total shipping volume, and a prohibition on the winery or their affiliated wineries from engaging in concurrent DtC shipping and sales to wholesalers. These are prime examples of how alcohol delivery restrictions can vary dramatically by state.

Beer

DtC beer shipping is far more limited than DtC wine shipping. For breweries, understanding these alcohol delivery restrictions is critical to avoid penalties and maintain compliance. The following states prohibit beer from being DtC shipped to their residents:

 

Spirits

Spirits shipping is the most restricted category. This class of alcohol faces the toughest delivery restrictions, making it essential for distillers to stay on top of each state’s DtC spirits shipping laws. The following states do not currently allow for direct-to-consumer shipping of spirits from out-of-state sellers.

 

Cider

Some states consider cider to be a type of wine, while others define it as beer or its own type of alcohol entirely. These nuances highlight how alcohol delivery restrictions can impact even more niche products like cider. Because of these technicalities, it’s extremely important to know the specific rules of each state. Some states prohibit the shipping of cider altogether; these states are:

Compliance Challenges

How to Stay Compliant Across Multiple States

Direct-to-consumer alcohol shipping requires navigating a patchwork of state laws and alcohol delivery restrictions. Compliance isn’t optional, and failure can result in fines or loss of licensure. To stay on track, businesses should focus on a few essentials:

Alternatives for Restricted States

If DtC shipping is not allowed, you should not send shipments to consumers in that state. Though there are third-party providers who claim to be able to ship on your behalf, keep in mind that many make promises that are too good to be true (such as being able to ship to consumers in Utah). We strongly advise that anyone looking at these third-party marketplaces or other sellers carefully review their terms and conditions and consult with a personal attorney or other counsel before signing on. At the end of the day, it’s your name on the label and if it is being sold improperly, state regulators will direct their pointed questions to you.

Conclusion

DtC alcohol shipping offers incredible growth opportunities, but success depends on understanding and adhering to state-specific alcohol delivery restrictions. Staying informed and leveraging compliance platforms like Sovos ShipCompliant can help businesses avoid costly mistakes.

FAQ:

Can I ship wine to consumers in all states?

No. Utah prohibits DtC shipments of any kind, including of wine.

Can liquor be shipped in CA?

Starting January 1, 2026, liquor can be shipped to California.

Which states prohibit direct-to-consumer alcohol shipping?

Utah prohibits all DtC alcohol shipments, and Rhode Island allows only on-site purchases. Most states prohibit DtC shipping of spirits and beer.

How can producers ensure compliance?

Get licensed, research the relevant laws of the states they ship into, work with compliance platforms like Sovos ShipCompliant, maintain shipping records, and follow state-specific laws like volume limits and tax requirements.

What penalties exist for illegal shipping?

Penalties for noncompliance include fines and loss of licensure.

Managing sales tax obligations can be complex in the direct-to-consumer (DtC) alcohol beverage shipping space. Luckily, Sovos ShipCompliant’s Alex Koral, regulatory general counsel, broke down key considerations in the recent Understanding Sales Tax for the DtC Shipper webinar. Here are highlights from the presentation to help you better understand the many nuances of this tricky topic.

What is sales tax?

Sales tax is based on the value of taxable goods that are sold in an individual transaction. States require retailers to remit a percentage of the money they make from a sale of goods, but they also have the retailer collect that tax money from customers on top of the listed price of the transaction at the time of purchase, so the money ultimately comes from customer’s pockets, not the retailer. Any money that a retailer collects for sales tax must be remitted to the state on an appropriate form. Sales taxes are levied primarily on transactions of goods, but services can also be taxed in some circumstances.
In total, 45 states impose a sales tax. The five sales non-tax states are New Hampshire, Oregon, Montana, Alaska and Delaware, referred to as NOMAD states (Alaska does institute some city-level sales taxes). Beyond the state level, many local counties, cities and districts have their own tax rates and rules. There are over 12,000 local tax jurisdictions that sellers must manage.

Nexus for DtC alcohol shippers

In theory, nexus is a straightforward concept but in practice, it can make your head spin. Essentially, nexus comes down when a business has a sufficient connection to a tax jurisdiction that it appears fair for the jurisdiction to impose a tax liability on the business. In addition, the jurisdiction cannot make complying with that tax liability overly burdensome for the business. For many years, that was interpreted to mean a business had to have a physical connection—to own property or have employees in the jurisdiction. But in the 2018 case South Dakota v. Wayfair, the Supreme Court ruled that, in the age of the Internet, states could legitimately claim to have a nexus with remote sellers who earn a reasonable amount of revenue in the state, i.e., “economic nexus.” In short order, all 46 states that levy some sales tax have established economic nexus based on annual sales thresholds.
In some states, economic nexus may lead to additional obligations, as the economic nexus may establish an additional, generic tax burden not set out under the DtC shipping laws. For example, in Illinois and Louisiana, DtC shippers are only required as a condition of their license to collect the state tax; however, if the DtC shipper also has economic nexus in either state, they would then also be required to collect all applicable local taxes.
It’s extremely important to understand the rules where you have nexus, as that will establish where you are required to remit sales taxes and which tax rules will apply. Once you’ve determined the rules, you’ll be better informed of how and when to collect and remit tax on your DtC shipments. It’s also critical to not register in a state where you do not have nexus, as registering automatically obligates a business to meet all tax obligations even if they otherwise didn’t have to.

Situs for DtC alcohol shippers

DtC alcohol shippers must also understand the “situs” for their sales, which basically means what rates, rules and procedures apply to a sale. By and large, situs is determined by where the consumer takes possession of the product, which for interstate sales means the destination location. In intrastate sales, some states will say that the ship-from location is the situs location, but most are moving towards destination-based situs. So, for DtC shippers with nexus obligations in many states, this means understanding and applying the situs rules for all those many states. It is also important to realize that only one jurisdiction can tax a transaction at a time, so while you may need to report all revenue to your home state, you should make sure to deduct exports from tax sales on your home state return and not pay taxes twice.

Sales tax for DtC alcohol shippers

Almost all states require DtC shippers to pay sales and use tax. To get a DtC license, shippers must assume tax liability. This “direct-to-consumer shipper nexus” was imposed to create parity for local businesses. Seven states do not have this inherit tax obligation on direct-to-consumer shippers. If you’re selling in Alaska, Colorado, Florida, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Wyoming and/or D.C., you must track your revenue to know where you might have an economic nexus.

How to manage your tax requirements

Compounding the complexity of the sales tax landscape for DtC shippers, almost everything is subject to change. States are not always diligent in informing taxpayers of changes in rates, forms and rules that might affect them. All these factors can make it seem overwhelming to manage sales tax.
This is where the right technology can help. Implementing real-time sales tax determination software that specializes in alcohol shipping can help ease the burden of keeping up with the latest sales tax rules and regulations. With real-time sales tax determination, you can rest easy knowing that you are collecting, and then remitting, the correct tax, down to the rooftop level. Having all the special rules, markups and regulations applied at the time of sale can help you ensure compliance and a smooth and seamless purchasing experience for your DtC customers. All compliance software isn’t created equal and choosing a partner that understands the intricacies and unique complications related to DtC shipping will set you up for success.

Take Action

If sales tax compliance is creating an undue burden on your business, discover how easy compliance can be with the right partner.

Beverage alcohol suppliers and producers selling in the United States typically must obtain Certificate of Label Approvals (COLAs) from the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB) before product distribution. This ensures that suppliers and producers are compliant with federal regulations regarding the design of their alcohol labels. (Additionally, most states have their own registration requirements that must be met before products can be sold.)

But what do suppliers and producers need to know about COLAs? How can you ensure that your product can compliantly make it to market?

Here are key highlights about COLAs and what it takes to get them approved.

certificate of label approvalKnow what’s required

• An item’s brand name, area of production, type of product and volume of the container’s content must be included.
• The Government Warning must be included and in a specific format.
• The regulations can vary for beer, wine and distilled spirits.

 

clipboard with check mark

Know what’s prohibited

• Health claims or disparaging remarks about competitors’ products are not allowed.
• Neither are references to other intoxicating substances nor claims about the “strength” of the product’s alcohol content.

 

Register with the TTB

• The TTB reviews labels to ensure they incorporate all necessary information and exclude prohibited messaging.
• If labels are not approved, they are sent back to be fixed.

 

Check for new and revised labels

• If a supplier updates a label, that may require applying for a new COLA. The TTB has allowable revisions that can be done without getting a new COLA, saving time and effort.
• Old labels may need to be surrendered and not used again in commerce.

 

Understand exceptions and exemptions

• There are some exclusions to the COLA process, such as wines with an ABV less than 7% and malt beverages that do not meet the FAA Act definition of beer (containing water, malted grains and hops).
• Certain products are subject to the FAA Act but are exempt in certain circumstances from needing a COLA, such as beer that is only sold in the state where it is produced.

Take Action

Ready to start the process for certificate of label approvals (COLAs)? Find out how Sovos ShipCompliant can help you streamline your workflow.

On June 16, Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy signed SB 9, an omnibus beverage alcohol bill that includes new provisions to regulate direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of alcohol in the state. As set out in SB 9, the new DtC shipping laws are set to take effect on January 1, 2024.

While Alaska currently does allow for DtC shipping of alcohol, SB 9 provides welcome clarity and stability to the DtC market in the state. Currently, DtC shipping in Alaska operates under a single-page letter from the Alcohol and Marijuana Control Office (AMCO) indicating that the state does not regulate the personal importation of alcohol by its residents. This effectively has kept the state open to DtC shipping of alcohol by all legitimate sellers, as long as shipments are not made into communities that prohibit the sale of alcohol.

Such loose regulations may seem appealing, but relying on an informal ruling by state regulators left the market vulnerable if future regulators were to decide that they could find justification in Alaska statutes to restrict DtC shipping. Anchoring DtC shipping permissions clearly in the state code allows the industry to grow there without fear of abrupt change in the state’s disposition.

However, SB 9 does contract the current DtC shipping market in Alaska by setting out specific parameters for who can ship to the state and how. Specifically, once the DtC shipping provisions in SB 9 take effect, DtC shippers operating in Alaska will have to comply with the following rules:

Notably, Alaska does not maintain a state-level sales tax. However, the state does permit individual communities to assess their own sales tax and has adopted economic nexus rules, extending liability for those local sales taxes to remote sellers. As such, any DtC alcohol shipper that does meet the state’s threshold for economic nexus ($100,000 in annual gross sales in the state or 200 individual transactions per year), will be required to register with the state’s Remote Seller’s Sales Tax Commission and remit those local taxes.

What this means for Alaska DtC alcohol shipping

Perhaps the biggest change to current DtC shipping in Alaska is that out-of-state retailers will no longer be permitted to ship into the state. Under SB 9, only beverage alcohol manufacturers, or retailers licensed by the Alaska Alcohol and Marijuana Control Office, will be eligible for the Direct Shipment License. While Alaska may not have been the biggest state for DtC shipping by out-of-state retailers, this is a blow to the retailer industry, which has been trying to expand their reach in the DtC market.

It is also interesting to see Alaska adopt production caps for breweries and distilleries that want to ship DtC into the state. That shipping of beer and spirits was retained in SB 9 should be seen as something of a win for those industries, which have not been having much success passing DtC shipping permissions in other states so far this year, but it is disappointing to see states continue to restrict their residents’ access to the full national beverage alcohol market. Historically, the DtC shipping channel is not made up of major, widely available brands, but is instead a place for rare, highly-allocated, or more boutique brands, which can still be made by larger producers.

In all, SB 9 will establish several new compliance requirements for DtC shippers, while also imposing new restrictions on from whom Alaska residents can receive DtC shipments. In exchange, though, the DtC market will benefit from the stability of having clear rules fixed in the state’s statutes.

Take Action

Learn more about managing your DtC shipping compliance.

It’s no secret that direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of alcohol is a valuable and growing market. Wineries, breweries, distilleries, and retailers alike have benefited from having direct access to consumers across the country. With consumer demand at an all-time high, it is understandable more alcohol sellers want to get into the DtC game as soon as possible.

But DtC shipping can be complicated. Understanding, following and keeping up with the myriad rules is difficult, so it’s no wonder that some businesses will look for ways to reduce those barriers, including seeking out third-party services that promise to them go away entirely. While there certainly are services that can ease the pains of managing a DtC shipping program, it’s always necessary to look before leaping at something that sounds too good to be true.

We’ve compiled some of the key practices that are offered to DtC alcohol shippers to minimize their compliance burdens but that might be leaving them at risk of possible enforcement actions from state regulators.

Don’t go in for contract gimmicks

Some DtC programs out there have adopted a neat solution to managing regulatory compliance: foist it on their customers. In this type of arrangement, the seller will set out in their terms and conditions that all sales are deemed to occur at their business location, and that the customer is responsible for any subsequent shipping back to their home or office.

On the one hand, this might seem perfectly legitimate. The vendor is licensed to sell alcohol, and anyone of age could go to their shop, buy some beer, wine, or spirits and take it home to consume, even in a different state. However, this becomes questionable—and possibly illegal—when it involves using a third-party carrier to bring the alcohol purchased to the consumer’s home.

Under the 21st Amendment, states have clear authority to control the transportation of alcohol into and within their borders, and they have all adopted laws that either prohibit the shipping of alcohol directly to consumers or limit it to specific situations, such as only from licensed wine producers. There is no state where consumers can ship alcohol to themselves through a third-party carrier. While many states do provide for consumers to personally import alcohol that they have bought out-of-state, they require that the consumer personally import it, for example in their checked luggage or car.

Even if an alcohol vendor could contractually declaim liability for following state laws (and that is not an argument that’s likely to win in court), they will still, be enabling their customers to break the law. Suppliers looking to remove their compliance burdens should therefore avoid working with any service that offers this type of arrangement and should never adopt these terms and conditions themselves either.

When looking at possible third-party partners, keep an eye out for clauses that state:

Can I sell under someone else’s license?

Many prospective shippers balk at the idea of applying for and managing the dozens of licenses required to establish a national DtC shipping program. Third-party services that offer the use of their licenses, therefore, may seem like a godsend. How these services work, and how legitimate they actually are, though, can be unclear.

The concern here is that legal DtC shipments generally require a license, and state regulators expect the name on the storefront to match the name on that license. If a supplier is marketing and selling from their tasting room or website, but conducting their shipping under someone else’s license, regulators may have some serious questions about what’s going on that can quickly lead to robust enforcement action.

The best way for a third-party to legally DtC ship a supplier’s products for them, is for that third-party service to either be assigned as an authorized brand dealer or be a retailer licensed to make DtC shipments. Either way the supplier will need to sign away their ownership of the product and any involvement in the sale, and the latter will also require they properly distribute their products to the retailer, likely through a wholesaler. This could be the best way for some suppliers to go, but it would mean not being able to sell or ship directly to consumers themselves.

Ultimately, suppliers looking at one of these services should make sure to thoroughly understand how they work, and what kind of risk they may be assuming.

What about ‘three-tier DtC’?

A novel service that has been gaining attention recently aims at a “best of both worlds” approach by combining the perceived legitimacy of the three-tier system with the prospect of shipping to consumers wherever they are (even claiming access to consumers in all 50 states). In this Frankenstein’s monster of a service, a supplier will market and sell their products directly to consumers, but the actual order fulfillment will then run through a partner retailer who in turn received possession of the alcohol being sold from a wholesaler.

Central to “three-tier DtC” is that a supplier will work with a specific retailer that can fulfill deliveries across the country. However, this brings up two huge, unresolved questions. First, it would appear to violate tied-house rules for a supplier to direct sales to a specific retailer. Second, it is unclear how retailers can ship alcohol to consumers everywhere (currently, only 14 states and D.C. permit retailers to ship alcohol across borders). Even relying on retailers making local deliveries themselves would leave out some consumers, as no retailer operates in every state and many delivery permissions restrict the retailer to operate only in the city or county where they are licensed.

While the idea of making DtC sales under the auspices of the three-tier system has gained a lot of attention, suppliers may want to remain skeptical for now.

Take Action

Want to avoid the headaches surrounding third-party DtC gimmicks? Learn how to get licensed.

By Chloe Cristallini, Marketing Manager for Bloom Studio

Recently, one of our webinar attendees asked, “What advice would you give someone who is first starting to sell alcohol DtC, or who wants to grow their DtC channel?”

Buying a bottle of wine should be as easy for people as buying a pair of shoes. Other industries have nailed e-commerce, and as a company, we like to think about how our industry can, too. In the end, it’s not just about selling alcohol online. It’s wrapping all the components together and making it almost product-agnostic in terms of what someone is buying and how they’re buying it. There is a product a consumer wants to purchase; that should happen with as few roadblocks as possible.

Making things this simple for the consumer comes with complexities for the seller. It’s not as easy as setting up a website and selling some products. There is no magic bullet or single solution. It’s about really knowing your consumer and forming a ten-year relationship with them, and thinking about how you will nurture that relationship continuously.

Based on our experience of running a digital agency for nearly 25 years and understanding the complexities of growing a business, several things must be happening simultaneously and cohesively. While it may look slightly different for each brand, here are the key elements to ensure success in your online endeavors:

Know your business objectives. Think about the big picture and where you see the company in 5-10 years. Having a clear sense of purpose and direction maintains laser focus in an environment full of distractions. It will also help your employees understand what the company is trying to achieve and what is required of them to support the mission. Goals should follow the SMART formula being specific, measurable, achievable, realistic and time-related.

Understand your Unique Value Proposition (UVP). A concise, straight-to-the-point statement about the benefits you offer customers and what makes you different. It describes your value, to whom you provide value and what sets you apart from your competition. Take Empathy Wines, for example; they are committed to making “ultra-premium wine more accessible” and it’s evident in everything they do.

Get to know your customer. If you want to craft a memorable experience and stand out from your competition, you need to dig deep into who your wine buyer is and what they want. Make an effort to visualize what is in your customers’ heads. Consider using empathy maps, personas, and other tools so you can better understand their pain points, motivations, goals and challenges. Once you know their pains and where you can make gains, then marketing strategies come more easily.

Craft a couple of Ideal Customer Profiles (ICP). Your ICP is the ideal buyer profile that your business serves. Start by making a list of your best customers based on factors like lifetime value and customer advocacy. Merge them into a fictitious character who has all the qualities that make them the best fit for the products you sell. You’ll want to collect information on their demographics, psychographics, interests and objections/role in the purchase process.

Analyze your competition and assess how you compare. Not all businesses will be known for or are good at everything – and that’s ok. What’s not ok is not knowing where those strengths (and weaknesses) lie. SWOT analysis assists you in understanding external and internal factors that can make or break your success towards your business goals. This exercise helps you see what resources you have to execute on an opportunity or forecast what might prevent you from seizing that opportunity.

Start determining your marketing strategy. Your marketing strategy is your game plan; it conceptualizes how your business and marketing goals could be achieved. It is the approach you will take to engage your ICP whilst considering the threats and opportunities posed by the industry. Marketing strategy doesn’t need to be all things at once; moreover, focus on where you can fill the gap and gain a competitive advantage. For example, if your goal at the winery is to sell more of your pinot, the strategy might be to “devise new reasons people should consume pinot”. Think about your UVP and how you can fulfill the needs of an industry problem – use this to drive your marketing strategy.

Use tactics to execute your strategy. While marketing strategy involves thinking, the tactics form the actions you’ll take to get there. With your marketing strategies in place, use tactics like lead generation, building a website or landing pages, social advertising and other activities to support your strategic marketing plan. Tactics will have various tasks, timelines and people assigned to them with milestones along the way to represent the progress towards your objectives. Use both strategy and tactics interdependently to ensure the success and growth of your brand.

Employ flywheels over funnels. For years, the funnel has been used by marketers, salespeople and business leaders alike. It allows businesses to understand the buying process that customers go through when purchasing products. Whilst insightful, they hold a significant flaw; funnels don’t consider how customers can help you grow. Flywheels focus on the energy generated from inputs. The actions taken by each team in your company impact one another. Marketing efforts affect how quickly potential buyers move through the sales process. Your sales motion affects how likely potential buyers will become happy customers. Support and service activities impact your customers becoming brand ambassadors and if they’ll recommend your products to their family and friends (or not). The flywheel model is a comprehensive way of understanding the forces contributing to your growth.

If you are looking at selling wine online, it’s not just about setting up a shop and selling some products. Even if your wine is impressive, if you don’t have clear goals, know your customer, understand your competition or have a solid strategy, you won’t generate the energy needed to grow in today’s “never normal” world.

Built on top of Shopify’s best-in-class e-commerce platform, Bloom provides everything a growing winery needs to sell online and manage their club memberships. Bloom is a platinum certified Sovos ShipCompliant partner—one of the 60+ integrated partners that makes Sovos ShipCompliant a central hub of the direct-to-consumer and three-tier beverage alcohol ecosystem.

Vino drinkers in 48 locales can get their favorite wines shipped direct-to-consumer (DtC) to their home, while beer and liquor aficionados only can have their top libations delivered in 12 and seven locations, respectively. These shipments must also be through a private carrier, as the United States Postal Service (USPS) is forbidden from delivering alcohol anywhere in the country. Current USPS laws are getting in the way of customers’ desires and producers’ bottom lines. But why can’t the USPS deliver alcohol?

Once upon a time

Prohibition ended nearly 100 years ago but some of the laws surrounding alcohol distribution remain in place. One of these laws, the ban on shipping liquor via the U.S. Post office, has persisted. Following Prohibition’s unraveling, John D. Rockefeller commissioned “Toward Liquor Control,” a report offering guidance to policymakers rebuilding alcohol regulation. These regulations were a direct response to the high amounts of overconsumption that was seen in saloons. Of course, a lot has changed in 100 years. Saloons are a thing of the past, and wine clubs and taproom alcohol sales are a common occurrence. But still, institutions operating in the 21st century are beholden to laws from a different time.

Common carriers have already proven with DtC wine shipping that alcohol can be safely delivered to individuals’ addresses. The sizable market for DtC wine shipping has also shown that the number of minors purchasing alcohol will not suddenly skyrocket. Third-party carriers are required to check IDs upon delivery and some states do in fact mandate age verification at the point of sale. Additionally, a recent Treasury Department report advocating states to further alcoholic beverage shipping noted the lack of evidence of problematic shipping related to minors.

Consumers want it

DtC wine shipping is a $4.2 billion industry. Both beer and spirits DtC shipping have a chance for similar success. For example, a survey conducted for the 2022 Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report found that 92% of regular craft beer drinkers would purchase beer DtC at least once a month if their state laws permitted it. If the USPS could get a piece of the DtC pie, consumers, producers and the government agency would all stand to gain.

Currently, 14 states and the District of Columbia permit out-of-state retailers to ship directly to their residents, and fulfill those orders through a common carrier. Many rural consumers rely heavily on the USPS because private carriers can’t or won’t access them. Because it’s a government-funded agency, the USPS provides service to every home in the nation. Some residents of states where DtC shipping is legal can’t take advantage of it because of their more isolated locations, an inequity for these buyers and the alcohol producers who create their favorite beverages.

What can be done about it?

There have been many attempts to change the Prohibition-era ban on shipping alcohol through the USPS. For example, there is the recent bipartisan bill, the USPS Shipping Equity Act. While not allowing for opening up DtC shipping in new states, the Act would give shippers more options and competition, which would in turn help rural areas that private carriers don’t serve.

The USPS Shipping Equity Act would also allow USPS to ship alcoholic beverages directly from licensed producers and retailers to consumers over the age of 21, in accordance with state and local shipping regulations. The bill gives USPS two years to develop regulations and implement the law, ensuring USPS is ready to safely deliver alcoholic beverages to adult consumers with appropriate identification checks in place.

Distilled Spirits Council of the U.S. (DISCUS) president and CEO Chris Swonger estimates that the bill passing could generate $180 million per year for the USPS. This new source of revenue could be extremely beneficial to the USPS, as it has faced more than a decade of financial challenges.

How can you make a difference? Contact your senators and let them know that you support the USPS Shipping Equity Act, and ask them to do the same. Government officials are voted into office to speak for their constituents, and it’s your right as a resident to bring up this (and any other) issue.

Photo credit: Ⓒ Brewers Association

Take Action

Learn more about DtC shipping and what it means to be compliant.

Despite the broad interest among Americans for direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of beer and spirits, there is clear reluctance among state legislators to change laws to enable these sales.

In California, the would-be DtC shipping expansion bill SB 620 was recently amended by the State Assembly in a way that will severely impair the ability of California residents to avail themselves of DtC shipments. While SB 620 had been widely hailed for what it could bring to California consumers, it appears that the Assembly instead chose to credit the fears and claims made by the most vocal of DtC shipping opponents.

Whereas SB 620 as initially introduced would have enabled California residents to receive DtC shipments of beer and spirits largely under the same conditions as they can currently receive shipments of wine, the bill as amended will only enable a much-reduced DtC market. The key changes found in the amended version of SB 620 include:

These changes show the Assembly was ready to defer to the wishes of special interests in the state. Wholesalers and other opponents of DtC shipping alleged that DtC shipping would bring rampant sales to minors and eliminate thousands of jobs related to retailing and transporting alcohol in the state. And while it is unclear how these changes will resolve those concerns (at least, if those concerns had had any real merit to begin with), it is clear that the Assembly is acting more on behalf of special interests than in the interest of their constituents.

By including these new provisions, the current version of SB 620 may be more trouble than it is worth. While any amount of legalized DtC shipping is beneficial to suppliers and consumers, if SB 620 does become law, it will establish a severely curtailed market that will not meet consumers’ expectations (even large distillers produce brands that do not get widely distributed, the main driver of DtC shipping), and will require future legislation to fix. Indeed, the restriction on not allowing DtC shipments to exceed a supplier’s wholesale distributions may lead some distillers to completely exit the California wholesale market, if they find managing the numbers game to be overly burdensome.

Across the country, Maine Governor Janet Mills signed LD 1358 on May 3, 2022, in another case of a clear, effective DtC shipping law for spirits being neutered. As originally written, LD 1358 would have established DtC shipping of spirits along similar lines as are currently available for shipping of wine in Maine. However, in its final form, the bill is merely a recommendation that the state further look into the prospect of DtC shipping of spirits.

While it is positive that the state is looking into the DtC spirits shipping market, and that it has committed the Bureau of Alcoholic Beverages and Lottery Operations to issuing a report on the subject by February 15, 2023, it still leaves Maine residents in the cold when it comes to accessing the full national market for spirits. If the state does come around to passing a full DtC spirits shipping bill in 2023, this may just be a mildly annoying delay, but there is the very real prospect that interests in the state will use this time to further influence the state legislature against DtC shipping of spirits.

Consumers continue to express their interest in being able to receive DtC shipments of beer and spirits, and the ongoing success of the wine DtC shipping market shows how those other products could manage. As such, it is a shame that states refuse to extend such permission to all suppliers. However, the best response for the industry is to double down on their lobbying efforts, engaging in grassroots campaigns by consumers to advocate for the change we all want to see.

Take Action

Learn more about managing your DtC spirits shipping compliance.

When it comes to the three-tier system of beverage alcohol sales, there is perhaps no more important relationship than that between a beverage supplier and their distributors (also known as wholesalers). The support provided by distributors is invaluable in accessing a state’s market, from handling complex logistical arrangements to guiding a supplier on state laws to serving as a brand ambassador for the supplier’s products in the state.

Even more so, suppliers are often legally required to work with distributors to sell their products wholesale in a state.

This confluence of affects—the necessary services offered by distributors and the influence of state law—can make establishing a wholesaler relationship fraught for a supplier. If the supplier is not careful, they can end up stuck in an unhealthy pattern with their wholesaler, with their products sitting unsold and their brand weakened in the state.

The best advice for any supplier, whether a domestic producer or an importer, that is looking to distribute their products into a new state is to talk to their attorney. Direct, specific legal advice is critical for the supplier to understand what their obligations are and will be, what legal restrictions on their distributor relationship may be there, and how they can set up their wholesaler agreements to avoid future problems.

But there are some key things that a supplier should always keep in mind when building out their three-tier distribution partnerships, which will be discussed in the rest of this post.

What to look for in a distributor

There is no single answer for what makes an ideal distributor. There are so many considerations for a supplier to manage, from the specific products they sell, the consumers they want to reach and sales patterns in each state, that each supplier needs to determine for themselves which is the best wholesaler to work with.

Consolidation within the distributor tier has made this more challenging, especially for smaller suppliers, who may need a more specialized service to sell their products. But there are still options out there for suppliers, especially with the recent rise of new distribution services designed to enable better business-to-business interactions.

Most of all, a supplier needs to make sure that whichever distributor they work with, their distributor will be effective. The wholesaler will be the primary means for selling and handling the supplier’s products in the state, making it absolutely essential that the distributor will actively and knowledgeably market and sell the supplier’s products. The wholesaler will need to understand the product well and take care that it is presented to the best retailers in the best locations. And of course, the wholesaler will need to properly keepsafe the products that are in their hands and follow up with all of their reporting and tax obligations.

The importance of a strong contract

Suppliers need to make sure that they have a coherently written and thoroughly considered contract to best ensure that a distributor will be an active and effective partner. In the contract they can set out the terms of their agreement, establish clear expectations and outline conditions for if those expectations are not met.

Ideally, the supplier will never experience any trouble with their wholesaler and not need to invoke any of their contractual powers. But setting out those terms and conditions, the expectations and consequences, well ahead of any problems that may arise, will make dealing with those problems that much easier.

As such, working with an attorney who can help draft a specific distributor contract at the beginning of the relationship is absolutely necessary for all suppliers. Establishing a relationship with a handshake agreement, or simply signing whatever boilerplate contract a distributor sends over may seem friendly and simple, but doing so will more likely lead to future strife than having the seemingly difficult conversation up front. There are always unique situations and expectations that each side will bring when negotiating a wholesaler relationship, and making sure that your take on those things is heard and is put down in writing is absolutely essential.

The legal limitations of a distributor relationship

Entering a distributor relationship carefully and with full consideration is especially important in light of the many laws and regulations that restrict when and how suppliers can establish and change their distributor relationships. During the decades following Prohibition, particularly in the 1970s, many states adopted franchise laws and other rules surrounding interactions between suppliers and distributors, which place limits on how wholesaler relationships function in the state.

It is necessary again here to point out that, if you are in a conflict with one of your distributors or are otherwise dealing with a state’s franchise laws, talk to your attorney. Not only are these rules unique in each state, but they are complex and may require a number of very specific steps on your part. They should not be taken lightly or seen as a petty annoyance, and talking with an expert is critical for avoiding greater problems.

Franchise laws, as they work in beverage alcohol regulations, were originally intended to reduce undue influence in the industry by leveling out the power dynamics between large suppliers and small distributors. The fear was that some particular conglomerates, responsible for the vast majority of beer sales in the U.S., could lean on their wholesalers and force them to adjust contracts to cut prices, exclude competitors’ products, or otherwise privilege their products in the market. In response, franchise laws were enacted that, variably, may (among other things):

Franchise laws are much more common in beer sales, but they are also out there for wine and spirits distributions. Often they are tied to other restrictions on establishing a distributor relationship, such as limiting the number of distributors who can carry a single brand or limiting the number of distributors a supplier can designate to operate in certain territories in the state.

This all underscores the need for suppliers and their wholesalers to be operating under good, clear contracts. While franchise rules may affect how a contract’s terms can be enforced, suppliers should do what they can in their contracts to set out specific terms and expectations that can be brought up in the future. For instance, a franchise law may require a supplier to prove “bad faith action” on the part of their distributor; but having established in their contract certain conditions that they agree constitute “bad faith action” can make addressing and fixing that problem much more straightforward.

The power dynamics of the beverage alcohol industry have greatly shifted over the past several decades. There is now a sea of smaller craft producers having to work with a greatly diminished pool of distributors, many of them extremely large and focused more on established brands that sell millions of gallons per year. This inversion perhaps undermines the original intent of franchise laws and should make regulators and legislators reconsider how they police distributor relationships going forward. Nevertheless, franchise laws are on the books in many states and suppliers need to be aware of them and the restrictions that may apply when they want to cancel or renegotiate an established distributor contract.

Work today to prevent future complications

Even if suppliers were not required by law to work with distributors, distributors would continue to play a critical and necessary role in the beverage alcohol industry. By acting as the face of a brand in a state and enabling the safe and efficient movement of products, wholesalers are one of the most important relationships that a supplier can have. Understanding how to establish and maintain an effective and friendly relationship is therefore critical for all suppliers. When a supplier considers the additional limits on their relationships that exist due to a state’s laws and regulations, can make this process seem all the more fraught. But taking a cleareyed and careful approach, and consulting with legal experts, can help ensure that potential pitfalls and heartaches are avoided.

Take Action

Learn more about streamlining your three-tier compliance processes with ShipCompliant Market Ready.

Have you ever wanted to order your favorite out-of-state liquor and get it shipped right to your front steps? The COVID-19 pandemic pushed consumers to rethink how they obtain the necessities and conveniences, but ordering distiller spirits for home delivery is not that easy, with only eight locales nationally permitting the direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of spirits.

Spirits are in high demand

Prohibition era laws are still in place, severely restricting alcohol shipping, particularly for spirits and beer. However, wine has had great success with direct-to-consumer shipping, and the numbers show that spirits lovers want the same access. Distillers also desire parity in the beverage alcohol world. With over 15 years of compliant, tax-paying DtC wine shipping, producers and consumers have demonstrated that brands can be adored (and safely shipped) across state lines. The numbers also show that there is a strong desire from spirits consumers to have their favorite products sent to their front doors.

We are well past the Prohibition era, and there are new and fun ways to experience your favorite cocktail. There are over 2,300 distilleries in the U.S. according to The Distilled Spirits Council of the United States (DISCUS). Whether a new startup or a buzzing pre-Prohibition operation, many are part of distillery trails, tourism initiatives that educate and delight consumers. Cocktail lovers can print a map and collect stickers for a prize while traversing the Colorado Spirits Trail. It’s recommended to visit the 18 distilleries that make up the Kentucky Bourbon Trail over the course of four days, while the adventurous can prolong their stay to ten days and experience 41 tours during what has been dubbed “the ultimate Bourbon lovers’ quest”. No matter your preferred libation, there’s a distillery trail for you to discover.

Once a tour is over, consumers from far away are missing out on the chance to have a souvenir shipped home. And if their new favorite spirits aren’t available locally, they will need to make another trek to the distillery for a refill.

DISCUS found that eight out of 10 consumers think distillers should be allowed to directly ship their products to legal-age consumers in any state. Approximately three-quarters said they would consider purchasing spirits online shipped directly from distillers to them from outside or within their state. In fact, the most recent amendment to California Senate Bill 620 would give direct shipping privileges to California distillers who produce up to 150,000 gallons of spirits per fiscal year.

Make some noise

So there is consumer demand for DtC liquor shipping, but perhaps there’s nothing that can be done. Can consumers really make a difference? Absolutely. The DtC wine shipping market has grown because wineries and consumers were very active in advocating for it, bolstered by grassroots coalition Free the Grapes. Industry groups like state guilds and national organizations can help create collective action and build lobbying platforms. Involving consumers can also help speed up the often lengthy legislative process—because the squeakiest wheel gets the grease. Ship My Spirits is a grassroots coalition working to bring expanded DtC shipping to the distilled spirits industry by making it easy for spirits enthusiasts to write to their legislators straight from their website.

The old adage is true: there is strength in numbers. If you’ve ever tasted the perfect whiskey (or rum, gin, tequila or vodka) and wished you could send a bottle to your front door, now is the time to demand change. We’ll drink to that.

Take Action

Learn more about managing your DtC spirits shipping compliance.

Tax compliance can easily become an overlooked area as alcohol producers work on numerous aspects of their three-tier distribution compliance, including state license forms and brand registration requirements. For alcohol producers distributing in the three-tier system, excise tax determination and reporting is especially critical. Businesses must ensure they stay compliant as they scale into new states, which can get confusing, complex and time-consuming. Yet it’s necessary to accurately track and manage all excise tax requirements, reporting and deadlines.

We’ve broken down some of the key things to keep in mind when it comes to excise tax determination and reporting in the three-tier system.

The three-tier system and excise taxes

Excise taxes are calculated against the volume of alcohol being sold or distributed, and they are levied at both the federal and state level. Federal excise taxes are generally paid by suppliers, be they domestic producers or importers. While it can be tricky for a supplier to determine exactly when it is due, federal taxes are relatively straightforward.

Under the three-tier system, wineries, breweries, cideries and distilleries need to recognize their tax liability in each state they ship into to understand their state-level excise tax burdens.

Generally, excise taxes are paid to the state by the first party to own the product in that state. As such, domestic producers are required to remit tax on what they produce to their home state regulators. But for interstate distributions, that often means the distributor. Still, there are a few exceptions (e.g., Wisconsin, West Virginia and Pennsylvania for beer) where an out-of-state supplier must remit to the state themselves based on what they sell there.

More so, it is critical for suppliers to understand the applicable excise tax so they can properly set their prices with their distributors. The biggest distinction among states on excise taxes is the different rates that apply. While spirits are always taxed more (sometimes by a lot), beer is taxed at the low end, and wine is taxed somewhere in the middle, the specific rates vary widely from state to state. For instance, spirits are taxed at $2.68 per gallon in Indiana, but right across the border in Kentucky, they are taxed at $8.41 per gallon.

This all changes when a product is sold through a control board, as instead the state will apply its own “mark-up.” That is the difference between the price at which a supplier sells their product to the state and the price it is sold at to consumers in retail stores. These markups include a variety of additional costs, from transportation to storage, but always include some kind of excise tax equivalent, which the state then collects directly.

Suppliers should always remember that excise taxes do not need to be paid to their home state on alcohol that was distributed out of state. Exports and interstate sales should be deducted from the total local production. That way, alcohol producers only pay home state excise taxes on products that are actually consumed in their home state.

The three-tier system and reporting

Distributing reports are key when it comes to managing tax compliance. Most states require suppliers to file follow-up reports, listing what was sold into a state, when and to whom. But these reporting requirements vary from one state to the next. For example, Alabama wine three-tier distribution requires monthly reports to be filed, with a list of the items shipped, invoice copies, prices and sizes. With Alaska wine sold in the three-tier system, such reporting is not required.

Essentially, states must be able to verify their tax collections from distributors. These reports can be as simple as one statement on total volume, or they can include a summary of all invoices from a producer in a specific time frame. What matters is understanding the specific requirements of the states you are shipping into and preparing to fulfill whatever reporting is needed.

Remember that as you expand into a new state for three-tier distribution, consulting with your compliance team, attorneys and even a producer located in that state will help you better understand how the state rules apply to your specific circumstance. Working with the right partner can also help the process be as seamless as possible.

Take Action

Learn how ShipCompliant Market Ready can help with your three-tier compliance processes, from license management to tax determination and reporting.

What’s the difference and why does it matter?

Consumers may not care about the legal technicalities of how their favorite alcoholic beverages arrive at their front doors, but federal and state regulators absolutely do. Here’s a quick guide to what producers and retailers must know about direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping versus local delivery of beverage alcohol.

Direct-to-Consumer Shipping

sovos shipcompliantWhat is DtC shipping?

• DtC shipping is when an alcohol seller receives an order from a consumer that is fulfilled through a shipment using a third-party common carrier, sent directly to the consumer.

• These shipments often cross state borders and must abide by the rules of the state where the consumer is located and will receive the shipment.

• There are regulatory restrictions on DtC shippers, from licensing and tax requirements to outright bans on who can ship.

dtc shippingIs it allowed everywhere?

• Not exactly. While 47 states and the District of Columbia allow residents to have wine shipped directly to them, just 11 states and D.C. allow the same for beer while seven states and D.C. allow liquor to be shipped directly to consumers. Only 14 states allow out-of-state retailers to ship DtC.

 

dtc shippingWhat’s the big deal?

• Smaller producers who struggle in the three-tier system can readily establish a national presence, while meeting consumer expectations that everything is available online.

• The wine industry has been shipping for decades, and there is widespread interest in the beer and spirits markets to expand their access.

• What was once a novel market expansion has since proven win-win-win for producers in terms of business growth, states in terms of increased tax revenue,  and consumers in terms of increased choice and convenience.

Alcohol Delivery

alcohol deliveryWhat is alcohol delivery?

• Alcohol delivery is when a local retailer makes a sale, but the consumer has their purchase brought directly to them instead of taking possession at the storefront.

• Often, retailers must deliver alcohol in their own vehicles, using their own employees.

• Many third-party services have recently provided marketplace and delivery support.

• These deliveries do not cross state borders (in some cases, not even county borders), and except for the delivery, otherwise are three-tier sales.

alcohol deliveryIs it allowed everywhere?

• Just like with DtC shipping, the local delivery of alcohol is not available in every state.

• There is also a difference between where a retailer can deliver using their own employees and vehicles versus where they can rely on third-party services to handle the delivery.

• As the use of third-party services has expanded, many states have added new licensing requirements and other controls on them to ensure the safe handling of alcoholic products.

alcohol deliveryWhat’s the big deal?

• Local alcohol delivery promises the advantages of the three-tier system, with a suite of available products, matched with the benefit of having those products brought directly to the consumer.

• This provides convenience for consumers who are busy or are otherwise unable to go to a retail store.

• Consumers are limited to products that have gone through the local three-tier system. Small production or highly allocated products that do not get widely distributed may still be unavailable to consumers.

Take Action

Want to learn more about the DtC shipping process and why compliance is so key? Reach out to our team and see how Sovos ShipCompliant can help.

In 2022, wine producers and wine consumers can enjoy unparalleled access to each other through the market for direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of wine. The current map for DtC wine shipping of 47 states and the District of Columbia, is thanks in no small part to vigorous lobbying and advocacy efforts over the past few decades, especially in the years following the 2005 Granholm ruling.

Yet, despite those efforts from consumer and industry groups like Free the Grapes! and Wine Institute, there is an ongoing need for further action in state legislatures, both to continue to expand DtC wine shipping permissions and to prevent those who oppose DtC shipping from clawing back any existing permissions.

At the recent Sovos ShipCompliant Wine Summit (back in Napa after a two-year hiatus!) thanks to invaluable support from Wine Institute, I gave the State of the Industry presentation, a look into the active and upcoming legislation that could affect the DtC wine shipping industry in 2022. Here are some of the highlights.

But first, what about 2021?

Of course, no preview would be complete without a brief look back at the previous year, and there were some major headlines from 2021.

The biggest change in 2021 was the addition of Alabama to the DtC wine shipping map, which became effective last August. Also in 2021, Ohio expanded DtC shipping permissions for larger format wineries (those producing over 250,000 gallons per year), by creating a new “S-2” license for those wineries in particular.

Several states in 2021 also added new requirements for when DtC wine shippers use a third-party logistics service to facilitate their shipments. Tennessee, Kansas and Alabama each passed licensing and reporting requirements on fulfillment houses, which are all now in effect.

And, while not as critical as opening up a whole new market for DtC shippers, both Oregon and Wyoming expanded their volume limits for how much a licensee can ship to a single resident of those states, to five cases per month and 12 cases per year, respectively.

More information on all of these headlines, and more, can be found on the Sovos ShipCompliant blog.

What’s happening in 2022?

As ever, there are efforts underway to finally fill out the map of states that allow DtC shipping of wine. Unfortunately, a proposed bill to allow DtC shipping in Mississippi has already failed, and Utah is stuck on a complicated new system for allowing special order sales through its state stores. But in Delaware at least, HB 210 aims to open that state as the latest to allow its residents access to DtC shipments.

Bills in Alaska (SB 9) and Minnesota (HB 2576) would also create more clear cut rules for wineries to ship into both states. SB 9 in Alaska is particularly welcome, as even though wineries can fairly freely ship into that state currently, those permissions are only available under a decades-old Attorney General agreement that could be rescinded at any moment. Though going forward wineries would need to get licensed and pay Alaska taxes, that would be worth being able to stand on solid ground in the state. Similarly, the Minnesota bill would require some additional compliance requirements, but would also allow wineries to ship a lot more to their Minnesota consumers than they currently can.

Rhode Island is also looking to establish more amenable DtC shipping laws, as the state currently only permits DtC shipments when the Rhode Island consumer purchases the wine while physically present at the winery. HB 7594 (companion bill SB 69) would put in place the Wine Institute’s model shipping bill, with licensing and tax requirements, along with permission to sell remotely through clubs or the Internet. That bill is in opposition to HB 6300 (companion bill SB 2420), which, while allowing DtC shipping from remote sales, would impose a prohibitively expensive license.

While it was extremely welcome in 2021 when Alabama passed its DtC wine shipping bill, when rolled out, the licensing program turned out to be extremely difficult, leading many wineries to opt out of opening up their DtC markets to that state. HB 240 in Alabama, which would remove many of those licensing barriers, is therefore much needed and a much appreciated sign that the state wants to make itself an attractive destination for DtC wine shippers.

The addition of regulatory requirements on fulfillment houses in 2021 seemed to signal a move that other states would be apt to follow. However, there has not yet been a great tide of such legislation. Still there are efforts in some states, such as Louisiana and Wisconsin, to clarify that licensed DtC shippers can continue to rely on third-party services to facilitate shipments to those states, though it remains to be seen whether any restrictions or registration requirements will be imposed there.

Such efforts to better monitor third-party logistic services is part of a bent among states to regulate the DtC shipping market and levy enforcement actions on suspected bad actors. In 2021, Ohio and Michigan both instituted action under the 21st Amendment Enforcement Act against unlicensed shippers, and all signs are that such efforts will keep up in 2022.

But even licensed shippers in other states should remain vigilant of the need to keep in compliance with state rules when shipping their wine. All states retain the right to audit and police their licensees, and they continue to hear rumors and allegations of impropriety in the DtC wine shipping market. Sovos ShipCompliant maintains that the best defense to state enforcement is getting ahead of compliance needs, getting licenses, blocking even accidental sales to minors, paying taxes and diligently retaining records of such activity so you can quickly head off any claims or questions that a state regulator might have.

What wines may come?

The current $4.2 billion DtC wine shipping market is built on an ecosystem of producers, advocacy groups and third-party support services, all sharing the aim of making this a healthy and safe industry. It has taken decades of tireless work and striving to get where we are today, but we also cannot rest on the laurels of that work. There remains much to be done to further expand DtC shipping permissions and make this a more accessible market for all producers and consumers. As that work does happen, you can rely on Sovos ShipCompliant to keep you informed.

Take Action

Learn more about DtC compliant shipping, including everything from getting licensed to understanding the potential for an audit.

For suppliers of beverage alcohol, one of the most critical steps in getting to market is ensuring that their product labels comply with all applicable federal and state laws. An alcohol label contains critical information identifying the contents and producers, and as such it is highly regulated with rules at both the federal and state levels that must be met.

Federally, label review and approval is managed by the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB), which also establishes regulations for alcohol labels. Suppliers and producers selling in the United States will generally need to obtain a Certificate of Label Approval (COLA) from the TTB prior to distributing their products. This ensures that suppliers and producers are compliant with federal regulations when designing and marketing alcohol labels.

Obtaining a COLA is only the first step in getting individual products to market, as most states then have their own registration requirements that must be met before selling into those states.

There are numerous details here for producers and suppliers, which is why we’ve gathered key considerations for product registrations. Whether you are making your first foray into the three-tier system or are looking to expand into another state, ensuring accurate brand label registration will help you maintain compliance.

The label approval process

The first step of the label approval process is to know the required and prohibited information, which should be taken into account when designing labels, as getting ahead of those rules can prevent delays down the road. Federally, rules for labels are set out in both the Federal Alcohol Administration Act (FAAA) and the Internal Revenue Code (IRC). Often, the FAAA and the IRC overlap in what they require and prohibit, but they have jurisdiction over different types of alcoholic products, so it is important for a supplier to understand what applies specifically to the products they sell. Notably, the COLA process is only covered in the FAAA, so products not covered by the FAAA are exempt from COLA requirements.

In all cases, a label must include the brand name and area of production, and identify the type and volume of the container’s content. In addition, there are several things that cannot be included, such as health claims or disparaging remarks about competitors’ products. In all cases, the label must contain the Government Warning (mandated by both the FAAA and IRC), which also must be in a specific format. The TTB website for Beverage Alcohol Manuals (BAMs) provides invaluable outlines of the labeling requirements for beer, wine and distilled spirits, and all suppliers should read them carefully.

Once you’ve determined that your labels are ready for review, you can begin the COLA process. COLAs ensure that suppliers and producers are compliant with federal regulations for alcohol labels. Under the Federal law, most alcoholic products being distributed across state borders must first be registered with the TTB and receive a COLA before they can be sold. The TTB will review your label to ensure it incorporates all necessary information and excludes all prohibited messaging. If the TTB finds a label to be improper, they will send it back to be fixed. While the TTB has vastly improved the time for reviewing labels, having to work through multiple rounds of COLA review can add weeks to a supplier’s go to market plan, making first-round approval highly desirable. Often, it is a small thing, like improperly formatted Government Warning, that causes the TTB to send back a label.

Exceptions to the product label rules

While most products sold in the three-tier system require COLAs, there are a few notable exceptions.

As noted, some products are not regulated by the FAAA and are therefore entirely excluded from the COLA process. These include:

In addition, there are some products that are subject to the FAAA but are exempt in certain circumstances from needing to get a COLA, including:

What do states look for in product registrations?

Once you have your federally-approved COLA in hand (unless your product meets the above exceptions), it’s time to get state-level specific. Nearly 40 states have their own product registration requirements. Often, these state registrations are something of a formality, more a notice to the state of what products they can expect to see on retailer shelves. But often enough, these state registrations get complicated.

Registrations can cost from free to hundreds of dollars per brand , and time for approval can run from instantaneous to six weeks. Notably, states that have moved towards electronic registrations such as through Product Registration Online have seen vast improvements in their time for approval.

Often states require suppliers to provide information on their distributors during product registration. Again, the goal is for the regulators to understand what is being sold in their state and who is involved. In many states, though, such distribution information is also used to manage the state’s franchise restrictions, such as documenting the approved territories for distributors or establishing a record of existing relationships in case a party wants to adjust their agreements in the future.

For importers and other resellers, product registrations also often require them to provide proof that they are permitted to sell those products. This can include submitting brand authorization or Primary American Source letters from the actual manufacturer. Understanding each state’s requirements and having the necessary documentation on hand can make the overall process much easier and quicker to get through.

What about revisions?

Product labels are not static documents; suppliers decide to change or update them regularly, whether that is a brewer selling a brand in a different size bottle or a winery redesigning a label for a new year. Suppliers should keep in mind that such changes may require additional approval or registration from regulators.

At the federal level, all suppliers should be aware of TTB’s allowable revisions, which have greatly reduced the number of labels that need federal approval. While often enough a new label means a new COLA, some changes, like font and color revisions or rewriting certain non-critical information, can be done without a new COLA. States, though, have their own rules about revisions, so even if a revised label doesn’t require a new COLA, it may still need to be resubmitted to the states where it is being distributed.

Double checking with the TTB and all state agencies before beginning the revising process can help to avoid costly mistakes. The key to compliance is understanding what you’re selling, where you’re selling it and contacting government agencies to fully understand their specifications ahead of time.

Whether you’re a brewery, winery or distillery, getting your product to market quickly is a top priority. As such, taking the time to know and understand the product label requirements is critical to avoiding delays. Varying processes can take longer than anticipated and may be at a different price point. Summer ale labels that are submitted in March may not hit the shelves until the fall if edits are needed. Planning ahead and following TTB guidelines are imperative to easing the process. You don’t want critical, but seemingly distracting, requirements to hold back your time to market.

Take Action

The three-tier system for distribution doesn’t have to be confusing. Learn more about Sovos ShipCompliant’s Market Ready solution and streamline your compliance processes.

Direct-to-consumer (DtC) spirits shipping is increasingly becoming a hot topic in the craft beer and spirits worlds, with both producers and consumers pushing for greater access. However, while 47 states and the District of Columbia allow wine to be shipped DtC, just six states and D.C. do so for spirits.

Several states have bills that could expand DtC shipping for spirits products. New York and California have received a lot of attention for the legislation they have in the works that could potentially vastly expand the market for DtC spirits shipping. We’ve highlighted some of the key points for each bill, as well as what expanded spirits DtC shipping actually means for the beverage alcohol industry.

What’s happening in states with Direct-to-Consumer Spirits Shipping

New York

New York Senate Bill 4245A would allow for intrastate and interstate shipment of liquor. In January 2022, it was referred to the Commerce, Economic Development and Small Business Committee.

Sovos ShipCompliant spoke with Brian Facquet, president of the New York State Distillers Guild, to understand how the legislation would impact the market.

The three-tier system has a clear distinction between suppliers, wholesalers and distributors, and then retail businesses. The system is wonderful, Facquet said, but it was created in the 1930s following Prohibition.

“We’re not saying anything about the world not needing a distributor or a retailer,” he said. “But the manufacturers have less power and less rights.”

Wineries across the country can directly ship their products to New York consumers, and have been able to do so for years. The state allowed for temporary DtC spirits shipping by New York producers during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, and distillers were able to prove that it could be done appropriately and safely, Facquet said. However, that measure expired in June 2021.

California

California also had a temporary measure in place that allowed distillers to ship products directly to consumers. However, that expired on March 31, 2022. California Senate Bill 620 aims to instill permanent DtC shipping for liquor.

“The bill was recently passed out of the Senate with substantial amendments,” according to the California Artisanal Distillers Guild. “We have to see what the amendments change, but it is hoped that small craft distillers can ship to our customers.”

Currently, California only permits out-of-state suppliers to shipping wine and cider DtC.

Dispelling the anti-DtC arguments

As with most legislation, there are parties in favor of the bills and those who stand in opposition. With DtC spirits shipping, opponents often stress their feared impacts on jobs, safe delivery, impacts on minors, and the proper payment of taxes.

On the contrary, Facquet stressed that more jobs will be created, as more shipping equals more jobs for common carriers (e.g., UPS and FedEx). Additionally, retailers have seen job growth from the increase in demand for local products. Data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that since 2005 (when Granholm v. Heald allowed the wine DtC market to flourish) New York wholesalers had a 53% increase in jobs. Retailers added more than 3,600 jobs for an increase of 38%.

Common carriers have also already proven with DtC wine shipping that alcohol can be safely delivered. The sizable market for DtC wine shipping has also shown that the number of minors purchasing alcohol will not suddenly skyrocket. Third-party carriers are required to check IDs upon delivery and some states do in fact mandate age verification at the point of sale. Additionally, a recent Treasury Department report advocating states to further alcoholic beverage shipping noted the lack of evidence of problematic shipping related to minors.

Finally, DtC alcohol shippers have already proven to be compliant taxpayers. Sovos ShipCompliant alone has facilitated states’ securing hundreds of millions in tax revenue; from 2017 to 2020, there was $438 million in DtC tax revenue paid to states via Sovos ShipCompliant. More states opening up for DtC spirits shipping would only help those revenues continue to grow.

Local demand and beyond for Direct-to-Consumer Spirits Shipping

Direct-to-Consumer spirits shipping will also bring other benefits, Facquet noted. For example, New York distilleries are allowed tasting rooms, which are an important part of how smaller spirits producers build local fans. From there, consumers then go into retail locations and ask for those local brands. Essentially, tasting rooms are part of building demand for products to be sold through the three-tier system.

Beyond being a beloved local brand, distillers desire parity in the beverage alcohol world. With over 15 years of compliant, tax-paying DtC wine shipping, producers and consumers have shown that brands can be adored (and safely consumed) across state lines. The numbers also show that there is a strong desire for expanded DtC shipping options.

The Distilled Spirits Council of the United States (DISCUS) found that eight out of 10 consumers think distillers should be allowed to directly ship their products to legal-age consumers in any state. Approximately three-quarters said they would consider purchasing spirits online shipped directly from distillers to them from outside or within their state.

It’s difficult to know for sure how these pieces of legislation (and those yet to come) will play out. Stay tuned to Sovos ShipCompliant for the latest updates, and reach out to your local state representatives to learn more about the importance of consumer voices pushing bills forward.

Take Action

Learn more about DtC compliant shipping, including everything from getting licensed to understanding the potential for an audit.

Brandy registrations see impressive 322% spike from Q4 2021 

As spring and the warmer months inch closer, beverage alcohol brand registration patterns are also continuing to creep higher. The industry is perhaps gaining a better understanding of how to move forward in a marketplace working through a pandemic. There were increases in Product Registration Online (PRO) new product registrations* for both wine and spirits, with spirits seeing growth from last quarter and last year.

We’ve previously seen that the first half of the year is when the number of registrations tends to climb. The first quarter of 2022 is currently on track to outpace yearly registration totals from both 2021 and 2022.

The following is a breakdown of new product registration data via PRO from the first quarter of 2022 (January, February, March) for spirits, wine and beer.

Spirits

Spirits product registrations are up 108% from Q4 2021, and up 21% from Q1 2021. In fact, all spirits categories show increases quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year.

Among spirits product registrations:

Wine

Overall, the number of wine brand registrations in Q1 2022 spiked 44% from Q4 2021, but saw a 17% decrease from Q1 2021. The White, Red and Rosé, and Fruit and Dessert Wine categories all saw increases in quarterly growth.

Among wine product registrations:

Beer/Malt

Stout registrations led the beer/malt category, with both quarter-over-quarter (307%) and year-over-year (46%) growth. Porter new product registrations and Malt Beverage (which does not include beer, flavored malt beverages, malt liquor or near beer) are up quarter-over-quarter 13% and 16%, respectively. Overall, Malt new product registrations are down 16% from Q4 2021 and saw an 18% decrease from Q1 2021.

*Product Registration Online (PRO) data encompasses nationwide label/brand registrations by PRO users. Product Registration Online processes some 100,000 state registrations annually.

Take Action

Learn how PRO enables fast, easy electronic brand filings for wine, spirits and beer brands in participating states.

Sovos ShipCompliant’s Alex Koral, regulatory general counsel, invited Tom Wark, executive director of the National Association of Wine Retailers and author of the Fermentation Newsletter, for a conversation about the three-tier system’s role in the modern-day beverage alcohol regulatory landscape.

Tom shares his take on how Prohibition may have initially shaped the approach to regulating the industry, along with how the landscape of what is being regulated has evolved since that time.

Alex Koral: Following Prohibition’s unraveling, John D. Rockefeller commissioned  “Toward Liquor Control” (TLC), a report offering  guidance to policymakers rebuilding alcohol regulation. What were the pre-Prohibition “evils” the authors wanted to prevent and how likely are those evils to arise in the modern day economy?

Tom Wark: “Toward Liquor Control” was published just as Prohibition was ending and served as an influential treatise on how to regulate alcohol sales in a way that would prevent a return to the conditions that resulted in dangerous overconsumption. It’s notable that the problems “Toward Liquor Control” primarily addressed were having their impact at least from 1900 through the beginning of Prohibition in 1918—over 120 years ago.

Preventing a return to “saloon culture” was the primary concern. Prior to Prohibition, saloons were often the center of urban society. Primarily young, immigrant men holding working class jobs used the saloon as a gathering place, as a restaurant, as a social club, as a source of news and as a place of political organizing. In this respect the saloon played a key role as a social center for a growing and important population. However, saloon owners took advantage of their key role in the community to encourage overconsumption. Often, saloon owners were “tied” to specific brewers or distillers and had agreed only to sell these products in exchange for the producer funding their operations. But great demands were placed on the saloons, and they were forced to sell significant amounts of alcohol and often at very low or promotional prices. The results were degrading outcomes that harmed lives, made neighborhoods dangerous and destroyed families. These “tied houses” that saw significant influence over them by producers were what the post-Prohibition regulatory theorists particularly wanted to avoid going forward.

Though it is never mentioned in “Toward Liquor Control”, the solution for many state lawmakers was to adopt the three-tier system, where a wholesaler was placed between producers and retailers (e.g., restaurants, retail outlets and bars). In this way, lawmakers and regulators kept producers, wholesalers and retailers separate and avoided the corruption resulting from tied houses. And it worked.

AK: Modern advocates of the three-tier system claim that they are merely holding up the principles laid out in TLC. How closely does the current alcohol market,and the three-tier system itself, align with those principles?

TW: Present day advocates of the three-tier system need to recognize that today’s society is so radically different from a pre-Prohibition society and support reforms that recognize the socio-economic conditions of the 21st century, rather than pretending we are still combating potential problems that characterized a society that no longer exists. The three-tier system was designed to address a culture where urban working class immigrants and others had very few options for building community other than home and the local gathering place—the saloon.

But in 1900 there were no automobiles. There was no television. There was no Internet, there was no social media. There was no media streaming. There was little sports entertainment. There were no movie theaters. There wasn’t even any radio. There was no intercontinental air travel. Today’s society and culture is nothing like 120 years ago. Yet, current day advocates of the three-tier system pretend we must maintain a nearly 100-year-old system of alcohol regulation to avoid social ills that existed then and could not occur again today. This tells me that the three-tier system serves a much different purpose today than it did in 1935. Today it serves as a gatekeeping mechanism and a prophylactic surrounding the profits of the now unnecessary state-mandated use of wholesalers to bring products to market.

AK: What changes in the alcohol market have we seen since the 1930s? How do those impact the relevance of the three-tier system today?

TW: The three-tier system method of alcohol regulation boils down to two things:

Everything else is something different from the three-tier system.

The primary and key differences today from the early 1900s are three-fold:

AK: What parts of the three-tier system do you think would still be utilized, even if they weren’t required by law? 

TW: If we are going to continue to pretend that the dreaded saloon of 1900 will make a reappearance in 2022, then keeping producers, wholesalers and retailers separately licensed will surely prevent any tied houses. However, there remains no value today to legally mandating that producers sell through wholesalers. This is not to say that if the wholesaler mandate disappeared so would wholesalers. In fact, most alcohol would still be moved through them. However, we would also see the utility that comes with producers, particularly small- and medium-sized producers, selling directly to restaurants and retailers.

AK: Are there parts of the three-tier system that you find are harmful, that are contrary to the principles set out in TLC?

TW: Consumers are certainly harmed by the continued wholesaler mandates. They have access to far fewer products than they would under a self-distribution option. Moreover, opponents of direct shipping by brewers, wineries, distillers and retailers (primarily wholesalers but also a very large number of retailers) believe they are upholding the three-tier system by opposing this obviously successful distribution channel.

It should also be said that producers and retailers are both harmed by a lack of producer self-distribution privileges. Numerous producers would easily self distribute their products locally if it were legal. They would also be able to distribute to farther flung markets while producing greater revenue than they do by selling through a wholesaler in those markets. Retailers, particularly independent fine wine retailers, benefit from being able to offer products to their customers that are not procured through wholesalers. By being able to purchase products directly from in-state and out-of-state producers and importers, retailers can distinguish themselves by offering a greater diversity of products. This also helps alleviate lower pricing as a means of addressing the competition. The benefits of removing the state mandated use of a wholesaler and allowing direct shipping by producers, retailers and importers are substantial.

AK: The current alcohol market in the U.S. is vastly safer and healthier than it was pre-Prohibition. Why do you think there is not more attention paid to the apparent success we’ve had, and how much should we attribute that success to the three-tier system and alcohol regulations generally, as opposed to more social forces?

TW: The three-tier system played a key role in preventing a return to what was essentially an unregulated system of alcohol sales prior to Prohibition. But that system outlived its usefulness more than two decades ago. Surely the various anti-abuse efforts by folks like Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) had an impact. However, the three-tier system exists today to prop up a collection of, largely, huge wholesalers with tremendous market and political power.

The other day I asked the head of a trade association why they don’t advocate more for self-distribution rights and direct shipping rights. I was told, “My members are afraid if they did undertake that kind of political advocacy there would be repercussions from wholesalers.” This tells me two things. First, an entire group of alcohol market participants are avoiding pursuit of their own interests. Second, the sizable upside of self-distribution and direct shipping is negated by the threat of real repercussions by wholesalers.

AK: Three-tier advocates often claim that the system  is needed to prevent the sale of “dangerous” and counterfeit alcoholic products, to prevent sales to minors, and to ensure tax payments are made to states. Why do you think that the three-tier system is not necessary to prevent those “harms” and how can they be managed outside of the three-tier system?

TW: No one believes the three-tier system does anything to prevent counterfeit products or dangerous products from entering the marketplace. It’s a pretext for maintaining the three-tier system and the profits it funnels to wholesalers. The assumption here is that bars and restaurants would be buying counterfeit and dangerous products to pass off to their customers for profit. But wholesalers are just as likely to do the very same thing.

As for the notion that the three-tier system plays a role in keeping wine out of the hands of minors, there simply is nothing to support this. First, every study and survey conducted on this issue shows that minors primarily get alcohol from inside their home or from older friends and family. Whether a producer sells alcohol to a wholesaler who then sells it to a retailer has nothing to do with this dynamic. More to the point, with online ID verification and shippers obtaining adult signatures at the time of delivery, direct shipment (presumably a distribution channel that falls outside the three-tier lines) can be seen as the least likely way by which minors obtain alcohol.

Take Action

Learn more about managing your DtC alcohol shipping compliance.

The three-tier system, under which beverage alcohol is predominately sold in the United States, establishes a clear distinction between the different “tiers” of the market. As it is designed to work, alcohol suppliers sell solely to wholesalers, who in turn sell solely to retailers, who then are the entities that consumers purchase alcohol from. In practice, this arrangement is specifically required by law.

Despite the benefits of the three-tier system, it’s not necessarily easy to manage. For small suppliers in particular, it can be prohibitive as consolidation in the distributor tier has led to massive companies that are interested only in the most profitable brands. As such, the prospect of self-distribution, where a supplier sells directly to retailers, bypassing the distributor tier, can seem very attractive.

Many states have, in the last few decades, established limited self-distribution permissions. These have been a major boon for craft producers who have come to rely on self-distribution to get their products into local restaurants and package stores. However, when those same producers move to sell nationally, they quickly realize that self-distribution is almost never allowed when selling from one state into another.

We’ve highlighted important things to remember about self-distribution considerations in the three-tier system.

The value of self-distribution in the three-tier system

Self-distribution can be a lifeline for small producers who otherwise may not be able to get the attention of distributors. Especially when selling beyond your local community, it can be difficult to get noticed by distributors who don’t see the worth in carrying new or growing brands. For example, smaller wineries that focus more on limited runs, producing only a few hundred bottles at a time of a given product, could struggle to find a distributor willing to carry those brands.

However, where state law requires producers to sell only through a distributor, then craft producers have very few options to get their craft alcohol in front of customers. Self-distribution allowances can have great value for furthering market access to small businesses.

States that historically have developed more liberal and open permissions for craft producers (such as tasting room sales) tend to have more robust craft industries. This can be due to having that better brand build up, giving smaller producers more options to getting their product in front of consumers. Self-distribution fits well into those supporting permissions.

Self-distribution can in turn further proper three-tier sales, as a producer who personally builds demand for their craft brands can make them appealing for a distributor to pick up and sell. There are plenty of benefits to working with distributors, from having ready access to retailers and logistical support. That way even where producers can self-distribute, they will continue to look to sell through distributors.

As always, be aware of state laws

Producers that may be benefiting from local self-distribution permissions, however, need to be aware that most states do not permit self-distribution from out-of-state suppliers. Understanding those state laws is essential when looking to enter a new state. Just because you were able to do something locally does not guarantee that you will be able to do the same when selling into a new state.

For the few states that do allow out-of-state suppliers to self-distribute, there are often additional licensing requirements that go along with that permission. The supplier will also need to otherwise step into the compliance shoes of a distributor, such as paying state excise taxes.

For example, Montana requires out-of-state wineries to hold a Foreign Winery License to sell to Montana wholesalers. But the state also offers an additional “endorsement” to self distribute, which requires paying a $50 fee and remitting state excise tax. Overall, be aware that there may be an extra level of licensing and follow-up reporting required by a state.

While not common, interstate self-distribution can offer clear benefits to smaller producers looking to gain a national foothold. The Treasury Department’s February 2022 report on competition in the beverage alcohol industry signaled clear federal interest in supporting small businesses, including enabling greater market access. Perhaps more states will enact more self-distribution permissions for craft producers as a means of accomplishing that goal.

Take Action

Ready to up your three-tier distribution game? See how Sovos ShipCompliant’s Market Ready solution can streamline your compliance processes.