Direct-to-consumer (DtC) is a phrase that can encompass many things: tasting room sales, retailers sales, sampling and festival sales. But, DtC shipping is the shipping of alcohol directly to the purchaser through delivery by a third-party carrier (e.g., UPS or FedEx). In DtC shipping the customer gets the product indirectly, but the sale is made directly with the producer.
There are a handful of reasons that breweries and distilleries might consider getting into the DtC shipping space:
After the Supreme Court case Granholm v. Heald in 2005, discriminatory treatment of out-of-state producers in DtC shipping was prohibited. This led to a “compromise” situation where states can allow DtC shipping of wine with license and tax payments required. Currently, 46 states allow DtC wine shipping.
When it comes to beer and spirits shipping DtC, there are product-type concerns—some consider spirits as “dangerous” and when it comes to beer, the majority of the market is large corporations who wouldn’t benefit as much from DtC shipping. And, compared to the wine industry there has been significantly less engagement in lobbying efforts.
Cider products are sometimes grouped into beer or wine regulations, but can vary depending on the ABV or fermented material—creating differences in taxation requirements. DtC shipping for cider is currently a grey area since no state’s DtC laws mention cider explicitly. So for a cider to be shipped DtC, it must be categorized as a “wine” and shipped under compliance with wine shipping laws.
The DtC wine shipping market has grown because wineries and consumers were very active in advocating for it. In order to expand beer and spirits DtC shipping, the laws need to be changed and this can take significant time. Industry groups like state guilds and national organizations can help create collective action and build lobbying platforms. Involving consumers can also help speed up the process—explain the limits of DtC shipping to any consumers who ask about it and share what they can do to help.
Learn how ShipCompliant can help with your DtC shipping compliance.
Sovos is sponsoring the 14th Annual DtC Wine Symposium, this time, virtually!
Don’t miss our keynote session on January 22nd: “Where the DTC Market is Trending”, presented by Larry Cormier, SOVOS ShipCompliant; Andrew Adams, Wine Analytics Report.
This Keynote provides a comprehensive overview of the entire DTC market, where it’s headed and why. Larry Cormier, vice president, and general manager of Sovos Shipcompliant will be joined by Andrew Adams, editor of the Wine Analytics Report, to preview key findings on the publishing day of the 2020 DtC Wine Shipping Report including critical DTC metrics and new findings on the consumers fueling DTC sales growth.
Looking to enter a new market or bring new wines to the marketplace? Growing any business can be complicated, and the beverage alcohol industry is no exception. Not knowing how or where to begin can be the biggest hurdle. From market research and branding to strategic considerations and compliance, this 10-step guide will get you on the right path in expanding your winery’s footprint.
Before trying to expand or launch a new product, it’s important to take a look at your current operations. Make sure you are already meeting all registration and compliance requirements and determine if you have enough staff, equipment and financial resources for an expansion.
Do extensive research on what varietals are trending, up and coming, and currently popular to help you determine if your product will have demand right away. Determine which states have the highest wine consumption, signalling strong demand. This will help you determine who to target, and how your winery can capitalize on market opportunities.
In a market with hundreds and hundreds of options it’s important to make your brand and product attract consumers’ attention. Consider how you can present your brand through visual design, aesthetically pleasing or differentiated packaging, a compelling brand story, or any other component that makes your brand unique.
For your target audience, identify things like geography, age, psychographics, shopping preferences, and the types of wine and brands frequently purchased. Knowing and applying this information to your product will help it resonate with consumers on a personal level, increasing the likelihood of success.
Successful expansion relies on meticulous planning. Figure out your distribution strategy for each new area you want to enter and refine your sales pitch. Pin down details like if you are targeting a more local or national audience, and if your messaging and product placement will remain the same regardless of the market you enter.
After you’ve planned your strategy, now it’s time to organize the logistics, from supply chain to infrastructure. These factors can change based on location and the type of wine you sell, so it’s important to have a thorough understanding and extensive plan.
Make sure your distributors will care for your products, and be transparent with them regarding the time and resources you need. Verify that your products will fit in with their sales model and establish clear goals that you can use to measure success in the future. Taking the time upfront to determine if your distributors can meet your needs will save you a lot of time and resources down the road.
Now it’s time to obtain all the correct licenses and registrations you need to legally distribute your wine in new states. When it comes to excise taxes, shipping reports, licenses, registrations, price posting, and Certificates of Label Approvals (COLAs) the rules and requirements vary by state, making compliance complicated. Don’t underestimate the time, effort and importance of this step.
Stay on top of your compliance with regularly paying taxes and filing shipping reports. Actively track your data and measure your performance periodically to make sure you’re meeting goals and expectations and remain in good standing in each state where you have sales. If you get behind on state filings you risk penalties, fines or loss of licenses.
Assess the process and reflect on your successes and any mistakes you’ve made along the way. Use this information to better your next expansion—whether it’s moving into even more regions or increasing product diversity.
Help your winery get and stay compliant today.
Do you have questions about the rules, regulations, and compliance requirements of the beverage alcohol industry? This series, Ask Alex, is a perfect opportunity to get those pressing questions answered straight from one of the industry’s regulation and market experts, Alex Koral, Senior Regulation Counsel, Sovos ShipCompliant.
To take advantage of this opportunity and get your questions answered, submit questions to askshipcompliant@sovos.com and we’ll answer them here, in this blog series.
As we mentioned in a recent blog post, Chicago is extending its city excise tax on sales of alcoholic beverages to all sales made into the city, including those coming from out-of-city sources. Previously, this tax only applied on sales made in the city, in local package liquor stores. But Chicago saw a tax gap from sales of alcohol that were coming from outside of the city, and so they implemented an ordinance change to fill that gap; going forward, all sales of alcohol that finalize in Chicago need to have this tax applied, including direct to consumer shipments of wine.
For anyone affected, this means registering with the City of Chicago Finance Department, and filing a monthly report remitting the city excise tax. The broader implication of this tax, though, is that it is the first time a city is demanding tax remittances from non-local sellers.
While it is not new for DtC shippers to have state-level tax liabilities, it has never been the case for a city-administered tax. Generally, cities were seen as too locally-focused to impose taxes on remote sellers, but with Chicago beginning enforcement of this tax requirement this position may change.
There are other cities out there that extend their own excise tax on alcohol sold in their jurisdictions, so we’ll have to see if they follow Chicago. But we’ll also have to see how well Chicago manages the collection of these new taxes. There will be a lot of new tax filers that the Finance Department will have to process.
It was so wonderful to see how our audience continues to engage with us and look for valuable information and updates about the wine industry, even in these challenging times. Our annual summit is always a highlight of the year, when we get together to learn and connect and build on our collective experiences. And we were all saddened to have to cancel the live event. So seeing how well everyone moved to a virtual summit was extremely heartening and made me very encouraged about the future of this industry as we move out of the ongoing crisis (hopefully sooner than later).
It also came across to me that the DtC shipping market is at a bit of a moment of truth. While shipping by wine producers is a well-established market, there continue to be questions and concerns coming from state regulators, which came through from the panel with Matt Botting and Dexter Jones, from the California and Texas ABCs, respectively (whom I want to extend another huge thank you to for joining us!). No one thinks we can put the wine shipping genie back in the bottle, but we all need to make sure that everyone involved is following each state’s rules and are working to reduce any lingering leeriness that regulators have about this market. This will be especially true as more parties, like retailers, breweries and distillers, look to enter the DtC market in their own right.
Since we released the annual Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report in partnership with Wines Vines Analytics back in January, a lot has changed when it comes to how consumers are getting their wine. The COVID-19 pandemic swayed buying channels drastically, shifting traditional retail and on-premise sales over to ecommerce sales. With brick-and-mortar retailers being closed down temporarily, or hours modified, and on-premise locations like bars and restaurants being closed, many consumers have turned to DtC shipping in order to purchase their favorite wines. The DtC channel has seen significant growth due to this; in fact there have been almost 1 million more cases shipped in the first half of 2020 (January through June) than in the first half of 2019, a 29% increase. In terms of value, consumers have spent $222 million more in the first half of 2020 compared to 2019, a 15% increase.
Here’s a deeper look at just how much the DtC shipping channel has changed since January.
Every legal ship-to state has seen a volume increase in the first half of 2020. The range varied from +6% in Oregon to +125% in Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania also had a significant value increase of 59%. California remained a stronghold of the DtC shipping channel, making up 32% of the overall channel value and 29% of its volume.
Of the winery locations tracked (Napa, Sonoma, Central Coast (CA), Rest of CA, Oregon, Washington, Rest of US) the Sonoma region saw the largest increases in both volume and value, adding 290,000 cases shipped and $71M in additional revenue. The Rest of CA region also saw a significant volume increase of 62%. The regions of Napa, Rest of CA and Rest of US each added about $30M in value compared to 2019.
Within the DtC report, winery sizes are grouped together by the number of cases they produce annually. Wineries in the limited production (<1,000 cases) and large production (500,000+ cases) groups both had volume increases of 54%. Small wineries (5,000 to 49,999 cases) had significant growth as well, adding $139M in value. But, very small wineries (1,000 to 4,999 cases) saw only a 2% increase in volume and had a decrease of 5% in value.
Every varietal increased in volume in the first half of 2020. The highest volume increases were Pinot Gris (+53%) and Sauvignon Blanc (+47%). The lowest volume increases were Cabernet Franc (+15%), Cabernet Sauvignon (+16%) and Syrah (+17%).
In terms of value, Cabernet Sauvignon was the only varietal to see a decrease (-1%), but remains number one in the channel in terms of value, with $411M. Pinot Noir, Red Blends, and Chardonnay each added over $30M in value.
The average bottle price grew slightly in Oregon (+2%) and Washington (+4%). But, it decreased in Sonoma (-$2), Central Coast and Rest of CA (-$2.80), Rest of US (-$0.40), and most drastically in Napa (-$7.90).
The pandemic had drastically changed how consumers purchase wine, as reflected in the data above. Now the question is, will these trends and increased popularity continue post-pandemic?
This data was compiled with the help of Wines Vines Analytics, a leading source for wine industry data. Download the 2020 DtC Wine Shipping Report today.
Sovos is proudly sponsoring the 2021 Virtual version of Unified Wine and Grape Symposium!
Earlier this year, Kentucky passed a bill enabling direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of wine, beer, and spirits by licensed suppliers. When the bill was originally passed, it was expected it would take effect by July 15, 2020.
However, as our partners at Wine Institute recently confirmed, the state is instituting a delay on the implementation of these DtC laws until the associated regulations have been enacted, which would enable the Alcohol Beverage Control Commission to prepare the necessary license application processes.
Until such regulations are put into place, the ABC will not permit DtC shipping of alcohol under these new rules.
The process for drafting and enacting the necessary regulations is time consuming, requiring a full notice-and-comment period. It is expected that this will take several months before the regulations and application processes are available and DtC shipping of alcohol to Kentucky will be able to proceed.
Sovos ShipCompliant will continue to monitor updates from Kentucky and will provide more information on when DtC shipping to there can begin as it becomes available.
Sovos ShipCompliant hosted the 15th annual Wine Summit a couple weeks ago, only this time it was a shortened “Piccolo” virtual version. This half-day event featured some of the most popular sessions and presentations originally scheduled for the cancelled live event back in May. The recorded version of the event is available to watch on-demand; in the meantime here are some of the highlights and quick facts from each presentation:
Larry shared some perspective on Sovos ShipCompliant in the era of COVID-19 and beyond along with data on the direct-to-consumer (DtC) wine shipping market since the pandemic began earlier this year.
Dexter Jones and Matthew Botting discussed several regulatory topics with Alex Koral, Senior Regulatory Counsel, Sovos ShipCompliant, including temporary legislation changes resulting from COVID-19, the Texas DtC shipper audits, barriers in the three-tier system, and compliance regulations around common carriers shipping alcohol.
In his fifteenth annual Wine Summit address, Steve Gross shared that the Wine Institute continues its work on expanding shipping by opening new states and improving existing statutes, as well as protecting existing shipping privileges. As the pandemic worsened, they shifted to also prioritize allowing wineries to do production, DtC shipping and curbside pickup, allowing virtual tastings and dealing with common carrier COVID-19 protocols.
For more thorough information and discussion, get access to the event’s recordings and slides on-demand here. And mark your calendar for the 2021 Sovos ShipCompliant Wine Summit, April 28-29 at the Napa Valley Marriott. We look forward to seeing you there!
As of July 1, 2020, wineries making direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipments of wine into the city of Chicago will face an additional tax burden. Under Chicago ordinance O2020-801, the city’s Liquor Tax will now apply to all sales of alcohol to consumers in the city.
Chicago has long imposed an excise tax on sales of alcoholic beverages within city limits.
The tax rate is $0.36 per gallon for wines with an alcohol by volume content of 14% or less, and $0.89 per gallon for wines with an ABV between 14% and 20%.
Previously, this tax only applied to sales that were made at stores physically located in Chicago, but the rule change was specifically intended to encompass all remote sales that finalize within the city. Since Chicago is by far the largest destination in Illinois for DtC shipments of wine, this will likely have a large impact on DtC wine shippers. (Illinois currently does not permit DtC shipping of beer or spirits, so while the Chicago Liquor Tax does broadly apply to all alcoholic beverages, this change only specifically affects wine shippers.)
Going forward, wineries making DtC shipments into Chicago will be required to register with the City of Chicago Finance Department and file a monthly remittance of the Liquor Tax on their shipments into the city. Tax returns are not due for any month where sales were not made (i.e., $0 returns are not required), and the first tax filings will not be due until August 15 at the earliest.
The Chicago Finance Department has made it clear that wineries should not register for the Liquor Tax until after they have made a shipment of wine to Chicago after the effective date of July 1. This is a departure from most other taxes, which usually require registration in advance of sales. The Finance Department has indicated they will not accept any registrations from wineries that have not yet made sales into Chicago after July 1, 2020.
Further, there are no minimum thresholds for when this tax will apply. Any and all sales of DtC shipped wine into Chicago will require remittance of the Liquor Tax.
Once a winery has made a DtC shipment into Chicago, they will be required to submit a tax registration form with the Finance Department. There are two versions of the Tax Registration Application, one for Corporations, LLCs, and Partnerships, and another for Sole Proprietorships. Once completed, these forms should be submitted by email to Daniel.reichart@cityofchicago.org at the Finance Department for review, using the subject line “Wine Provider Registration.”
Businesses not located in Chicago are not required to receive a city business license. However, this does then mean that remote businesses are required to use the paper registration forms linked above rather than register through the Chicago Business Portal.
The Finance Department will process the application and should issue an approval within a few days. Once this approval has been received, the winery will then need to fill out and submit the Affidavit for Initial Tax Period Form, and submit it to the Finance Department by email with the subject line “Wine Provider Registration.” This form may also require the inclusion of a Power of Attorney form. During the COVID crisis, the Finance Department is temporarily relieving the notarization requirement under the guidance that a notarized affidavit can be submitted later on.
Finally, the winery will receive notice from the Finance Department that their application has been processed and that a Business Direct account has been created for them. They should then go to Chicago Business Direct and complete setting up their account.
Within their Chicago Business Direct account, a user can link to their Chicago tax account using the “Manage Business Account Access” page. Through this page, a user can also create additional user profiles that can be accessed by additional employees or third parties.
Thereafter, the winery will be required to remit the Liquor Tax on their DtC shipments to Chicago using the online-only Liquor Tax Return (Form 7573), which is due by the 15th of each month for when sales were made. In addition, an annual return must be submitted, which will summarize the yearly sales made by the filer.
The Chicago Finance Department only manages city taxes and sales made in or into the city limits. Therefore no other state, county, or non-Chicago tax is implicated by this change, nor will the Chicago Finance Department manage the remittance of these taxes.
Sovos ShipCompliant is currently working to develop the 7573 Liquor Tax Return to enable users to file by the first due date of August 15.
The application of the Chicago Liquor Tax is a departure from standard tax obligations for DtC wine shippers, who generally have only been burdened with state and state-administered local taxes. (An example of that is Louisiana, where local sales taxes only apply for wineries with economic nexus in the state and that is itself a very recent change following efforts by the state to simplify how it manages local tax collections.)
Of course, cities are as concerned as any other governmental body in maximizing their tax returns, and Chicago’s actions follow years of debate on whether the Liquor Tax could apply to remote sales as initially written. Whether this imposition of a city excise tax is unique, or becomes part of a trend, however, remains to be seen.
Do you have questions about the rules, regulations, and compliance requirements of the beverage alcohol industry? This series, Ask Alex, is a perfect opportunity to get those pressing questions answered straight from one of the industry’s regulation and market experts, Alex Koral, Senior Regulation Counsel, Sovos ShipCompliant.
To take advantage of this opportunity and get your questions answered, submit questions to askshipcompliant@sovos.com and we’ll answer them here, in this blog series.
No, not all states require product registrations, but most do. All alcoholic products that are being distributed across state borders must first be registered with the federal Trade and Tax Bureau (TTB), and receive a Certificate of Label Approval (COLA); there are exceptions for wine products with an ABV of 7% or less, and beer products that will only be sold in the same state they are produced in.
But then, there are about 40 states that have some kind of product registrations. These registrations vary a lot from state to state. Some are very easy—just requiring you to provide a copy of your COLA—but others get rather complicated, requiring you to provide laboratory analysis and/or distributor agreements and territory assignments.
Many states are moving to make registrations easier, including using online services like Product Registration Online (PRO). In the past, when some states joined the Sovos ShipCompliant-provided PRO service, they were able to drastically reduce the registration burdens. For instance, Colorado removed the state-fee for registrations and now allows instantaneous registrations.
Renewals also vary among the states. Many states do require an annual (or bi- or tri-annual) renewal, in order to let them know you will still be selling those products in the state. But others will never require a renewal, and once registered you can continue to sell those products in perpetuity. State agencies should provide you a notice when renewals are coming up, but it is important to be able to anticipate renewals yourself. Often these renewals are due either by January or July 1, so I would pay extra attention at these times of the year for notices from state regulators.
Be careful when entering a new state so you can fully anticipate any upcoming and future compliance requirements you will need to meet. And registrations are definitely an area where a supplier can get caught unawares.
Louisiana, effective July 1, 2020, is implementing a new service for all remote sellers with economic nexus that will require them to collect and remit all local taxes on sales they make into Louisiana. This is a necessary step for the state to implement its economic nexus rules, otherwise remote sellers wouldn’t be able to readily manage local sales taxes in the state.
This will affect DtC wine shippers who have economic nexus (defined as making either $100,000 in annual gross revenue or 200 separate annual transactions in Louisiana), and will now be required to collect and remit specific local taxes on their shipments to the state. Under the state’s DtC shipping laws, licensees are only inherently required to collect and remit the state tax of 4.5%—this law remains unchanged. But effective July 1, DtC shippers with economic nexus will also have a liability for local taxes and should plan on registering with the new Commission for Remote Sellers in order to remit their Louisiana taxes.
Last fall, Texas announced its plans to audit all DtC licensees to ensure they are properly licensed, remitting taxes correctly, using proper shipping practices, and only selling wines that they produce or bottle—that is, ensuring they are in compliance with the state’s laws. So it is very likely that, if you are a licensed DtC shipper in Texas, you will receive an audit notice in the coming months or years (this will be a long process to go through all roughly 1,600 licensees).
The notice will list out the specific information that the state is looking for and you should make sure to follow those specific requests and not any general data points that someone else has mentioned. But per their notice from last year, the TABC is looking for a wide range of data, including: sales data used to generate excise tax returns, COLAs for the wines you have sold into Texas or other proof that these are wines you produce or bottle, agreements you have with shipping companies and any contract bottlers you may work with, and copies of your home state and federal production licenses. (Much of this data is available in your Sovos ShipCompliant account; please reach out to our Support team if you need help finding them.) But again, you should comply with whatever is listed in any notice you receive and not rely on this list alone.
As for the process, the TABC has done a lot to make the audits as streamlined as possible. They have a lot of licensees to go through, so are themselves interested in making it an easy and smooth process. You should make sure to talk directly with your auditor and promptly provide any additional information they request. If your information is in order, that should make the entire process much easier and as streamlined as possible.
Looking to enter a new market or expand your product line? Growing any business can be complicated, and the beverage alcohol industry is no exception. Not knowing how or where to begin can be the biggest hurdle. From market research and branding to strategic considerations and compliance, this 10-step guide will get you on the right path in expanding your brewery’s footprint.
Assess your current operations. Before trying to expand or launch a new product it’s important to take a look at your current operations. Make sure you are already meeting all registration and compliance requirements and determine if you have enough staff, equipment and financial resources for an expansion.
Evaluate the market. Do extensive research on what is trending, up and coming, and currently popular to help you determine if your product will have demand right away, who to target, and how it can stand out.
Revisit your branding. In a market with hundreds and hundreds of options it’s important to make your brand and product attract consumers’ attention. Consider how you can present your brand through visual design, aesthetically pleasing or differentiated packaging, a compelling brand story or any other component that makes your brand unique.
Understand your audience. For your target audience, identify things like geography, age, psychographics, shopping preferences, and the type of alcoholic beverages and brands frequently purchased. Knowing and applying this information to your product will help it resonate with consumers on a personal level, increasing the likelihood of success.
Plan your strategy. Successful expansion relies on meticulous planning. Figure out your distribution strategy for each new area you want to enter and refine your sales pitch. Pin down details like is your beer going to be sold in a bottle or can, are you targeting a more local or national audience, and will your messaging and product placement remain the same regardless of the market you enter.
Sort out your logistics. After you’ve planned your strategy, now it’s time to organize the logistics, from supply chain to infrastructure. These factors can change based on location and the product’s ingredients, so it’s important to have a thorough understanding and extensive plan.
Choose distributors. Make sure your distributors will care for your products, and be transparent with them regarding the time and resources you need. Verify that your products will fit in with their sales model and establish clear goals that you can use to measure success in the future. Taking the time upfront to determine if your distributors can meet your needs will save you a lot of time and resources down the road.
Get compliant. Now it’s time to obtain all the correct licenses and registrations you need to legally distribute your products in new states. When it comes to excise taxes, shipping reports, licenses, registrations, price posting, and Certificates of Label Approvals (COLAs) the rules and requirements vary by state, making compliance complicated. Don’t underestimate the time, effort and importance of this step.
Remain compliant. Stay on top of your compliance with regularly paying taxes and filing shipping reports. Be proactive and track your data and measure your performance periodically to make sure you’re meeting goals and expectations and remain in good standing in each state where you have sales. If you get behind on state filings you risk penalties, fines or loss of licenses.
Assess, reflect, repeat. Assess the process and reflect on your successes and any mistakes you’ve made along the way. Use this information to better your next expansion—whether it’s moving into even more regions or expanding your product lines and increasing product diversity.
See how Sovos ShipCompliant can help with your brewery’s compliance today.
On July 1, 2020, new economic nexus laws will come into effect in Louisiana, requiring all remote sellers who meet certain sales thresholds to collect and remit all state and local sales taxes on their sales into the state. Wineries and retailers making direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipments of wine to Louisiana residents may be affected by this rule change.
Louisiana, long one of the more complicated states for sales tax, is moving to require more nuanced tax collections from remote sellers by creating a new Louisiana Sales and Use Tax Commission for Remote Sellers, which will serve as a single-point system for out of state businesses to collect and remit sales tax—including specific local taxes—on their sales into Louisiana.
Going forward, remote sellers with economic nexus in Louisiana will be required to register with the Commission for Remote Sellers and remit all state and local taxes through a new, as-yet-to-be released online filing system.
Direct-to-consumer wine shippers have been required to collect and remit sales tax on their shipments into Louisiana. This was a condition for getting the necessary direct shipping licenses issued by the state. However, recognizing the complexity of managing local taxes in the state, DtC shippers were only required by statute to collect and remit the 4.45% state rate, and no local taxes.
This remains the primary tax liability imposed by Louisiana on DtC shippers. However, under the new rules that are coming into effect on July 1, DtC shippers that also have economic nexus—by making either more than $100,000 in annual gross revenue in the state or 200 separate annual transactions—will now face an additional local tax burden. (Remote sellers without economic nexus may also continue to voluntarily collect and remit at the state-wide average rate of 8.45%, using a specific form designed for those remittances.)
Sovos ShipCompliant users will be able to select which of these three options they fall into by selecting the appropriate tax preferences and tax returns. More information will be sent directly to users as these rules come into effect.
There are still some open questions to Louisiana, such as how a DtC shipper that already has a Sales Tax Account should transfer (if needed) to a Remote Seller Account. As available, we will provide answers; interested parties should also feel free to refer to the state’s information page for Remote Sellers.
The move by Louisiana represents only the latest of numerous changes to sales tax across the country that followed the 2017 U.S. Supreme Court ruling, South Dakota v. Wayfair. In Wayfair, the Court determined the longstanding “physical presence” requirement for imposing a sales tax liability on a business was inapt for the internet age. Instead a more basic “sufficient presence” standard would apply, which in that case was reflected in South Dakota’s “economic nexus” law.
In the intervening years, a wave of legislation has passed over the country as more states adopted rules similar to South Dakota’s, establishing sales tax liabilities on businesses with economic nexus, which has seemed to settle on a standard threshold of either $100,000 in annual revenue in the state or 200 separate annual transactions.
However, many states have been tripped up by having very complicated sales tax determination processes. In the dicta (i.e., guiding, but non-determinative language in the Supreme Court’s ruling) for Wayfair, Justice Kennedy noted that South Dakota’s law was likely proper because it did not impose too great a burden on out of state businesses, in particular because it had a straightforward system for calculating and remitting local sales tax rates. Since an out of state business only had to deal with a single entity in the state when registering for and remitting sales tax, and could easily find proper tax rates across the state, their troubles would not outweigh the benefits that the state would see from additional tax collections.
But the states do not have equal tax determination and remittance processes. While many have moved towards simplification, even joining an organization designed around easing tax filing burdens on businesses (the Streamlined Sales Tax board), other states maintain rather complex systems, allowing local communities to manage their own tax registrations and remittances. This puts an incredible burden on out of state businesses to manage several different tax filings for a single state, and is clearly far outside of the standard hinted at by Justice Kennedy.
Nevertheless, these states still would prefer to receive all of the local tax remittances that would be due. Some, like Colorado, only require out of state businesses to collect and remit state-administered sales taxes (Colorado, though, remains extremely complex to manage for even in-state businesses). Others, like Louisiana, had used a single average rate that a remote seller could use for all sales in the state.
However, Louisiana had long been hinting that it would require remote sellers to collect specific local taxes, but had delayed implementation of that part of its economic nexus laws pending the establishment of this new Commission for Remote Sellers. It does mark a notable change in policy for the state and what will hopefully be a friendly standard for how more-complicated states might interact with remote sellers regarding their sales tax liabilities.
This is a common question wineries face when entering the direct-to-consumer (DtC) market, and the answer is yes. In order to ship wine DtC, a winery needs to have a DtC shipper’s license. This can be challenging as the rules and requirements to obtain this license vary by state. Because of this, an increasing number of businesses claim that they can eliminate this obstacle and handle all of the licensing needs for wineries that want to ship DtC.
But beware, wineries must obtain their own DtC shipper’s license in each state they wish to ship to in order to be compliant, with few exceptions. Relying on third-party licenses as a workaround or temporary solution can create a multitude of problems like fines, penalties, loss of other licenses, and even criminal charges.
Unfortunately, there are several problems with selling under someone else’s license. If you are the winery on record as the seller, or if the end consumer would name your winery as whom they purchased from, then you need your own license.
Here are some common scenarios and the difficulties that they present:
Wineries should not overlook their compliance obligations. States set up specific rules for DtC wine shipping, and they expect them to be followed rigorously. Attempting runarounds in order to avoid compliance headaches can lead to greater trouble down the line. So, use your own DtC shipper’s license.
Want to get licensed? Find out how.
It was May 2005 when the U.S. Supreme Court issued a ruling in Granholm v. Heald, one of the most consequential beverage alcohol-related cases the Court has heard. The case challenged laws in Michigan and New York that permitted in-state wineries to make direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipments to their residents, while prohibiting that right for out-of-state wineries.
This arrangement was very clearly discriminatory against out-of-state interests, which is normally unquestionably unconstitutional. However, this being beverage alcohol, there was an open debate whether it might still be allowable.
And the decision was close. By a slim 5 to 4 majority, the Court determined that a state’s power under the 21st Amendment to set up its internal alcohol market was not a carte blanche right to trample over other constitutional provisions. After all, the 21st Amendment was focused on enabling states to manage the health and safety of their residents in relation to alcohol consumption. Unless a law was tailored to those ends, it was otherwise subject to normal constitutional scrutiny.
Per the Court, if Michigan and New York wanted to allow their residents to receive DtC shipments of wine, they had to enable equal access to that market for both in-state and out-of-state wineries. A state was, of course, still free to entirely restrict such sales, it just could not establish a discriminatory set of rules.
In the fifteen years since that decision, a lot has changed.
For one, the DtC wine shipping market has blossomed. Spurred by the Granholm ruling, industry groups and grassroots organizations engaged in intensive lobbying efforts to spread DtC wine shipping laws across the country. Currently 46 states allow such shipments (or at least will soon, once Kentucky’s laws take effect), and annual DtC wine shipping revenue is currently at just north of $3 billion.
But as good as the DtC shipping market has been for wineries, other members of the beverage alcohol industry—retailers, breweries, distillers—have struggled to get anywhere near the same boon. There has been increased interest and efforts—including another Supreme Court case—to extend DtC permissions, but the rules remain closed.
In the meantime, though, the current COVID-19 crisis has created much more immediate focus on alternative means of selling and distributing alcohol.
So, as we look back on fifteen years of Granholm, there is a lot to unpack and examine about what the case has meant, how it helps shape current policy discussions, and where it might take us in the years to come.
Despite being heavily regulated and relatively nascent, DtC shipping of wine has developed into a robust and effective means for small and medium wineries to get a national footprint and for wine connoisseurs to access wines that aren’t widely distributed.
However, the success that wineries have seen from DtC shipping is not widely shared among other members of the broader alcohol industry.
Beer producers are limited to just about 10 states: Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Ohio, Oregon (but only from states that themselves permit DtC shipping of beer), Vermont, Virginia, the District of Columbia, and, effective later this summer, Kentucky.
Spirits producers face an even more truncated map. Only Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, North Dakota, the District of Columbia, and, effective later this summer, Kentucky, permit distillers to ship DtC. Arizona does permit licensed microdistillers to make DtC shipments; however, they cap the annual production size of such distilleries at 1,189 gallons.
A few states seem to allow in-state producers to make DtC shipments of both beer and spirits as an extension of those businesses’ tasting room sales. However, these permissions are not widely advertised, likely because they would be readily subject to a Granholm challenge.
Cider is an interesting product type, as it straddles the boundaries of wine and beer. As an agricultural product (i.e., when the cider is actually produced from apples, and isn’t merely apple-flavored), cider is generally regulated as a wine. However, many agencies see cider, with its lower ABV and beer-like packaging, as more resembling a beer. This adds a lot of confusion to when and where cider may be shipped DtC.
Generally, where cider meets the definition of wine in a state, it should be allowed under the state’s DtC shipping laws. However, several states put ABV thresholds on the cider they will allow to be shipped, generally requiring it to have an ABV of at least 6% or 7%. Cider producers, therefore, would do well to not presume that they will inherently be able to ship their product DtC under a state’s wine shipping laws. While most states have told us that, where a cider meets the federal definition of a wine it can be currently shipped under their DtC wine laws, the multifaceted view that states take to cider makes it difficult to create a clear picture of where in fact it may be shipped DtC.
Retailers have managed to get access to about 15 states’ DtC markets: Alaska, Connecticut, Florida, Louisiana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Virginia, West Virginia, Wyoming and the District of Columbia; and then California, New Mexico, and Idaho operate on a reciprocity basis, permitting each other’s retailers to ship to their residents. Where permitted, retailers are limited to the same product limitations as producers.
There is no real reason why non-winery members of the alcohol industry could not enjoy the same DtC shipping privileges of wineries. Indeed, the success of DtC wine shipping, which is by and large compliant with state regulations and remits millions of dollars in tax revenue annually to the states, signals that, if made available, these other industry members could also create effective and compliant DtC shipping programs.
However, to reach the level of availability that wine producers have, these other industry members will need to engage in widespread lobbying efforts—including gathering grassroots support—to change laws across the nation.
In recent years, there has been increased interest among retailers, breweries and distilleries in entering the DtC market. They have seen the success of DtC wine shipping and fairly want to share in the bounty. Despite this interest, their options for available markets are still diminished.
Nevertheless, this moment, 15 years after Granholm, brings new opportunities and action.
Last June, the Supreme Court issued a ruling in Tennessee Wine and Spirits Retailer’s Association v. Thomas (TWSRA), the first beverage alcohol case the Court had heard since Granholm. While this case was limited to the specific issue of whether Tennessee’s two-year residency requirement for applying for a package store license was valid, there was hope that it could spur further liberalization of the alcohol industry. That is because the ruling, in invalidating the residency requirement, determined that the anti-discriminatory principles of Granholm should extend beyond the producer-tier, to retailers and distributors.
Almost immediately after the ruling came down, retailers began challenging seemingly discriminatory laws prohibiting out of state retailers from making DtC shipments across the nation. A few cases that predated TWSRA were amended to take into account the Supreme Court’s new jurisprudence. However, the hopes of such efforts may have been premature.
Just a few weeks ago, the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in Lebamoff v. Snyder that a Michigan law permitting in-state retailers, but not out-of-state retailers, to ship wine DtC to its residents was valid. The ruling largely overlooked the anti-discriminatory provision that the Supreme Court set down in TWSRA and Granholm, instead focusing on the potential harmful impact on the state’s three-tier system that interstate shipping would bring. Claiming that interstate DtC shipping of alcohol would lead to a heavy loss of tax revenue (despite the possibility of requiring all DtC shippers to pay destination-state taxes) and abuse by underage drinkers (even though this is a much more common problem for in-person retailers), the court upheld Michigan’s law.
What this decision means for court cases in other states remains to be seen. But it does severely diminish hopes that retailers could find regulatory relief from discriminatory laws in the courts.
Ultimately, it is a global emergency that is more likely to spur changes to the alcohol industry and bring greater allowances for DtC shipping of alcohol.
Almost every state, facing a catastrophic curtailment of day-to-day business, has enabled emergency rules vastly expanding the rights of alcohol sellers to engage with consumers. Restaurants and craft producers across the country are able to sell wine, beer and even mixed cocktails to go; many are even able to fulfill remote orders through common carriers, paralleling the DtC wine shipping market.
These rules are a patchwork, varying wildly from state to state. And it must also be said that these are emergency relaxation of otherwise valid prohibitions—states are not changing their laws, they are instead merely not enforcing a number of restrictions. These provisions are also largely focused on local, small businesses, which state governments want to buoy in times of social distancing.
But we have seen that, as in so many cases, it’s impossible to put the genie back in the bottle. Consumers are flocking to online sales and fulfillment through common carriers. Forced by an emergency (and one we all hope ends soon with a minimum of loss of life and other suffering), consumers are discovering the benefits of DtC shipping of alcohol. And they will demand more of it going forward.
Indeed, several states have already introduced legislation making some of their emergency provisions permanent. To-go cocktails seem like a new happy hour. And consumers are certain to question the validity of prohibitions on shipping of alcoholic beverages going forward.
Again, the COVID-19 crisis is an unmitigated tragedy, but those looking to gain new footholds for DtC shipping of alcohol would do well to build on the increased attention that this tragedy has brought to remote sales of alcohol and fulfillment through common carriers.
The fifteen years after Granholm have seen constant efforts by the wine industry to expand their DtC permissions and build out a market and infrastructure capable of handling the demand. And the success is ready to see, with a $3+ billion dollar annual market that largely meets the particular compliance requirements imposed by the individual states.
What the next fifteen years will bring remains to be seen. But there are many reasons to believe that DtC shipping of all alcoholic products by more industry members will continue to expand. There is the desire among consumers, and the interest and ability to comply with laws among sellers. All we need is to build on our past success.
Do you have questions about the rules, regulations, and compliance requirements of the beverage alcohol industry? This series, Ask Alex, is a perfect opportunity to get those pressing questions answered straight from one of the industry’s regulation and market experts, Alex Koral, Senior Regulation Counsel, Sovos ShipCompliant.
To take advantage of this opportunity and get your questions answered, submit questions to askshipcompliant@sovos.com and we’ll answer them here, in this blog series.
When a state newly opens up to DtC wine shipping, the biggest impact is the sudden availability of hundreds of thousands, even millions, of new consumers for wineries to interact with directly. The biggest increases in annual DtC shipments always accompany the entry of a new state to the market; even a relatively small state like Oklahoma, which opened in October 2018, shifted the overall numbers. Of course, we will have to wait for Kentucky’s DtC laws to come into effect before we will see any new shipments, but the prospect of an entire new state is always exciting for the DtC market.
It is also possible that this news will spark increased interest among consumers in other states to look into available DtC shipping options. One of the bigger limitations currently affecting the DtC market is lack of awareness among consumers, and so anything that can pique the interest of even a handful of new customers will be positive. And DtC shippers can anticipate this growth by preparing, by building out their online marketplaces, developing strong logistics protocols, and getting ahead of anticipated compliance needs.
DtC shipping of beer and spirits is definitely an area of growing interest. Many brewers and distillers across the country are looking at the DtC wine market — $3 billion in annual revenue, easy(ier) access to a national market for small brands — and wondering how they can also benefit.
Now, there are certainly differences in shipping these products than for wine: beer doesn’t have the price point advantage, which can make shipping costs seem prohibitive; spirits have to contend with age-old stigmas around higher-alcohol content products. Kentucky is also a little unique in having a very strong and active local spirits industry, which is poised to lobby to make sure they’re included in any new allowable sales models. But it does seem like the trend is moving towards greater access to more products for consumers, and so I would expect DtC shipping of beer and spirits to become more common over the next few years. However, it will take a lot of commitment by these industries and grassroots efforts to convince states to change. Prospective beer and spirits DtC shippers would do well to take a cue from the wine industry on how best to accomplish this.
Samples have long been an area of keen interest for the DtC shipping market, and it is unfortunate that it took the current COVID-19 crisis to spur regulatory action on this issue. It should be noted that this issue is not constrained to the TTB, but also relies on individual state agencies allowing the shipping of samples. The TTB, indeed, merely indicated that shipped samples will be considered part of a winery’s normal removal of tax paid wine; it is then up to the individual state to determine the parameters of when and how it can be shipped (though generally applicable federal labeling and tax rules must be followed per TTB guidance).
States, then, are waiving enforcement of laws that limit where wineries can provide samples or indicating that sample-sizes may be shipped under existing DtC shipping laws. This often requires the winery to charge customers for samples or include samples as a package deal with other purchases of wine. Similarly, state labeling and tax laws must be complied with.
So ultimately, DtC wine sampling tends to look like other DtC shipments of wine, just in smaller bottles. In some cases, these emergency provisions are actually clarification of what is otherwise allowable. However the states that are instead just not enforcing laws restricting the shipment of samples will need to have actual law changes to make these provisions permanent. This crisis has spurred increased interest in DtC shipping of samples, though, and so I would expect that at least some of these allowances will become permanent.
To be an expert, one has a specialty. Ours is beverage alcohol compliance. Since compliance sits at the heart of operations, being connected at every step helps our customers focus on their business instead spending countless hours on manual processes.
Compliance is challenging, but we make it easier with a large and robust network of partnerships, enabling clients to have seamless operations across the board. Integrated technology helps eliminate time-consuming work like transferring data from one system to the next, so you can focus on your specialty, regardless of where it falls within the beverage alcohol industry.
Which would you rather do, re-type and and manually update information from one system to the next in order to compliantly fulfill, tax, and report on an order or, have that data transfer seamlessly with no extra manual work? It’s a no-brainer. This is where integrated technology improves your efficiency and productivity while minimizing time spent.
Say a customer in Oregon wants to order a case of your Pinot Noir and have it shipped DtC. With a seamless technology integration, like ShipCompliant being directly integrated into your ecommerce platform, a compliance check will be done in real time, letting your potential customer (and you) know right away if they can order and receive that DtC shipment. The compliance check will make sure the destination address allows wine shipments, that the consumer hasn’t exceeded the Oregon volume limits of two cases per individual in one calendar month, and prompt you to collect all the required customer information needed in your quarterly reports to the state.
This crucial integration also allows accurate sales tax determination in real-time, preventing any complications in the future—between you and customers, or between you and state agencies. Once the order is complete, integrated systems allow that data to be transferred into your fulfillment system and beyond, while ensuring compliance at every step and cutting down a lot of manual and time-consuming work along the way.
Having seamless, quick and efficient data transfer throughout your DtC shipping operations will reduce the time spent on compliance and reporting obligations.With this data and information being transferred across platforms, the risk of incorrect information, noncompliance and order inaccuracies greatly decreases. Having systems that “talk” to each other simplifies operations and reduces time spent on manual processes while minimizing the risk of human error. With a streamlined and efficient process, you and your team have more free time to prioritize other aspects of your business that previously you couldn’t give your full attention.
Our client, Moshin Vineyards, saw a notable improvement in their customer experience after implementing ShipCompliant, as it connects directly to their POS and immediately informs their team of any compliance issues—a process that used to take over 50 hours a month to complete manually. Moshin Vineyards chose ShipCompliant for their compliance operations in part because of our integrations with a large number of the most widely-used front-end systems in the industry. Now, Moshin Vineyards considers ShipCompliant a cornerstone of its DtC compliance process, electing to choose only from the 60+ solutions that integrate directly with the platform.
“We selected ShipCompliant first and absolutely fell in love with the idea of how it managed the DtC compliance process. Then we found software that would work with it, not the other way around. ShipCompliant makes it possible to do our job and we can trust that the information from ShipCompliant is accurate. You just can’t put a price on customer satisfaction and peace of mind,” says Julia Lander, Director of Hospitality, Moshin Vineyards.
With compliance being important at every step, we have strategically partnered with front end systems, ERPs, fulfillment houses, carriers and even state agencies. Sovos ShipCompliant actively works with these partners in order to maintain the best integrations. In the week of May 3, there were over 1.9 million API calls between our platform and our partners to check compliance, commit orders and calculate sales tax.
Anthony Orig, senior technical partner manager, says, “Our partnerships go well beyond the technical integrations and into the realm of providing valuable content to the industry: from compliance webinars with the Texas Alcohol Beverage Commission to DtC marketing best practices and ways to keep engaged with your customers. We are continually expanding our ecosystem with new partnerships and collaborations.”
Our integrated partners are industry-leading software and on-premise solutions that we’ve created direct integrations with for real-time, alcohol-specific tax rates, compliance checks, order data and product SKU syncs.This allows different systems to “talk” to each other seamlessly, reducing manual time and effort spent. We have over 60 partners at the different levels of platinum certified, certified, partner and third party integrator.
Sovos ShipCompliant also aligns with industry partners whose work helps their clients and members focus on what they do best, making and selling great beverage alcohol products.
There is no one magical solution or platform that solves all the problems beverage alcohol producers, suppliers, distributors and retailers may face. But a strong network of integrated platforms and partnerships minimizes obstacles by helping you meet state reporting obligations, ensuring compliance, and keeping your business running seamlessly. So, whether you’re just starting out or if you’re adding new capabilities to your established business, this vast network of both integrated and industry partners that can help you along the way.
If you are looking for a compliance solution but already have multiple systems in place for specific parts of your operations, we make it so you don’t have to choose one platform over another. Sovos ShipCompliant integrates into your company’s workflow seamlessly to improve overall operations, simplify data transfer and efficiency, and ensure compliance at every step. Adding a compliance solution shouldn’t be a burden, but a benefit and opportunity to quickly improve the efficiency of your operations.
Want to learn more about our partners or partner with us yourselves? See our partners here.
Our recent webinar with WineDirect and Enolytics, Post-Pandemic Planning: Customer Engagement for the Road Ahead, was a timely topic that drew lively Q&A—too many to address in our allotted hour! Here are our panelists’ take on the most-surfaced themes in your questions.
(Missed the live webinar? You can still access the recording and slides on demand.)
Cathy Huyghe, Enolytics: To catalogue risk, we create cohorts and analyze their behavior. By “cohort” we mean a group of people with similarities, such as females in a particular wine club who have been members for a certain number of months. This is the “pre-marketing” segmentation that lays the groundwork (and adds real-life teeth) to the kind of personas that underpin successful targeted marketing outreach and creative communications.
Then we ask, what is the likelihood of that cohort leaving the club at this period of time? Every cohort has a risk profile, that our algorithms define based on variables (churn rate being one of them) on a month-by-month basis.
Cathy Huyghe, Enolytics: In addition to what is described above regarding cohorts, an additional variable worth considering is personal purchase history. In terms of Enolytics specifically, this gets in the weeds technically; the algorithms we’ve developed are beyond the capabilities of Excel and are in the realm of artificial intelligence. But here’s an example. If customers’ purchase history aligns very closely with the more general cohort purchasing history, we find that those customers are at greater risk. If customers deviate from the cohort and purchase outside the wine club (through telemarketing and website channels, for example), we find that those customers are at less risk.
Adrienne Stillman, WineDirect: If you are working out of a spreadsheet, or have more basic customer data, start with what you have. If you only have geography, segment based on that. You should also have purchase history. With those two things, you can target your local club members for pickup orders and your one-time tasting room buyers from Texas for an introductory shipping offer. Start small and build as you go.
Cathy Huyghe, Enolytics: You might be surprised at how much we can do with relatively limited fields of data. Birthdate, for example, is critical in order to identify generational differences. Another example is first name, which we use to determine gender with a high mathematical probability. A third example is contact information like email or phone, and also street address where the order is shipped.
Birthdate, first name and zip code are the three most essential pieces of information you want to be sure are in your database, because that enables segmentation by generation, gender and geography. Email address and phone number are also very important in order to enable targeted campaigns via email (driving traffic to your website) or telemarketing.
Cathy Huyghe, Enolytics: Yes, Enolytics in integrated with WineDirect’s ecommerce tools via a daily data sync. Enolytics also interacts with WineDirect by seamlessly directing you to the appropriate WineDirect window as needed. For example, when Enolytics identifies a bad email address, we’ll automatically open that customer’s contact profile in WineDirect so that you can fix it with a minimum of clicks.
Alex Koral, Sovos ShipCompliant: Similarly, WineDirect is a Sovos ShipCompliant Platinum Certified integrated partner.
Adrienne Stillman, WineDirect: There’s a lot of room for human error when it comes to updating or entering data, from a guest themselves accidentally inputting a bad email to tasting room staff inadvertently mis-entering a phone number.
Ensuring accurate data entry at the point of collection is critical. Ideally, the guest should enter their own data electronically wherever possible, be that on your website or in your tasting room. Remove as many manual steps as possible between data entry and upload into your customer relationship management (CRM) software.
You can also simply ask customers and fans to periodically to update their information via email. If people are invested in your brand, they want to hear from you and they’ll do it.
Finally, if you see high-value customers unsubscribe from your mailing list, or see a drop-off in engagement, this would be a good group to target with a call campaign for a check in and opportunity to update their data that way.
Alex Koral, Sovos ShipCompliant: Like most of the emergency provisions that are in effect during the COVID-19 crisis, the relaxation of signature requirements is unlikely to become permanent. The waiving of this requirement is a valid and rational response to social/physical distancing, but this is a temporary action that does not relieve the general requirement to get adult signatures when delivering packages containing alcohol. Many states’ laws specifically demand carriers get an adult’s signature at the time of delivery, and require follow-up reporting documenting the signatures they have received. These laws will have to be amended through legislation in order to become permanent. During this emergency, when concerns about proximity with other people are top of mind, states are looking the other way at this and other otherwise effective laws. But we should expect that when the emergency clears (which we all hope happens soon), requirements like signing for wine packages will once again be enforced.
It should also be noted that, even if the signature requirements are being relaxed during the emergency, it remains an absolute requirement that alcohol be neither sold nor delivered to anyone under the age of 21. Carriers that are not gathering signatures at the time of delivery must still physically contact a person at the time of delivery and verify that they are of age to receive alcohol. Failure to comply with these requirements carries the risk of criminal prosecution, which can be imputed from the carrier onto the winery.
Adrienne Stillman, WineDirect: First, think about how you can “re-acquire” some of your existing mailing list members who haven’t purchased from you in a while —or ever. These are your warmest leads and will be the easiest to convert to a sale. Strategies for reaching this group include special email offers, phone sales campaigns, direct mail and social media advertising. Remember: multi-channel campaigns are more successful than single-channel.
You can also leverage social media lookalike audiences to generate potential groups of new customers you can advertise to.
Finally, incentivize your existing fans to evangelize on your behalf by offering special gifting opportunities and rewarding referrals.
Adrienne Stillman, WineDirect: Aim for next day—any longer than that and they may have moved on to a different product.
P.S. Keep an eye on our webinars listing for upcoming and on-demand educational events.