When New York first passed its law defining what constitutes a “vendor” subject to collecting sales tax in the 1980’s, the idea of online shopping sounded like science fiction. In retrospect, NY may have effectively enacted the first “economic nexus” law when they drafted their definition of “vendor” to include a person who regularly or […]
Key Lessons from Spain’s SII Requirement as Updates Loom
With implementation of technology-enabled tax compliance and reporting initiatives, Spain is leading the way throughout Europe not only in closing the VAT gap but also in obtaining visibility into business data. As more and more countries move toward requiring transactional data in real-time, most notably Italy and Hungary, it’s important for companies to consider lessons learned in the initial implementation of Spain’s SII to prepare for the expected wave of VAT compliance and reporting change.
Spain’s SII mandate took effect in July 2017, requiring businesses to adapt their processes and technological infrastructure to support quasi real-time transaction reporting. The results were almost immediate. Within three months, the Spanish government reported that approximately 50,000 businesses met the mandate – a 90% compliance rate – with transmission of more than 700 million invoices totaling €630 billion in value. Since the launch, companies have learned several key lessons:
Government Needs Take Priority Over Business Needs
While the Spanish government views its VAT compliance and reporting requirements a success, many businesses have a contrary opinion. Companies have voiced concerns that the platform was designed for tax authorities and did not take into consideration businesses’ point of view, requiring adoption of new technology and significant changes to common practices.
Endless Change Is the Name of the Game
In the first few months after launching SII, Spain implemented several modifications to the mandate. In February, the Spanish tax authority announced even more changes, updating the technical documentation for implementation of version 1.1 of the SII. This updated version will go into effect July 1, 2018, pending the ratification of an order governing this process. Version 1.1 corrects problems identified during the initial implementation of the SII, and includes changes designed to make compliance easier for taxpayers.
Given the initial results of SII, Spain is expected to roll out the mandate to remaining businesses not currently required to participate as early as 2019.
Errors Must Be Avoided
Given the dramatic business impact of the compliance and reporting rules, Spain has been initially tolerant of missed deadlines and errors. But the government will soon become more stringent, assessing penalties and fines, as well as denying companies the right to deduct VAT if they don’t comply. That’s one of the reasons the tax authority is moving toward version 1.1; changes are designed to facilitate taxpayer compliance.
Thus far, Spain’s Ministry of Finance reports only an 84% correlation between reporting transactions and the corresponding VAT returns. That means 16% of transactions would have resulted in fines and penalties should the government be enforcing them. Companies must take a hard look at their compliance and reporting efforts and eliminate such errors as the government moves swiftly to start cracking down.
For more details about the initial Spain SII implementation and how your company can prepare for what’s on the horizon, download our white paper, “Key Lessons Learned from Spain’s SII Rollout.”
With recent enforcement measures, the IRS has offered definitive proof that the Affordable Care Act (ACA) is still alive and that the agency plans to strictly enforce ACA reporting. Last spring, the agency issued Letter 226J to Applicable Large Employers (ALEs) that failed to cover 95 percent of employees. ALEs are companies with 50 or […]
UPDATE (Jan. 8): Reporting season is moving forward according to plan. The IRS has announced that it will process tax returns on schedule and without delays. While the agency will clarify its contingency plan in the coming days, organizations should proceed as planned with 1099 reporting and other seasonal filings. The IRS will recall a […]
The South Dakota v. Wayfair decision last June has created a lot of angst for indirect tax professionals and the businesses they work so hard to protect from the burdens of sales and use tax filing. Six months later as we begin the new year, that angst has not gotten any lighter. Any federal legislative […]
2018 was a volatile year in indirect tax compliance for tax, finance and IT professionals worldwide. With an increase in globalization and tax gaps surpassing tens of billions in some countries, it’s not surprising that one of the biggest challenges governments are addressing is revenue collection. Like enterprises, governments are creating new, technology-driven processes to […]