“Trends” Report Excerpt: The Consequences of VAT Non-Compliance

Christiaan Van Der Valk
December 23, 2019

The following is an excerpt from “Trends in Continuous Global VAT Compliance,” the 11th edition of the industry’s most comprehensive guide to e-invoicing, e-archiving and VAT reporting. The full report is available for download

To reduce the VAT gap, countries are pushing taxable organizations to comply with VAT requirements and enforcing different types of legal consequences for irregularities. The consequences VAT non-compliance can be significant. 

As a result, most companies want to be as certain as possible they can quickly and easily prove their VAT compliance to avoid risks, including:

  • Administrative fines: If a company cannot prove the veracity of invoices, it may be fined. Trading partners who have been drawn into an audit that leads to this conclusion may also be penalized.
  • Sanctions under criminal law: In some countries, non-compliance with invoicing requirements can be equated with tax evasion, which is typically liable to sanctions (e.g., fines, imprisonment) under criminal law.
  • Protracted audits: Audits should generally take only a few days, but many companies are audited for weeks or even months. This eats up precious expert resources and creates risks of more processes and documents being scrutinized and, potentially, found flawed or lacking.
  • Spill-over effects into other areas of taxation or accounting: Once a tax authority has established that a sales transaction cannot be evidenced, a company may also face sanctions in other areas of taxation. For example, non-recognition of an invoice for tax purposes may undermine the credibility of a company’s annual accounts or deductible expenses under corporate income tax.
  • Trading partner audits: The tax authority may have no choice but to verify the records and original documents of the audited company’s trading partners. This can negatively affect a company’s relationship with business partners.
  • Mutual assistance procedures: Auditors may need to call on their counterparts from other countries to obtain evidence about certain aspects of the company’s operations. Such procedures tend to be long and can tie up expensive expert resources within a company for months or even years.
  • Loss of right to deduct VAT: A company that does not have sufficient evidence of purchases — that cannot prove it was in control of its processes at the time of the transactions — may need to pay back input VAT it reclaimed on such purchases. With an average VAT rate of 20 percent, this means a high risk of that company retroactively losing more than its profit margin.
  • Obligation to pay VAT over fraudulent invoices: If a fraudster can easily forge invoices that are not reasonably distinguishable from a supplier’s normal invoices, a tax authority without credible evidence to the contrary may in extreme cases consider such invoices to have been issued by that supplier and claim output VAT payment if the buyer reclaimed the corresponding VAT. 
  • CTCs and data analysis: The introduction of CTCs and tax authorities’ growing ability to analyze vast amounts of transactional and other economic data collected directly from source systems rapidly makes compliance a much more binary proposition than before. In the post audit world, compliance was often a matter of legal interpretation where courts upheld standards of reasonableness such as proportionality, which tempered the desire of many tax authorities to penalize taxpayers for mere irregularities. The consequences of non-compliance in the CTC world is expected to become much tougher and far-reaching.

CTCs drive harsher penalties 

A recent example of the trend for countries with CTC regimes to toughen invoicing-related penalties is a recently adopted Mexican law (CS-LXIV-II-1P-006) that makes invoicing for, for example, non-existent operations a felony, equating potential invoicing errors with tax fraud and organised crime.

Take Action

Want to learn how to avoid risks associated with VAT non-compliance? Download the 11th edition of “Trends in Continuous Global VAT Compliance.”

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.

Author

Christiaan Van Der Valk

Christiaan Van Der Valk is vice president, strategy. Elected a World Economic Forum Global Leader for Tomorrow in 2000, Christiaan is an internationally recognized voice on e-business strategy, law, policy, best practice and commercial issues. Formerly co-founder and president of Trustweaver (acquired by Sovos), Christiaan also holds long-standing leadership roles at the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) and the European E-invoicing Service Providers Association (EESPA). Over the past 20 years, he has presented at and authored key papers for international meetings at the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), the Asia Europe Meeting, World Trade Organization and several other UN agencies. Christiaan earned his Master of Laws degree from Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam.
Share This Post
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

North America ShipCompliant
May 14, 2021
Alabama Is Latest State to Permit Direct-to-Consumer Shipping of Wine

Alabama Governor Kay Ivey signed HB 437 into law on May 13, 2021, making Alabama the latest state to legalize direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of wine. With this step, only Delaware, Mississippi and Utah continue to prohibit this popular and valuable means of selling wine. Alabama’s new DtC law will not become effective until August 1, […]

Tax Compliance Tax Information Reporting
May 14, 2021
Anatomy of a Due Diligence Letter

What is unclaimed property due diligence? An unclaimed property due diligence letter is an organization’s last chance at contacting an apparent owner and preventing their property from escheatment. Each state or reporting jurisdiction has its own unique set of requirements and standards. Due diligence letters are typically required to be sent 30 to 120 days […]

EMEA VAT & Fiscal Reporting
May 13, 2021
EU Council Approves DAC7 Rules on Digital Platform Tax Reporting

On 22 March 2021 the EU Council approved DAC7, which establishes EU-wide rules meant to improve administrative cooperation in taxation. In addition, the Directive addresses additional challenges posed by a growing digital platform economy. What is DAC7? In 2011, the EU adopted Directive 2011/16/EU on administrative cooperation in the field of taxation in the EU […]

E-Invoicing Compliance EMEA VAT & Fiscal Reporting
May 13, 2021
Russia Introduces Mandatory E-Invoicing From 1 July 2021

Russia introduces a new e-invoicing system for traceability of certain goods on 1 July 2021. Federal Law No. 371-FZ will amend the Russian Tax Code to introduce the new procedure for the traceability system, which will bring the introduction of mandatory e-invoicing for taxpayers dealing with traceable goods. Since its introduction, B2B e-invoicing in Russia […]

North America ShipCompliant
May 12, 2021
Tennessee Set to Impose Regulations on Fulfillment Houses in DtC Wine Shipments

On May 6, 2021, Tennessee Governor Bill Lee signed HB 742 into law, establishing a slew of new provisions affecting the direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping of wine in the state. These provisions, however, will not become effective until January 1, 2022. While the bill does impose several new restrictions and requirements on businesses involved in DtC […]