Showdown on the Prairie – Kansas AG Invalidates DOR Economic Nexus Pronouncement

Charles Maniace
October 3, 2019

In a startling development that appears intertwined with local Kansas politics, Attorney General Derek Schmidt issued an opinion that attempts to place a temporary halt to the Department of Revenue’s (DOR) plan to extend its sales tax compliance requirements to remote sellers as of October 1, 2019 – leaving taxpayers in a state of limbo. For sellers that have robust sales tax automation tools in place, however, the uncertainty created by these circumstances is far less problematic.

Back on August 1, 2019, the Kansas DOR published Notice 19-04. In short, the notice signaled the DOR’s intention to compel remote sellers to collect Kansas tax effective October 1, 2019. This action was somewhat remarkable as it came on the heels of a failed legislative attempt to pass a remote collection bill that was vetoed by the governor (for unrelated reasons). It was also unusual because it applied to all sellers regardless of the strength of their economic connection with Kansas, meaning that one sale into Kansas, no matter how small, creates a compliance requirement. 

What wasn’t particularly unusual was that the standard was promulgated exclusively by DOR action and not through legislation. Many states held the assertion that existing law gives them the authority to apply tax to the maximum extent allowed, and many states did not wait for their local legislature to act to put rules in place. While other states had a far different opinion, Kansas believed that it could not apply a small seller exemption (e.g. 200 transactions and/or $100,000 in gross sales) through its Notice but could only do so through legislation…and it turns out this assessment may come back to haunt the state government.

Without going into the particulars, the AG’s opinion holds that the Notice constitutes an invalid exercise of the DOR’s authority and accordingly there is no legally sufficient basis for it to compel remote collection on October 1. The opinion specifically points to the absence of a safe harbor for small taxpayers and hold, at a minimum, such a requirement could only come into existence through a more comprehensive notice and comment rulemaking process. As a result, the Notice has no force or legal effect.

However, Kansas Revenue Secretary Mark Burghart respectfully disagrees and in a statement published on the DOR website, he holds fast to his position that:

  • Notice 19-04 simply informs out-of-state retailers of the law that overwhelmingly passed the Legislature in 2003 that ensures the obligation of out-of-state retailers to collect and remit the taxes…The Notice does not reflect a change in policy, but only restates long-established statutory provisions regarding the duty to collect and remit Kansas taxes.
  • The Department of Revenue cannot select which laws it enforces. Kansas statutes are presumed to be constitutional, and unless deemed otherwise by a court of competent jurisdiction, the Department is obligated to enforce the statutes enacted by the Legislature.

In short – the DOR believes that the Notice is valid, that a collection requirement exists, and sellers should comply. Whether the DOR would move to enforce this new requirement through an assessment or audit in light of the Attorney General’s opinion remains uncertain. 

It’s possible that the DOR could deploy its rulemaking procedure to enact a remote collection requirement in a way that involves more procedure or formality, or maybe things become clear in a few months when the legislature reconvenes and possibly passes an economic nexus bill that the governor signs. 

However, sellers need not be paralyzed with fear or apprehension. Companies that have technology solutions in place that “Solve Tax for Good” are readily able to adapt to expanded, adjusted, revoked, or modified economic nexus standards.

Take Action

Download the presentation slides and recording from “The Speed of Sales Tax – How to Stay Ahead of Changing Regulations in 2019,” where Deloitte Tax LLP joins Chuck Maniace and Erik Wallin of Sovos to discuss trends in sales tax compliance that will impact tax professionals’ day-to-day processes and work.

 

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.

Author

Charles Maniace

Chuck is Vice President –Regulatory Analysis & Design at Sovos, a global provider of software that safeguards businesses from the burden and risk of modern tax. An attorney by trade, he leads a team of attorneys and tax professionals that provide the tax and regulatory content that keeps Sovos customers continually compliant. Over his 20-year career in tax and regulatory automation, he has provided analysis to the Wall Street Journal, NBC, Bloomberg and more. Chuck has also been named to the Accounting Today list of Top 100 Most Influential People four times.
Share this post

North America Tax Information Reporting
March 22, 2024
Market Conduct Annual Statement Reminders and More

On the second Wednesday of each month, Sovos experts host a 30-minute webinar, Water Cooler Wednesday, to share the latest updates on statutory filings. In March, Sarah Stubbs shared information about the many filings due after March 1, from Market Conduct Annual Statements to health supplements for P&C and life insurers writing A&H businesses and […]

North America ShipCompliant
March 21, 2024
How Producers Can Build a DtC Shipping Market

Direct-to-consumer (DtC) shipping has become one of the leading sales models for businesses of all sizes and in all markets. The idea of connecting directly with consumers is notably attractive, as it helps brands develop a personal relationship and avoid costly distribution chains. Yet, for all its popularity, DtC is often a hard concept to […]

North America ShipCompliant
March 20, 2024
Key Findings from the 2024 DtC Beer Shipping Report

This March, Sovos ShipCompliant released the fourth annual Direct-to-Consumer Beer Shipping Report in partnership with the Brewers Association. The DtC beer shipping report features exclusive insights on the regulatory state of the direct-to-consumer (DtC) channel, Brewers Association’s perspective and key data from a consumer preferences survey. Let’s take a deeper dive into some of the […]

March 20, 2024
As the World Gets Smaller, Think Bigger About Global Tax Compliance

For the past few weeks back, my colleagues and I have been talking a lot about the importance of a global strategy when it comes to addressing today’s modern tax environments. On the heels of Sovos introducing the Sovos Compliance Cloud, many in our company’s leadership team have blogged about related topics and the critical […]

North America ShipCompliant
March 12, 2024
Florida HR 583 Set to Uncork Larger Format Wine Bottles

Florida wine lovers could soon enjoy a bigger selection of bottles based on a recent bill passed by the state’s legislature (HR 583) that would remove the existing cap on wine bottle sizes. What is Florida’s HR 583 bill? Currently, Florida law prohibits the sale of wine in bottles larger than one gallon (a little […]