Is Sales Tax Economic Nexus Simplification on the Horizon?

Alex Forbes
April 10, 2019

A topic of conversation on the recent Sovos and Deloitte Tax LLC webinar, “The Speed of Sales Tax – How to Stay Ahead of Changing Regulations in 2019,” was whether or not states will seek further economic nexus simplification.

State of sales tax economic nexus

Currently, there are 36 states enforcing sales tax economic nexus rules. While many of these states are streamlined sales tax (SST) states, a good number of them are not. Whether these non-SST states will be determined to create an undue burden still remains to be seen.

California began enforcement April 1, 2019, while Texas is holding out until October 2019. There are still eight states, including Arkansas [Update 4/12: Arkansas enacts economic nexus law], Arizona, Florida, Idaho, Kansas, Missouri, New Mexico and Virginia, without sales tax economic nexus rules. Those dominoes will fall eventually, whether this year or next, according to our webinar panel. For example, New Mexico House Bill 6 has been enacted and is scheduled to create economic nexus July 1, 2019. Virginia House Bill 1722, also scheduled to pass July 1, will create economic nexus there. Kanas, on the other hand, has a bill before the governor, but the panel is not confident it will have an economic nexus standard there in the immediate future, believing it will be vetoed.

In Missouri, a very complicated taxing jurisdiction, there are a number of bills currently being debated and the state may be working on something for this year, while Tennessee is still in litigation.

Remote seller nexus simplification on the horizon?

South Dakota created the standard of 200 transactions or $100,000 in gross sales as the barrier to trigger an economic nexus registration and collection requirement after the South Dakota v. Wayfair decision. Our panel reiterated that there’s no magic in those numbers, but when the first states started to enact an economic nexus standard, they used those same numbers, viewing them as a bit of a safe harbor even though they were never intended as one.

A few states that initially enacted a 200 transaction, $100,000 in gross sale threshold are in legislation this year looking to potentially change that threshold as they bolster their rules by statute. For example, California may be changing to a $500,000 threshold, while North Dakota and Washington are following a trend of eliminating the number of transactions threshold and going simply with a gross sale type standard.

When asked if the panel was seeing a trend of states eliminating the number of transactions when adopting Wayfair economic nexus rules, an example of where things become murky came readily to mind:

Not all states count the number of transactions and sales the same way. For most states, a gross sales number is used as a proxy for economic presence. Others will count only taxable sales, some just retail sales, which could create exclusions for a lot of companies. Kentucky counts sales of products and digital property but not necessarily services or anything else. Illinois counts product sales including exempt sales, but not exempt sales for resale.

Chuck Maniace, director of regulatory analysis, Sovos, sees this as a practical concern, meaning these states recognize that to register a taxpayer and to process their tax return every single month is not a completely substantial burden. They’re trying to exclude from this process those businesses that may technically have an obligation but may not be particularly fruitful in the amount of revenue they bring.

Washington state, where taxing is based on amounts of retail sales as part of legislation that eliminated the 200 transaction threshold, is going to be moving from gross receipts on retail sales to cumulative gross income on January 1, 2020.

For further details about remote seller nexus simplification, such as what Alabama, Colorado and Louisiana and doing, where there may be undue burden and places that are ripe for challenge, view the webinar recording and download the slides.

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.

Author

Alex Forbes

Alex Forbes is Senior Manager, Content Marketing, at Sovos. When not helping readers navigate their tax-related digital business transformation journeys, he enjoys day tripping around New England with his wife.
Share This Post

LATAM VAT & Fiscal Reporting
May 20, 2020
Sovos Acquires Taxweb, Extends Tax Determination Capabilities in World’s Most Challenging Compliance Landscape

Earlier this month Sovos announced its second acquisition of 2020, completing our solution for Brazil with an unparalleled offering that solves tax compliance in the place where it is most challenging to do so.  Too many companies doing business in Brazil have been burdened by managing multiple point solutions for continuous transaction controls (CTCs), tax […]

Asia Pacific E-Invoicing Compliance EMEA India
July 31, 2020
India: Last-Minute Changes to the Proposed E-Invoicing System

The October deadline is fast approaching for the Indian CTC invoicing mandate, but it remains a moving target. In a swift move that was published just two months prior to go-live, authorities have now changed the scope of who is affected by the reform, as well as updated the JSON format. Why the change? The […]

ShipCompliant United States
July 30, 2020
2020 DtC Wine Shipping Mid-Year Report

Since we released the annual Direct-to-Consumer Wine Shipping Report in partnership with Wines Vines Analytics back in January, a lot has changed when it comes to how consumers are getting their wine. The COVID-19 pandemic swayed buying channels drastically, shifting traditional retail and on-premise sales over to ecommerce sales. With brick-and-mortar retailers being closed down […]

EMEA IPT
July 30, 2020
Filing Premium Taxes When Non-Authorised Insurer

A non-authorised insurer is the term used to describe an insurance company that isn’t licensed with a particular country to provide insurance. This can also be known as non-admitted insurance. The non-authorised insurer doesn’t have to comply with local laws and regulations, however, one consequence of not being authorised means it doesn’t get the same […]

EMEA VAT & Fiscal Reporting
July 28, 2020
Building a VAT Roadmap for 2021 and Beyond

At a time when the global VAT landscape is undergoing significant change, we teamed up with Shared Services Link to understand more about the key challenges faced by AP and VAT professionals at multinational companies and what their focus is for 2021 and beyond. What remains clear is that pace of digital change is increasing […]

July 28, 2020
Sovos Buys Keane’s Unclaimed Property Consulting Services & Software as States Accelerate Audits

Last week, Sovos purchased the unclaimed property consulting services and reporting technology of Keane. This acquisition boosts our SaaS and services offerings for unclaimed property compliance — just as states are hungry for revenue streams to offset their budgetary gaps. This is a critical time for insurers, financial institutions and other companies facing compliance regulations […]