South Dakota vs. Wayfair – Answers to Your Online Sales Tax Questions

Alex Forbes
April 24, 2018

Last Tuesday, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in South Dakota vs. Wayfair which challenges a precedent most recently articulated in the 1992 case of Quill vs. North Dakota. Quill affirmed that a business must be physically present (loosely defined as people or property) in a state before it can be compelled to collect and remit sales and use tax in connection with mail order or internet sales made to its residents.

In the digital age, states have increasingly come to view the physical presence standard as an anachronism, whose continued existence stymies their ability to fund their government. South Dakota contend they are losing millions of dollars in sales tax revenue every year under Quill and researchers estimate $34 billion in revenues lost nationwide. Without a doubt,  there are some compelling arguments favoring an overturn.

South Dakota vs. Wayfair Oral Arguments – Insights to Glean

So what’s top of mind for the Justices? Based on their questions asked last Tuesday, the national impact of an overturn is clearly being considered as opposed to focusing exclusively on what would happen in South Dakota. The possibility of states retroactively pursuing sellers for back taxes, and the burden/benefit to small sellers is also top of mind.

Will states find themselves in a situation where they’d be able to enact a rule that imposes collection obligation on a seller based on a single sale, or will they be weighing their options on how to expand collection responsibilities within the confines of Quill? How might a decision this summer impact governments and businesses, and what should each be doing to prepare? Find out this and more, take action below!

Take Action

Join us on April 27th at 12:00 ET for a live Q&A interview with Chuck Maniace, Director of Regulatory Analysis at Sovos, about what the SD vs. Wayfair Court decision could mean for the future of sales tax and what it could mean for your business. Chuck is a lawyer by trade but promises to keep the legal jargon to a minimum in answering a few key questions, and addressing your specific concerns. Bring your questions! Save Your Seat.

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.


Alex Forbes

Alex Forbes is Senior Manager, Content Marketing, at Sovos. When not helping readers navigate their tax-related digital business transformation journeys, he enjoys day tripping around New England with his wife.
Share This Post

Sales & Use Tax United States
June 17, 2019
South Dakota v. Wayfair One Year Later – Retrospective and Look Ahead Webinar

Since the groundbreaking Supreme Court decision in South Dakota v. Wayfair last June, tax compliance requirements of sellers have undergone a seismic shift. In recent months, we have also witnessed a series of after-shocks directed at setting the foundation for U.S. sales tax compliance in the modern age. In a live webinar and Q&A, “South […]

United States
June 14, 2019
Sovos Again Named a Top Workplace Based on Employee Satisfaction

Earlier this week, the Star Tribune (Minneapolis, MN) released its annual list of Top Workplaces. The newspaper compiles this list based on employee satisfaction scores for companies across Minnesota. Sovos has once again been named to this list as a national standard setter of leading workplaces because of the actions we take to put employees […]

E-Invoicing Compliance EMEA
June 13, 2019
French VAT Fraud Prevention Package to Include a New Attempt to Mandate B2B E-invoicing

The French Minister of Public Accounts and Action, which has authority over all tax matters, has taken advantage of the process that is required to transpose the EU E-Commerce Directive to launch a number of initiatives to curb VAT fraud, including a renewed attempt to create a system of mandatory e-invoicing. Going from B2G to […]

June 13, 2019
Knowing When and How to Reclaim IPT

An insurer may need to reclaim insurance premium tax (IPT) from a tax authority for many reasons. These include a policy cancellation or mid-term adjustment, an administrative error or issuing a no claims bonus. In each case, it’s important to be aware of the issues involved ahead of any reclaim to ensure taxes are recovered […]

Sales & Use Tax United States
June 7, 2019
Marketplace Sales Tax Collection Rules and Current State of Affairs

Marketplace sales tax laws are being used by states as an additional means to collect more sales tax revenue from remote sellers on marketplaces like Amazon, eBay, Etsy, and WalMart. These online marketplaces and the rules being introduced to compel marketplace tax compliance have introduced new sales tax collection and remittance questions and complexity. According […]