60% of Filings Submitted to ‘Early Adopter’ Tax Jurisdictions for First CRS Exchange May be Rejected

Rob Dean
April 24, 2017

Sovos is predicting the majority of transmittals submitted by qualifying financial institutions to early adopter tax jurisdictions in the next two months may be rejected and returned for correction and resubmission. As a result, institutions may require several rounds of resubmissions before their data is accepted.

The majority of transmittals submitted by qualifying financial institutions to early adopter tax jurisdictions in the next two months may be rejected and returned for correction and resubmission, predicts Sovos, a global tax compliance solution provider. Some institutions may require several rounds of resubmissions before the respective authorities accept their data, thereby putting their compliance departments under considerable strain, Sovos suggests.

Twenty-nine tax jurisdictions have set deadlines in May and June. These are the dates by which financial institutions must submit data as part of the new Common Reporting Standard (CRS). The CRS will require all qualifying financial institutions to upload considerable volumes of information about their account holders to a new portal.

The UK is amongst the forty ‘early adopter’ countries and HMRC has set May 31 as its deadline.

The CRS is part of the OECD’s new automatic information of exchange (AEOI) regime designed to facilitate greater global tax transparency.

Sovos commissioned the Aberdeen Group to carry out a research study into FATCA filings made by financial institutions in the US last year. It found that only 44 per cent of filings submitted by the respondents were accurate and complete. Using this figure as a baseline, it predicts that only four in every ten transmittals for this year’s first CRS filing will be accurate (40 per cent).

The company points to five factors which it believes supports its prediction. These are:

  1. Volume of data

The volume of filings expected under CRS will be five times higher than under CDOT. Sovos believes this unprecedented number will put a significant number of financial institutions under considerable pressure to meet the deadline. It also questions whether HMRC’s new portal will be able to cope with the large number of financial institutions who are expected to upload their data at the last minute on the deadline date.

  1. Inconsistency across jurisdictions

Despite the OECD’s attempts to create a global standard for the automatic exchange of information (AEOI), a significant number of jurisdictions have introduced local variations or requested additional information. For example, India’s tax authorities have asked for the account holders’ parents’ dates of birth. This inconsistency has hindered financial  institutions in preparing for CRS.

  1. Lack of support received from jurisdictions

Sovos believes HMRC has provided a very high level of support to financial institutions, but this support varies dramatically across jurisdictions.

  1. Degree of subjectivity found in the OECD Schema

The OECD’s schema ‘carries a high degree of subjectivity’, according to Sovos, and this has meant financial institutions have had to seek guidance from the jurisdictions or their in-house legal teams or sought professional advice from other sources. This has further delayed their preparations.

  1. Level of technical expertise available to compliance departments

Compliance departments will be expected to upload considerable quantities of data to the new portals and Sovos believes the level of IT support they have received varies dramatically. Smaller financial institutions, in particular, are at risk of attracting penalties for non compliance as their IT resources are smaller than those found in large institutions.

Commenting on the company’s prediction, Scott Freedman, Director Product Strategy, said, “We have a full time staff of compliance attorneys constantly monitoring jurisdictional changes across the world and, on average, we are currently implementing over 10,000 tax rule changes to our products every month. This level of regulatory change is unprecedented.

“We are particularly concerned that the first major CRS filing deadlines in May and June will be challenging. Financial institutions which are relying on in-house tactical solutions may find CRS transmittals particularly difficult. The financial penalties and loss of reputation associated with non-compliance may motivate them to look at centralised automated solutions which offer more robust validation engines.”

Take Action

For more information on the Sovos AEOI Solution, click here.

To access the Sovos/Aberdeen report referenced, click here.

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.


Rob Dean

Robert Dean is the European Sales Engineer for Sovos’ AEOI products. He has an extension background in technology, working with large banks and financial institutions to help them test, validate and implement technology solutions that automate their AEOI reporting processes. Robert has an M.S. in IT and has held a number of senior IT and commercial roles.
Share This Post

United States
Marketplace Facilitators and Payment Processors – The New Taxpayers?

Marketplace Facilitators and Payment Processors Find Themselves in the Global Tax Compliance Crosshairs  While approaches may differ across the globe, one of the defining trends in indirect tax over the last few years has been the effort to expand the number of types of businesses responsible for collecting tax. However, one of the challenges associated […]

Tax Information Reporting United States
How to Respond to the Growing Challenges of 1099-R Reporting

The demographics don’t lie: Reporting for form 1099-R is only going to grow more difficult as baby boomers retire. The form used to report distributions from IRA, pensions, annuities and other similar retirement accounts is poised to explode in volume. As such, financial institutions (FIs) and insurance companies can’t afford to mishandle 1099-R reporting. The […]

E-Invoicing Compliance EMEA
Portugal Issues New E-Invoicing Rules: A Flavour of Clearance but Not Quite There

On 15 February 2019, Portugal published Decree-Law 28/2019 regarding the processing, archiving and dematerialization of invoices and other tax related documents including: The mandatory use of certified invoicing software General requirements for paper and electronic invoices Dematerialization of tax documentation Archiving of tax documentation (including ledgers, etc) Adjacent tax rules and obligations The decree aims […]

EMEA LATAM VAT & Fiscal Reporting
Are We in the Golden Age of VAT Recovery?

The value-added tax (“VAT”) was described in the EU as a “”money machine” over 20 years ago. Yet according to a 2015 study by the European Commission by the Centre for Social and Economic Research (CASE), the “VAT gap” was approximately 168 billion EUR. This represents 15 percent of the theoretical VAT that would be […]

Tax Information Reporting United States
As Legal Sports Gambling Grows, So Does Growth in W-2G Reporting

With the NCAA basketball tournament approaching, the US is gearing up for its biggest gambling weeks of the year. And while most “March Madness” pools might technically be illegal, legitimate sports betting is sweeping the US following last year’s landmark Supreme Court decision allowing states to legalize sports gambling in casinos.   As legal sports […]