Don’t Forget the SAP Configuration – Mexico CFDI PAC Strategies (Part 2 of 5)

Scott Lewin
August 2, 2013

In my previous article concerning Mexico CFDI electronic invoicing, we focused on the logistics and shipping aspects of the CFDI legislation. The lesson learned from that article was: the new laws affect your ability to ship, so make sure you don’t just contract with a single point of failure. Instead, ensure you have built-in contingency and a multi-PAC switch capability.

For today, we are going to focus on the ERP configuration – this is almost always forgotten or dramatically underestimated and is always the overwhelming cost of implementing, monitoring and maintaining as solution. Most PAC contracts you will findforce you to do the following:

  • Create the ERP extraction file
  • Map that file to a .txt or format that can easily be consumed by the PAC
  • Manage a communication engine such as SFTP to get the file to the PAC
  • Manage Addenda development and maitenance
  • Manage automating the printing
  • And manage the distribution to the end customer

The PAC – provides a signature leaving you responsible for all the other components. Companies who have been through this process before estimate that the ERP configuration is at least 80% of the total cost of implementing CFDI and if your solution provider is not doing this, then you or a systems integrator will be doing it for you. And they will be constantly adjusting this configuration as the laws evolve.

Classic SAP data extraction issues include but are not limited to:

Discounts – there is only one field on the Mexico XML

  • What if your customers wants to see the discount per line item on the PDF
  • Is a discount a percentage, a flat rate, or some arbitrary logic that is customer specific
  • Question – how many customers do you have, how many different pricing configurations do you have – all of this will be difficult to map into a rigid XML

Surcharge – The Mexico XML has no field for Surcharge

  • Most customers want this as a line item on the invoice – how do you manage just this one example of an “Extended Attribute”

Addenda creation and management

  • These are customer specific requests (for example Wal-Mart and VW). These are information requests and are not a legal requirement for the government validation. Instead, they are specific requirements for data used for Straight-Through Processing by the Buyer.
  • These also can change over time, so ensure you understand how these change management requests will be handled. In Mexico, you not only have to be concerned with government changes, but also the customer changes as well for your maintenance teams.

A common storyline I hear is: a company will look to the ERP vendor for a standard solution – unfortunately there is not one available nor is there one coming that will be easily implemented for a multinational.

Why? – First, many multinationals are not on the most up to date version of SAP. They run their OSS note applications only a few times a year. Getting a series of OSS notes that require a massive baseline upgrade is not something that is palatable for an SAP COE. Second, changes to the government regulations happen on a frequent basis without much advanced notice. It is not realistic to expect the ERP vendor to stay current with individual country changes. We see updates often released 12 months+ after the announcement of a new electronic invoicing requirement. Lastly, the addition of Addenda in the Mexico process compounds this issue even more.

In short, be sure your company has coordinated the evaluation of Mexico CFDI at both the local end user level and the SAP COE. Otherwise, you will be left with two separate projects, two separate solutions, two separate monitoring issues, and two separate ongoing maintenance issues. There are providers in the marketplace that solve both the SAP configuration issues as well as the government connectivity issues and they maintain all components throughout both customer changes and government changes.

Sign up for Email Updates

Stay up to date with the latest tax and compliance updates that may impact your business.


Scott Lewin

Gain timely insight and important up to the minute information about the current legislative changes in Latin America, including Brazil Nota Fiscal, Mexico CFDI, Argentina AFIP and Chile DTE. Learn how these changes affect your operations, your finances and also your Information Technology teams.
Share This Post

United States
June 14, 2019
Sovos Again Named a Top Workplace Based on Employee Satisfaction

Earlier this week, the Star Tribune (Minneapolis, MN) released its annual list of Top Workplaces. The newspaper compiles this list based on employee satisfaction scores for companies across Minnesota. Sovos has once again been named to this list as a national standard setter of leading workplaces because of the actions we take to put employees […]

E-Invoicing Compliance EMEA
June 13, 2019
French VAT Fraud Prevention Package to Include a New Attempt to Mandate B2B E-invoicing

The French Minister of Public Accounts and Action, which has authority over all tax matters, has taken advantage of the process that is required to transpose the EU E-Commerce Directive to launch a number of initiatives to curb VAT fraud, including a renewed attempt to create a system of mandatory e-invoicing. Going from B2G to […]

June 13, 2019
Knowing When and How to Reclaim IPT

An insurer may need to reclaim insurance premium tax (IPT) from a tax authority for many reasons. These include a policy cancellation or mid-term adjustment, an administrative error or issuing a no claims bonus. In each case, it’s important to be aware of the issues involved ahead of any reclaim to ensure taxes are recovered […]

Sales & Use Tax United States
June 7, 2019
Marketplace Sales Tax Collection Rules and Current State of Affairs

Marketplace sales tax laws are being used by states as an additional means to collect more sales tax revenue from remote sellers on marketplaces like Amazon, eBay, Etsy, and WalMart. These online marketplaces and the rules being introduced to compel marketplace tax compliance have introduced new sales tax collection and remittance questions and complexity. According […]

Tax Information Reporting United States
June 5, 2019
IRS Promises Clarity on Crypto Tax Regulations This Month

For the second time in the last month, the IRS has alluded to forthcoming guidance related to cryptocurrency and digital asset transactions.  IRS Commissioner Charles Rettig said in late May that clarification on crypto tax regulations might arrive by the end of June and gave further hints as to what might be included in the […]